After two years of investigations and scandal, David Rivera may owe his collapse at the polls on Tuesday as much to the changing politics of his newly created congressional district as to the crippling weight of humiliating headlines.
Rivera, a Republican, lost his congressional seat in an 11-point loss to Democrat Joe Garcia, whom Rivera had beaten to win the seat in 2010. Rivera has been hounded by criminal investigations since before he took office, hobbling his once-formidable fundraising and leaving him adrift in his own party.
Rivera says he lost the race not because of the press reports of the criminal investigations — probes whose very existence he once denied — but because of an unexpected wave of support for President Barack Obama, and weaker turnout for Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney.
“I think an analysis of the results demonstrates that the presidential election had a significant impact on several congressional races, including my own,” Rivera said Wednesday. “It makes it tough for Republicans down ballot to be successful.”
Premium content for only $0.99
For the most comprehensive local coverage, subscribe today.
Rivera also may have been undone in part by a changing climate in his own congressional district, which was redrawn by the Legislature earlier this year.
The new district, which stretches from Sweetwater through the southwestern suburbs of Miami-Dade to the Keys, is not as heavily Republican as the district that Rivera won in 2010. And a late Democratic voter registration push by the Obama campaign made the district even more difficult to hold.
Between June 1 and Nov. 1, more than 8,600 new Democratic voters in Miami-Dade were added to the district, outpacing new GOP voters, records show. Democrats now have a slight registration advantage in the district.
“This is becoming a Democratic district. This is a district that’s trending away from them,” said Jeffrey Garcia, a campaign consultant for Joe Garcia. (The two are not related.)
Citing an internal exit poll, Jeffrey Garcia said Joe Garcia soundly defeated Rivera among independent voters, and Garcia performed better than expected among Cuban American voters — Rivera’s longtime political base.
Rivera carried most of the precincts in the Sweetwater area, while Garcia won in much of Kendall and the Homestead area. In one Richmond Heights precinct, Garcia received 938 votes, compared to just 32 for Rivera. Garcia also carried Monroe County.
With the victory, Garcia becomes the first Cuban-American Democrat from Florida in Congress. Unlike Rivera and the other two Miami Republicans in Congress, Reps. Mario Diaz-Balart and Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, Garcia favors family travel and remittances to Cuba.
In his remarks to supporters Wednesday, Garcia said he hopes to work with Ros-Lehtinen and Diaz-Balart.
“We may be from different parties, but I respect them,” he said.
Speaking on Spanish language-radio Wednesday morning, Ros-Lehtinen said “things are going to work out fine” with Garcia in Congress, despite their differences over Cuba policy. The GOP maintained control of the U.S. House of Representatives.
Tuesday’s loss was the first election defeat for Rivera, the one-time leader of Miami-Dade’s Republican Party and a former state lawmaker whose influence and popularity withered under a series of criminal investigations and a scathing ethics probe.
Rivera, 47, worked in the 1990s for the U.S. Information Agency, the department that oversaw Radio and TV Martí. In 1996, he served as the South Florida campaign manager for the presidential campaign of Republican Sen. Bob Dole.
Rivera was first elected to the Florida House of Representatives in 2002, and he rose to become a top lieutenant to then-Speaker Marco Rubio, Rivera’s longtime friend and Tallahassee roommate. He served eight years in the Legislature without opposition before making a run for Congress in 2010 with the retirement of Rep. Lincoln Diaz-Balart.
But the high-profile congressional campaign brought increased scrutiny of Rivera’s finances.
In October 2010, The Miami Herald reported that Rivera had never worked for the U.S. Agency for International Development, as he claimed in several years of financial disclosure forms, and that he paid campaign funds to a company founded by his mother. Rivera insists that he worked for a USAID vendor, but he has refused to name the company, which investigators never could find.
The Florida Department of Law Enforcement then launched a probe of a secret $1 million consulting deal between Rivera and the Flagler Dog Track to run a campaign to win voter approval for slot machines in Miami-Dade. The investigation expanded to focus on Rivera’s campaign accounts, which often were used to pay expenses on his personal credit cards.
Miami-Dade prosecutors ultimately determined that the statute of limitations had lapsed on many potential charges, and weaknesses in campaign finance laws made prosecution difficult. But the FBI and the Internal Revenue Service are now investigating whether Rivera should have paid taxes on the money from the dog track deal.
In late October, the state Ethics Commission charged Rivera with 11 ethics violations stemming from the dog-track contract and his use of campaign funds.
The FBI is also investigating whether Rivera secretly financed an opponent of Garcia’s in the Democratic primary, potentially violating campaign-finance laws. Witnesses have told investigators and The Herald that Rivera steered thousands of dollars in cash to pay for mailers and campaign material for Justin Lamar Sternad, a first-time candidate who reported only $505 in campaign contributions.
Rivera has denied wrongdoing, and during the home stretch of the campaign he insisted that the FBI probe was an invention of The Miami Herald and El Nuevo Herald.
Rivera said Wednesday that he had made no decisions on what he would do once he leaves public office.
“I’m going to get with my family and friends and supporters and discuss how I can best continue to contribute to our community’s best interests, whether that be in public office or out of public office,” he said. “Time will tell.”