Weird

What would Florida Man eat? This tiki bar says it involves a ‘special trailer sauce’

“The Florida Man” pizza at the World Famous Tiki Bar at Lighthouse Resort Inn & Suites in Fort Myers Beach is made with homemade “special Trailer Sauce” and is topped with fried gator and banana peppers.
“The Florida Man” pizza at the World Famous Tiki Bar at Lighthouse Resort Inn & Suites in Fort Myers Beach is made with homemade “special Trailer Sauce” and is topped with fried gator and banana peppers. Courtesy of Robert Reilly

People always say they want to eat like a king. But have you ever wanted to eat like Florida Man?

A tiki bar inside a Fort Myers Beach resort thinks you will — and it has the ingredients.

Meet “The Florida Man” pizza. It’s the ultimate challenge for foodies who want to say: “I Am Florida Man (or Woman).” And like its name suggests, the toppings are a bit wild and very, well, Florida:

Fried Gator. Banana Peppers. And a homemade “special Trailer Sauce” that’s a bit spicy. And orange.

Yummy?

Tiki bar General Manager Robert Reilly says it’s delicious. Locals and tourists that visit the World Famous Tiki Bar at Lighthouse Resort Inn & Suites, 10501 Fifth St. in Fort Myers Beach, seem to think so, too.

The pizza was added to the menu in March and has quickly become one of the tiki bar’s bestsellers, Reilly said.

“The Florida Man” pizza at the World Famous Tiki Bar at Lighthouse Resort Inn & Suites in Fort Myers Beach is made with homemade “special Trailer Sauce” and is topped with fried gator and banana peppers.
“The Florida Man” pizza at the World Famous Tiki Bar at Lighthouse Resort Inn & Suites in Fort Myers Beach is made with homemade “special Trailer Sauce” and is topped with fried gator and banana peppers. Courtesy of Robert Reilly

Why is the pizza named after Florida Man?

Reilly said they were planning to create a specialty pizza with gator, which is what tourists usually want to try when they visit Florida. At some point, he remembered the Florida Man Challenge (Google “Florida Man” followed by your birthday to see what you get). And because the tiki employees are “the funniest people in the world,” the name stuck, he said.

It was current. It was funny. And the pizza had gator.

“It was a golden opportunity,” Reilly said.

Is there a Florida-themed drink to go with it?

Not yet, but Reilly said they’re thinking about adding one. For now, he says people tend to enjoy the 12-inch or 16-inch pizza while relaxing by the pool with a “bucket” of rum and juice.

But how does the gator pizza taste?

Like Florida, we guess.

This story was originally published June 9, 2021 at 9:56 AM.

Related Stories from Miami Herald
Michelle Marchante
Miami Herald
Michelle Marchante covers the pulse of healthcare in South Florida and also the City of Coral Gables. Before that, she covered the COVID-19 pandemic, hurricanes, crime, education, entertainment and other topics in South Florida for the Herald as a breaking news reporter. She recently won first place in the health reporting category in the 2025 Sunshine State Awards for her coverage of Steward Health’s bankruptcy. An investigative series about the abrupt closure of a Miami heart transplant program led Michelle and her colleagues to be recognized as finalists in two 2024 Florida Sunshine State Award categories. She also won second place in the 73rd annual Green Eyeshade Awards for her consumer-focused healthcare stories and was part of the team of reporters who won a 2022 Pulitzer Prize for the Miami Herald’s breaking news coverage of the Surfside building collapse. Michelle graduated with honors from Florida International University and was a 2025 National Press Foundation Covering Workplace Mental Health fellow and a 2020-2021 Poynter-Koch Media & Journalism fellow.  Support my work with a digital subscription
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER