Bodies, over time, break down. But four decades after the NFL’s only undefeated season, the perfect Dolphins lay claim to a legacy that has only strengthened by the year.
Their unequaled excellence, the members of the 1972 Dolphins hold sacrosanct. Some even celebrate with champagne when the last undefeated NFL team of the year falls, preserving their singular history.
Critics have called them petty, but Don Shula — the iconic coach —says that misses the point. It’s simply a source of pride.
“If somebody else does it — we’re not a bunch of angry old guys wishing they get beat — I’ll call that coach and congratulate him,” Shula said.
Premium content for only $0.99
For the most comprehensive local coverage, subscribe today.
Until then, the bragging rights are theirs alone. This weekend, when some three-dozen players on the fabled 1972 Dolphins return to South Florida their 40th reunion celebration, the itinerary is loaded.
There will be dinners and parties, a halftime salute Sunday and even the premiere of a new documentary on the team’s impact on Miami.
Defined by perfection, their bond has survived near-tragedies, creaking joints but remarkably few deaths.
Only six have passed since the Dolphins beat the Washington Redskins 14-7 on Jan. 14, 1973, in just the seventh Super Bowl ever played. The most notable death was the beloved Jim “Mad Dog” Mandich, the tight end-turned-radio personality who in April 2011 lost a public battle with cancer. As for those still with us, they are in surprisingly good shape.
Granted, Father Time — and the accumulative trauma from playing professional football — has taken its toll. Defensive lineman Manny Fernandez, now 66, recently had his second back fusion in three months, one of his 15 football-related surgeries.
Earl Morrall, who before he was the mayor of Davie was the Dolphins’ backup quarterback, is just four years younger than his Hall of Fame coach (Shula turns 83 next month). And while his body has noticeably weakened with years, Morrall still insisted on spending the weekend with his old friends.
“Even today, they’re still heckling each other and having fun,” said Nat Moore a former Dolphins player who now oversees their alumni association.
“The fact that [defensive end] Bill Stanfill still likes to get on Earl Morrall about being old, he couldn’t hear and all that. I just think they were a unique group that didn’t have any petty jealousy.”
A unique group, with some unique personalities.
Fullback Larry Csonka is in town from Alaska, where he’s an avid hunter and fisherman, often filming his exploits for cable television. His extreme lifestyle nearly caught up with him in 2005, when his boat capsized during a storm in the chilly Bering Sea. Ten hours later, the Coast Guard was finally able to save Csonka and his crew.
Like Morrall, Dick Anderson went into politics after football. When he wasn’t running several businesses, including the 1972 team’s memorabilia company (in which each player has a share), Anderson got elected to the Florida Senate.
When asked which of his professions was the most cutthroat, Anderson didn’t even pause.
“Politics,” he said. “You can’t trust the people who say something to you.”
Quarterback Bob Griese has been the most ubiquitous of the group, following up his Hall of Fame playing career with a long stint in the broadcast booth. His son, Brian, went into the family business; he was a quarterback in the league for 11 seasons.
Like Griese, Nick Buoniconti is a Hall of Famer who made a second career in television, appearing on the long-running series Inside the NFL. But that’s only a fraction of his story.
His son Marc is paralyzed from the neck down, from making a tackle for The Citadel in 1985. That tragedy inspired Nick to create the Miami Project to Cure Paralysis, an acclaimed research center at the University of Miami’s Miller School of Medicine.
Hardship also helped make Eugene “Mercury” Morris a crusader. The Dolphins’ running back served three years in prison after pleading guilty to selling cocaine to an undercover federal agent in 1982. Upon his release, Morris barnstormed the country, warning people of the perils of drugs.
These days, he’s best known as the go-to-Dolphin for media types needing a clever sound bite about the latest undefeated team closing in on perfection.
During the Patriots’ undefeated run through the 2007 regular season (they ultimately lost in the Super Bowl), Morris infamously quipped: “Don’t call me when you’re in my town, call me when you’re on my block and I see you next door moving your furniture in.”
Morris’ outspoken defense of his team’s uniqueness rubbed plenty the wrong way. But years later, he hasn’t softened one bit.
“The great pleasure I have is in knowing, when the time was for us to have the uniforms on that they have on now, we did more in a short span of time than anybody has ever done,” Morris said in September.
Then there’s Henry Stuckey, who’s on the opposite end of the attention-seeking spectrum. The little-used defensive back essentially vanished after his 1976 retirement. He hasn’t participated in any of the alumni events over the years, despite Moore’s best efforts to track him down.
Turns out, Stuckey is a retired casino worker living in Atlantic City, N.J. The Miami Herald reached him by phone last week, and convinced him to give his first interview in years.
“I do regret not seeing the old fellas, but I’ve moved on,” said Stuckey, who isn’t attending this weekend’s bonanza and keeps his Super Bowl memories, and ring, tucked away.
“I’m not trying to say people are jealous or don’t understand, but how can I wear my Super Bowl ring walking around Atlantic City? It’s like walking around Oakland (Stuckey’s hometown).”
There was no shortage of sparkle Thursday at the Dolphins’ training facility. Ten of the team’s more than three-dozen living members gathered to kick off the weekend, and each flashed their hard-earned championship ring for the cameras.
Griese and Anderson were there. So were Bob Kuechenberg and Larry Little, offensive linemen who opened those gaping holes for Morris, Csonka and Jim Kiick.
They couldn’t stay long; Coach was waiting. Shula had the team over to his home Thursday night. A banquet was held Friday, and Saturday afternoon, the graying icons attended the premiere of More Than Perfect, billed as the untold story of 1972 Dolphins. The film is coming soon to the NFL Network.
“Forty is a big number,” Kuechenberg said. “It’s not 50. But I don’t know how many will be here at 50.”
Added Fernandez: “They’re becoming more special because of our age. It didn’t initially start that way, but it does seem that every reunion we lose another player, another member of the family. I’m not keeping score. It’s something we do think about.”