Recalls

43 ice cream bar flavors recalled throughout the Florida Keys after a state inspection

The label for Unicorn flavor ice cream bars from Paradise Flavors
The label for Unicorn flavor ice cream bars from Paradise Flavors FDA

Marathon’s Paradise Flavors finished rectifying all the problems found in a state inspection when it recalled all 43 flavors of its ice cream bars sold in stores, restaurants and gas stations throughout the Florida Keys.

Wednesday, the day before the everybody-out-of-the-pool recall, Paradise got a “Met Inspection Requirements” from Florida Department of Agriculture Inspector Manuel Uribe. Uribe’s original Sept. 26 inspection found Paradise “using a sanitizing agent not manufactured to be used on utensils and food contact surfaces,” not having hand sanitizer at one hand washing station and no way to dry damp, just-washed hands at another handwashing sink.

But, what perhaps cost Paradise most was Uribe noticing food misbranding, as in “various flavors of ice cream bars are missing ingredients and sub-ingredients” including allergens milk, peanuts, tree nuts, wheat, soy and food coloring additives.

That’s a dangerous omission — consequences uncomfortable to fatal — to someone with a milk allergy, peanut allergy, tree nut allergy, wheat allergy, soy allergy or a food coloring allergy.

Uribe brought a monsoon of 60 Stop Sale Orders down on the thousands of 4-ounce ice cream bars in the facility at 9601 Overseas Highway. Paradise issued the recall Thursday.

People who have the ice cream bars and no food allergies can carry on as normal. If there’s a chance the ice cream bars will be eaten by someone with a food allergy, return them to the store where they were bought or to Paradise for a full refund.

Here are the varieties and the undeclared food allergens.

SEVEN MILE DELUX: Milk.

The label for Paradise Flavors’ Seven Mile Delux ice cream bars
The label for Paradise Flavors’ Seven Mile Delux ice cream bars FDA

UNICORN: Milk and food coloring.

The label for Unicorn flavor ice cream bars from Paradise Flavors
The label for Unicorn flavor ice cream bars from Paradise Flavors FDA

MINT CHOCOLATE CHIP: Milk and food coloring

GUAVA JELLY: Milk and food coloring.

VANILLA: Milk and food coloring.

BUTTER PECAN: Milk, tree nuts and food coloring.

PINK GUABA: Milk and food coloring.

The label for Pink Guaba flavored ice cream bars from Paradise Flavors.
The label for Pink Guaba flavored ice cream bars from Paradise Flavors. FDA

CAPPUCCINO: Milk.

SWEET CORN: Milk and food coloring.

PINA COLADA: Milk, tree nut and food coloring.

STRAWBERRIES AND CREAM: Milk.

RUM RAISIN: Milk and food coloring.

STRAWBERRY DELUX: Milk.

TRAIL MIX: Milk, peanuts, tree nuts, and soy.

BANANA BREAD: Milk, wheat, peanuts, tree nuts and soy.

PISTACHIO: Milk, tree nuts and food coloring.

KEY LIME CREAMCYCLE: Milk and food coloring.

CHOCOLATE RAZZBERRY CAKE/GANCITO: Milk, wheat, peanuts and food coloring.

The label for Chocolate Razzberry Cake flavored ice cream bars from Paradise Flavors
The label for Chocolate Razzberry Cake flavored ice cream bars from Paradise Flavors FDA

RICE PUDDING/ARROZ CON LECHE: Milk.

MAMEY: Milk.

YOUGURT WITH FRUITS: Milk, wheat, peanuts, tree nuts and soy.

FLORIDA SUNRISE: Milk and food coloring.

DULCE DE LECHE: Milk and food coloring.

CHOCOLATE WITH ALMONDS: Milk, peanuts, tree nuts and soy.

FERRERO ROCHER: Milk, tree nuts, peanuts, wheat and soy.

BLACKBERRY CHEESECAKE: Milk, wheat, soy.

SWEET AND CONDENSED MILK: Milk.

PINE NUT: Milk, tree nut, soy, and wheat.

PEANUT BUTTER: Milk, wheat, peanut and soy

COOKIES AND CREAM: Milk, soy, and wheat.

PASSION FRUIT DELUX: Milk.

MAMEY WITH SWEET AND CONDENSED MILK: Milk and food coloring.

MAGNUM: Milk, tree nuts, peanuts, soy and food coloring.

EZQUIMAL: Milk, tree nuts, peanuts, soy, food coloring.

CHOCOLATE: Milk and soy.

AVOCADO: Milk and food coloring.

COCONUT: Milk and tree nut.

KEY LIME PIE: Milk, wheat, soy and food coloring.

CHUNKY MANGO: Milk and food coloring.

SOURSOP/GUANABANA: Milk.

ORANGE CREAMCYCLE: Milk and food coloring.

BUBBLEGUM GUMMYBEARS: Milk, tree nuts and food coloring.

COTTON CANDY: Milk, peanuts, soy and food coloring.

Questions about this recall or food allergy matters with the ice cream bars can be answered (or at least fielded) by Paradise Flavors at 305-509-0112, every day,11 a.m. to 6 p.m., Eastern time.

David J. Neal
Miami Herald
Since 1989, David J. Neal’s domain at the Miami Herald has expanded to include writing about Panthers (NHL and FIU), Dolphins, old school animation, food safety, fraud, naughty lawyers, bad doctors and all manner of breaking news. He drinks coladas whole. He does not work Indianapolis 500 Race Day.
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER