In usual self-sabotage, Florida Democrats argue over gubernatorial candidate | Opinion

The Democratic Party already has an uphill battle to retake the Florida governor’s office after more than 30 years of Republican dominance. Debating whether the party’s only main candidate so far is pure in his support for abortion rights seems like a waste of time for a party that hasn’t won any statewide elections in years.

And, yet, you can always count on liberals to shoot themselves in the foot with purity and ideological tests, as it’s happening with a debate surrounding David Jolly, the former Tampa-area Republican congressman who’s running for governor as a Democrat.

The infighting has been playing out this month on the opinion pages of the Miami Herald and elsewhere. It began with an op-ed by Anna Hochkammer, executive director of the Florida Women’s Freedom Coalition political committee, who urged Democratic voters to be skeptical about Jolly’s abortion stance.

Jolly, the son of a Baptist pastor, did cast anti-abortion votes when he was in Congress, including signing onto the Life at Conception Act that would have given full legal rights to a fertilized egg. He has said he’s evolved on the issue and now supports abortion up to the point of viability, usually at around 24 weeks of gestation, and is against onerous abortion regulations such as waiting periods and mandatory ultrasounds.

Many Democrats are upset by Hochkammer’s op-ed and her political committee’s fundraising calls on the topic — one them says, “We’re not going to let ‘moderate’ men like David Jolly posture as reasonable,” Politico reported. Party figures fear the controversy could motivate somebody else to jump in the Democratic primary and drag Jolly into a costly intra-party battle before the 2026 general elections happen.

The debate over Jolly’s support for abortion rights ignores that he still is vastly more supportive of reproductive rights than any Republican he’s likely to face if he’s the Democratic nominee in November 2026. U.S. Rep. Byron Donalds, whose gubernatorial bid has been endorsed by President Trump, supports banning abortions in most cases after six weeks, according to Politico.

A group of high-profile, pro-choice women from Miami and Florida penned an op-ed in response to Hochkammer. On Jolly’s evolution on abortion, they wrote: ...”when faced with the tangible and tragic harms resulting from restrictive abortion policies, his view changed,” and that he vowed to try to put into law Amendment 4, a ballot initiative that got over 57% voter support last year but failed to meet a 60% threshold for passage.

Abortion rights are obviously an important issue in Florida after Republicans passed an extreme six-week ban. But, as a political issue, Democrats learned last year that reproductive rights did not help them win seats as they expected. Trump carried Florida easily even though Amendment 4 got majority support.

Democrats, if they still have a chance to win a gubernatorial election in Florida — and that’s a big if — should focus on the issues that are top of mind for voters, mainly the state’s housing, affordability and property insurance crises, issues that Jolly’s campaign says he would focus on.

It’s clear that some Democratic heavyweights are trying to clear the field for Jolly and avoid a primary, something that could backfire if progressives feel party leaders are engaging in the type of kingmaking that cost Hillary Clinton support in 2016, when many felt the party sidelined U.S. Sen. Bernie Sanders.

A column posted on the Daily Kos website called Jolly “Charlie Crist 2.0” in reference to the former Republican-governor-turned Democrat who lost to Gov. Ron DeSantis in 2022 by a landslide and failed to motivate the Democratic base. The real problem isn’t Crist or Jolly, but the lack of a Democratic bench of strong candidates who can run statewide.

Republicans, on the other hand, have a vast roster of proven political candidates. There’s still the possibility of a bloody primary between Donalds and First Lady Casey DeSantis if she decides to run. But we know that, once a nominee is chosen, Republicans will fall in line, as they did when Trump became the presidential nominee in 2016.

As the underdog, the Florida Democratic Party has a lot more to lose by engaging in ideological fights with each other.

Click here to send the letter.