Miami Herald Logo

Bin Laden driver’s conviction reversed by court | Miami Herald

×
  • E-edition
  • Home
    • Site Information
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • Herald Store
    • RSS Feeds
    • Special Sections
    • Advertise
    • Advertise with Us
    • Media Kit
    • Mobile
    • Mobile Apps & eReaders
    • Newsletters
    • Social
    • Facebook
    • Twitter
    • Google+
    • Instagram
    • YouTube

    • Sections
    • News
    • South Florida
    • Miami-Dade
    • Broward
    • Florida Keys
    • Florida
    • Politics
    • Weird News
    • Weather
    • National & World
    • Colombia
    • National
    • World
    • Americas
    • Cuba
    • Guantánamo
    • Haiti
    • Venezuela
    • Local Issues
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Environment
    • Health Care
    • In Depth
    • Issues & Ideas
    • Traffic
    • Sections
    • Sports
    • Blogs & Columnists
    • Pro & College
    • Miami Dolphins
    • Miami Heat
    • Miami Marlins
    • Florida Panthers
    • College Sports
    • University of Miami
    • Florida International
    • University of Florida
    • Florida State University
    • More Sports
    • High School Sports
    • Auto Racing
    • Fighting
    • Golf
    • Horse Racing
    • Outdoors
    • Soccer
    • Tennis
    • Youth Sports
    • Other Sports
    • Politics
    • Elections
    • The Florida Influencer Series
    • Sections
    • Business
    • Business Monday
    • Banking
    • International Business
    • National Business
    • Personal Finance
    • Real Estate News
    • Small Business
    • Technology
    • Tourism & Cruises
    • Workplace
    • Business Plan Challenge
    • Blogs & Columnists
    • Cindy Krischer Goodman
    • The Starting Gate
    • Work/Life Balancing Act
    • Movers
    • Sections
    • Living
    • Advice
    • Fashion
    • Food & Drink
    • Health & Fitness
    • Home & Garden
    • Pets
    • Recipes
    • Travel
    • Wine
    • Blogs & Columnists
    • Dave Barry
    • Ana Veciana-Suarez
    • Flashback Miami
    • More Living
    • LGBTQ South Florida
    • Palette Magazine
    • Indulge Magazine
    • South Florida Album
    • Broward Album
    • Sections
    • Entertainment
    • Books
    • Comics
    • Games & Puzzles
    • Horoscopes
    • Movies
    • Music & Nightlife
    • People
    • Performing Arts
    • Restaurants
    • TV
    • Visual Arts
    • Blogs & Columnists
    • Jose Lambiet
    • Lesley Abravanel
    • More Entertainment
    • Events Calendar
    • Miami.com
    • Contests & Promotions
    • Sections
    • All Opinion
    • Editorials
    • Op-Ed
    • Editorial Cartoons
    • Jim Morin
    • Letters to the Editor
    • From Our Inbox
    • Speak Up
    • Submit a Letter
    • Meet the Editorial Board
    • Influencers Opinion
    • Blogs & Columnists
    • Blog Directory
    • Columnist Directory
    • Andres Oppenheimer
    • Carl Hiaasen
    • Leonard Pitts Jr.
    • Fabiola Santiago
    • Obituaries
    • Obituaries in the News
    • Place an Obituary

    • Place an ad
    • All Classifieds
    • Announcements
    • Apartments
    • Auctions/Sales
    • Automotive
    • Commercial Real Estate
    • Employment
    • Garage Sales
    • Legals
    • Merchandise
    • Obituaries
    • Pets
    • Public Notices
    • Real Estate
    • Services
  • Public Notices
  • Cars
  • Jobs
  • Moonlighting
  • Real Estate
  • Mobile & Apps

  • el Nuevo Herald
  • Miami.com
  • Indulge

Guantánamo

Bin Laden driver’s conviction reversed by court

By Lindsay Wise and Carol Rosenberg

    ORDER REPRINT →

October 17, 2012 06:52 AM

A federal appeals court’s decision to toss the conviction of Osama bin Laden’s former driver could have implications for future prosecutions of terrorism suspects.

The driver, Salim Ahmed Hamdan, was detained by U.S. troops in Afghanistan in November 2001 and sent to Guantánamo. In the first U.S. military war crimes trial since World War II, a jury of six military officers found Hamdan guilty in 2008 of providing material support to terrorism and sentenced him to 5 1/2 years in prison.

But the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia on Tuesday threw out that conviction, stating in a 3-0 decision that material support for terrorism was not proscribed as an international war crime until Congress passed the Military Commissions Act in 2006. Since Hamdan worked for bin Laden from 1996 to 2001, he cannot be punished retroactively, the court concluded.

“Indeed the Executive Branch acknowledges that the international law of war did not — and still does not — identify material support for terrorism as a war crime,” wrote Judge Brett Kavanaugh.

Sign Up and Save

Get six months of free digital access to the Miami Herald

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

#ReadLocal

“If the government wanted to charge Hamdan with aiding and abetting terrorism or some other war crime that was sufficiently rooted in the international law of war at the time of Hamdan’s conduct, it should have done so,” Kavanaugh wrote.

Hamdan’s legal vindication is the latest challenge to the controversial war courts set up by President George W. Bush’s administration after the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. The Yemeni driver also was at the center of a landmark 2006 Supreme Court case that struck down the war courts as unconstitutional, forcing the Bush administration to revise the system and try again.

Tuesday’s decision dealt another blow to the war courts by upending material support for terrorism as an offense triable by military commission.

Hamdan’s attorney, Joe McMillan, a lawyer with Seattle-based Perkins Coie, said he regards the ruling as a victory for the American justice system.

“We see it as an important statement that the U.S. must conform to the rule of law as it goes forward, even in times of perceived national emergency,” McMillan said.

Although the ruling will help clear his client’s name, it’s probably more important to the American legal tradition than to Hamdan, he said. “It’s long been deemed unjust to hold a person criminally liable for conduct that was not recognized as criminal at the time it occurred,” he said.

The decision is likely to be reviewed by the Supreme Court, even though the nation’s highest court has been reluctant to review Guantánamo detainee cases in recent years, said Eugene R. Fidell, who teaches military justice at Yale Law School.

“Above all, the decision shows how important it is to have civilian courts review decisions of the military commission and the Court of Military Commission Review,” Fidell said. “The fact that the decision overturns a commission case demonstrates that the regular federal courts can be a bulwark against government overreaching.”

The decision also is significant in its rejection of Congress’ claim that material support for terrorism was an offense under the law of nations even before the Military Commissions Act of 2006, he said.

“If and when the Supreme Court considers the case, we will know more about the interplay between the legislative and judicial branches in determining what is and what is not forbidden by the law of nations,” Fidell said.

The charge of material support of terrorism is the linchpin of many cases against people accused of acting as lower-level operatives for al-Qaida and other terrorist organizations. One alternative is to charge them with aiding the enemy. Prosecutors also could attempt to charge them with conspiracy, which is harder to prove because it requires evidence of knowledge and consent. The military jury acquitted Hamdan of conspiracy in 2008.

Hamdan was born in Khoreiba, Yemen, in 1968. Osama bin Laden hired him as a personal driver in Afghanistan in 1996, according to an affidavit Hamdan submitted about his work history. After his capture in Afghanistan, Hamdan arrived in Guantánamo in 2002.

He was first charged in July 2004, but a federal judge in Washington halted the trial. In June 2006, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Hamdan v. Rumsfeld that the war courts set up the Bush administration were unconstitutional and violated the Geneva Conventions as well as military law.

The original charges against Hamdan were dropped. The government filed new ones in May 2007, after Congress passed the Military Commissions Act and Bush signed it into law.

On Aug. 6, 2008, a military panel at Guantánamo convicted Hamdan of providing material support for terrorism. At trial, there was no evidence that Hamdan knew in advance of the 9/11 attacks, but that he had heard bin Laden discuss them afterward.

Hamdan was given credit for time served and transferred to Yemen to complete his sentence. He was released in January 2009. A father of four, he now works as a taxi driver.

Contacted in Yemen on Tuesday, Hamdan declined to comment, citing legal advice.

Rosenberg, a Miami Herald staff writer, reported from Guantánamo Bay, Cuba. Adam Baron contributed from Yemen.

  Comments  

Videos

Guantánamo Bay naval station holds ‘We Will Never Forget’ 9.11 km memorial run

US military adjusts for Ramadan at Guantánamo

View More Video

Trending Stories

It’s not so hard for an immigrant to become a U.S. citizen. Here’s what you have to do

February 20, 2019 01:20 PM

Think Florida is a ‘sinful’ place to live? You’re right, according to this new study

February 20, 2019 01:18 PM

Americans arrested in Haiti driving around with an arsenal are flown to the U.S.

February 20, 2019 06:54 PM

Cuts are coming for Dolphins’ receivers, but there’s one their new coach raves about

February 19, 2019 12:31 PM

Here are two young players the new Dolphins staff really likes. And two issues looming

February 20, 2019 04:00 PM

Read Next

Why is Guantánamo seeking a wheelchair-accessible three-cell compound? Contingencies.
Video media Created with Sketch.

Guantánamo

Why is Guantánamo seeking a wheelchair-accessible three-cell compound? Contingencies.

By Carol Rosenberg

    ORDER REPRINT →

February 08, 2019 05:34 PM

In the same week the Pentagon said Guantánamo is still an option for ISIS prisoners in Syria, the war-on-terror prison seeks contractors to bid for a three-cell, ADA-approved compound. Price tag? Unknown.

KEEP READING

Sign Up and Save

#ReadLocal

Get six months of free digital access to the Miami Herald

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

MORE GUANTÁNAMO

U.S.: Guantánamo still an option for ISIS captives in Syria who can’t go home

Guantánamo

U.S.: Guantánamo still an option for ISIS captives in Syria who can’t go home

February 06, 2019 06:37 PM
Sept. 11 trial judge cancels Guantánamo hearing, is airlifted to US for emergency eye surgery

Guantánamo

Sept. 11 trial judge cancels Guantánamo hearing, is airlifted to US for emergency eye surgery

January 29, 2019 07:10 PM
Sept. 11 defense lawyers threaten hearing boycott over FBI interview of paralegal

Guantánamo

Sept. 11 defense lawyers threaten hearing boycott over FBI interview of paralegal

January 28, 2019 03:41 PM
Military judge schedules February 2020 for next war crimes trial at Guantánamo

Guantánamo

Military judge schedules February 2020 for next war crimes trial at Guantánamo

January 24, 2019 02:09 PM
GOP Senators urge Trump to send Islamic State prisoners captured in Syria to Guantánamo

Guantánamo

GOP Senators urge Trump to send Islamic State prisoners captured in Syria to Guantánamo

January 23, 2019 11:46 AM
Pentagon shipping jumbo cell to Guantánamo court for al-Qaida trial from hospital bed

Guantánamo

Pentagon shipping jumbo cell to Guantánamo court for al-Qaida trial from hospital bed

January 14, 2019 09:40 AM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

Miami Herald App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Start a Subscription
  • Customer Service
  • eEdition
  • Vacation Hold
  • Pay Your Bill
  • Rewards
Learn More
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletters
  • News in Education
  • Public Insight Network
  • Reader Panel
Advertising
  • Place a Classified
  • Media Kit
  • Commercial Printing
  • Public Notices
Copyright
Commenting Policy
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service


Back to Story