Crime

For 24 years, she had no name. Investigators now focused on finding her killer

A police sketch of Eileen Truppner is next to a photo of her. Truppner was found sexually assaulted and murdered in a grassy area of southwest Broward in 1998.
A police sketch of Eileen Truppner is next to a photo of her. Truppner was found sexually assaulted and murdered in a grassy area of southwest Broward in 1998. Broward Sheriff's Office

For more than two decades, she was the face of a police sketch Now, Broward detectives have a name for the woman, who was found sexually assaulted and murdered in 1998, the Broward Sheriff’s Office said Thursday.

Eileen Truppner’s body was discovered by a boater on a weekend family outing in a grassy area off U.S. 27 in southwest Broward in December 1998. Investigators believe she died by strangulation no more than three days before she was found.

Identifying Truppner is only the first mystery Broward detectives solved. They’re now focused on finding her killer.

A screenshot from a video showing a photo of Eileen Truppner.
A screenshot from a video showing a photo of Eileen Truppner. Broward Sheriff's Office

DNA cracks the case

DNA was instrumental to Truppner’s identification. The Broward Sheriff’s Office worked with the Florida Department of Law Enforcement’s genetic genealogy unit to track the victim’s family tree.

That’s when genealogy led them to three sisters, one of whom vanished in the late ‘90s. BSO Cold Case Homicide Detective Zack Scott then prepared to break the news to Truppner’s family.

“The upside is you’re able to give them some answers,” Scott said in a video. “The downside is that you have to tell them: ‘Listen, she was the victim of a murder.’ It’s certainly not the outcome that they wanted.”

A screenshot from a video showing a photo of Eileen Truppner.
A screenshot from a video showing a photo of Eileen Truppner. Broward Sheriff's Office

When Nancy Truppner received Scott’s call, she thought her sister was finally found and her decades in anguish would be over. But hearing about her sister’s fate broke her.

“The way she died, when she was a kind person,” Nancy, in tears, said in a video. “She was so good, and she died the way she died. She did not deserve that.”

Years before her murder, Truppner, a mother of two, moved to South Florida from her native Puerto Rico. Though she had struggles, Truppner remained hopeful, Nancy said.

A screenshot from a video showing a photo of Eileen Truppner with sister Nancy Truppner.
A screenshot from a video showing a photo of Eileen Truppner with sister Nancy Truppner. Broward Sheriff's Office

That’s why it was a shock for the family when Truppner vanished in 1998. The last time Nancy heard from her was August that year, the month she vanished, prompting the family to hire a private investigator to track her down.

The hunt for justice

Scott said he has narrowed in on several leads — including a potential suspect — and now needs to connect that suspect to Truppner. At this point, the investigation is focused on piecing together a timeline.

A screenshot from a video showing the clothing that Eileen Truppner was wearing when she was found murdered in 1998.
A screenshot from a video showing the clothing that Eileen Truppner was wearing when she was found murdered in 1998. Broward Sheriff's Office

Broward detectives are urging people who knew Truppner or came across her from August to December 1998 to come forward.

“If they can tell us anything about her life during that four-month period, no matter how insignificant they may think it is, it could be what we’re looking for to kind of connect the dots...”

A screenshot from a video showing a photo of Eileen Truppner.
A screenshot from a video showing a photo of Eileen Truppner. Broward Sheriff's Office

Anyone with information about Eileen Truppner’s murder should to contact Det. Zack Scott at 954-321-4214 or Broward Crime Stoppers at 954-493-TIPS (8477).

Grethel Aguila
Miami Herald
Grethel covers courts and the criminal justice system for the Miami Herald. She graduated from the University of Florida (Go Gators!), speaks Spanish and Arabic and loves animals, traveling, basketball and good storytelling. Grethel also attends law school part time.
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER