Makeup should highlight your natural beauty while using natural ingredients which is why we wanted to find the best organic eyeshadow on Amazon. Eyeshadows can contain ingredients that do damage to the skin; we make sure that these eyeshadows are free from petroleum, silicone, and phthalates so that they are gentle on your skin.
Although these products are organic and natural, they are also affordable so you won’t have to overpay for makeup that is best for your health.
Our Top Picks for 2024
- Best Overall: ONLYBETTER Vegan Organic Eyeshadow Palette
- Best for Skin Protection: Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Pressed Organic Eyeshadow Duo
- Best Budget: ATHR Organic Moonlight Crystal Eyeshadow Palette
- Best Single Color: Giselle Cosmetics Organic Makeup
- Best Color Options: BaeBlu Hypoallergenic Organic Eyeshadow
- Best for Sensitive Skin: Harvest Natural Beauty Organic Eyeshadow
- Best Nude Colors: Physicians Formula Eyeshadow Palette
- Best Consciously Crafted: Honeybee Gardens Nude Renaissance Refillable Eyeshadow
- Best for Everyday Look: Pacifica 10-Shade Pink Nude Mineral Eyeshadow
- Best Versatile Powder: Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Natural Powder Eye Color
- Best Compact: INIKA Organic Quad Eyeshadow Palette
- Best to Spoil Yourself: ATHR Crystal Eyeshadow
Best Overall: ONLYBETTER Vegan Organic Eyeshadow Palette
Key Specs
- 16 Colors
- Waterproof
- Portable
- Matte/Shimmer/Natural Finish
What We Love About It
With 16 different colors in a portable palette, this eyeshadow is the best organic eyeshadow overall. It not only has vibrant shades so you can mix and match, but it also is waterproof. The ingredients are 88% organic and are completely vegan as well so this makes for the perfect gift for a vegan friend or a great purchase for yourself if you are vegan.
We love how easy it is to apply and with the magnetic lid and built-in mirror, this organic matte eyeshadow palette is great for on-the-go or in the car. Because it is made of natural plant extracts, it is safe on your skin but still delivers bold colors and comes in 3 main palette choices.
Best for Skin Protection: Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Pressed Organic Eyeshadow Duo
Key Specs
- Powder
- Cappuccino/Pearl and 10 Other Color Combinations
- Shimmery/Metallic Finish
What We Love About It
With 11 available color palettes, this eyeshadow duo from Lauren Brooke will be able to match various shades and skiing types. We find this to be the best organic eyeshadow for skin protection because it contains organic jojoba, orange peel wax, zinc, and other minerals that hydrate and nourish the skin, providing daily protection from the elements.
We also love that this restores the skin with ingredients that are 100% natural and 88.3% organic. This is certified safe and humane by Leaping Bunny and PETA’s Beauty Without Bunnies Programs. The colors are also rich and blend easily for a seamless look.
Best Budget: ATHR Organic Moonlight Crystal Eyeshadow Palette
Key Specs
- Powder
- 12 Shades
- Metallic/Matte/Shimmer/Radiant Finish
What We Love About It
This organic matte eyeshadow palette has 12 shades and is convenient and easy to carry, but its various colors, organic ingredients, and affordable price make it perfect for those on a budget. This palette is only $15.50 and provides high-quality colors that can be effortlessly applied to the skin. It is also made with the environment in mind since it comes in a recyclable palette and is vegan and cruelty-free.
We love the organic ingredients which include organic coconut oil; moringa seed, which helps with fine lines and wrinkles; organic shea butter, which hydrates and protects the skin; and sapphire which adds to the skin’s radiance and fights against negative energies.
Best Single Color: Giselle Cosmetics Organic Makeup
Key Specs
- Powder
- Travel Size
- Shimmery Finish
- Single Color
What We Love About It
This American-made eyeshadow is free from parabens and toxins so your skin will remain healthy and protected. This is the best organic eyeshadow we found with single color options since you get your choice of 20 different colors and all of them come in a travel-sized case; you can buy multiple so you can mix and match or just purchase one to match your skin tone.
We love that this eyeshadow can be used as a lip stain, nail polish, foundation, or bronzer as well. The easy-to-blend formula is made of mica and iron oxides to provide a more radiant skin tone that will last all day long. Although the container seems small, there is a substantial amount of powder, making it well worth the price.
Best Color Options: BaeBlu Hypoallergenic Organic Eyeshadow
Key Specs
- Powder
- 21 Colors
- Shimmery/Matte/Natural Finish
What We Love About It
To us, BaeBlu makes the best organic eyeshadow if you are looking for a lot of color options since you have your choice of 21 great colors that are rich, dense, and have a smooth velvety texture. They are easy to apply and create a smooth and uniform finish when applied to the skin.
We love that this hypoallergenic formula uses a natural mineral color that will not cause tearing, redness, or irritation and is, therefore, safe for sensitive skin. It’s also water resistant, making it stand up to sweat and humidity all day without using a substantial amount of product. These colors are bold and come in various finishes, like satin, sparkle, matte, shimmer, and duotone.
Best for Sensitive Skin: Harvest Natural Beauty Organic Eyeshadow
Key Specs
- Powder
- 5 Colors
- Single Color
What We Love About It
Free from fragrances, preservatives, and nasty oils this eyeshadow is the best organic eyeshadow for those with sensitive skin. The powder, when applied, goes on smooth and leaves a velvety, creaseless finish thanks to its 100% natural and organic ingredients. This means sensitive eyes are safe from tearing and irritation.
The color choices are more limited than some of our other options, but these colors have a depth and richness of pigment that we love when applied to the skin. The feeling of this eyeshadow is light and easy to apply, without any creases or caking. Also, it is Leaping Bunny Certified and sustainable so it is great for the planet and you.
Best Nude Colors: Physicians Formula Eyeshadow Palette
Key Specs
- Powder
- Matte Finish
- Nude Colors
What We Love About It
If you are looking for the best nude colors to match your skin tone we believe this is the best organic eyeshadow pallet for you since it comes with 6 different nude colors perfect for those that are just looking for something simple yet rich. These colors are easily blendable thanks to an organic blend of tucuma butter, murumuru butter, monoi butter, and cupuacu butter.
Those natural ingredients also provide the skin with essential fatty acids to moisturize the skin, keeping it soft and conditioned. We also love that this is a healthy choice for those with sensitive skin since these ingredients won’t cause irritation, and it will last all day long.
Best Consciously Crafted: Honeybee Gardens Nude Renaissance Refillable Eyeshadow
Key Specs
- Matte/Natural Finish
- 4 Shades
- Refillable
Honeybee has thought about the sustainability of its product down to its nifty palette, which contains a mirror and is completely refillable, which is why we find it to be the best organic eyeshadow that is consciously crafted.
We love the richness and depth of the colors, some find that it appears muted on their skin, but we find it to be the perfect balance of color and blendability. This is a vegan formula, as well as organic, and applies to the skin smoothly and doesn’t leave any creases. The palette can hold 8 colors and is magnetic, so you can set it for on-the-go makeup application.
Best for Everyday Look: Pacifica 10-Shade Pink Nude Mineral Eyeshadow
Key Specs
- Powder
- Matte/Natural Finish
- Pink Nude Colors
What We Love About It
If you are looking for an organic matte eyeshadow palette that can go with you anywhere and is perfect for an everyday look, we recommend this 10 Shade Eyeshadow from Pacifica. We find this to be the best organic eyeshadow for the everyday look since it is composed of 10 nude colors for any complexion.
We love the velvety finish that this eyeshadow palette provides especially since it is made of coconut water and mineral colors that won’t be harsh on the skin, but still provide a rich pigment. Users rave about how gentle it is on the skin and how good it is for sensitive eyes.
Best Versatile Powder: Lauren Brooke Cosmetiques Natural Powder Eye Color
Key Specs
- Powder
- Matte/Natural Finish
- 33 Colors
What We Love About It
Different days and different events require different styles and colors, so finding a reliable but versatile powder is important for those who have a versatile life. This natural and organic option from Lauren Brooke is the best organic eyeshadow since it has varied colors that can be bold enough for special events or simple and clean enough for daily use.
We love this eyeshadow since it applies and blends easily, and it has a lovely yet subtle sparkling finish. It’s also sure to stay on all day but doesn’t leave a cakey or flakey residue.
Best Compact: INIKA Organic Quad Eyeshadow Palette
Key Specs
- Powder
- Four Shades
- Shimmery/Matte/Satin Finish
What We Love About It
Made of cocoa seed extract, mineral mica, and carnauba wax this quad eyeshadow palette is the best organic eyeshadow for a compact since it is small and easy to carry, but still has bold and rich colors. This eyeshadow is gentle on the skin thanks to the carnauba wax, which is hypoallergenic, and the mineral mica provides a radiant glow
We love that this palette is simple with pure mineral pigment and a long-lasting finish. The casing is also made from card and tin, which makes it sustainable and adds to the earth-friendly quality that the INIKA brand stands behind.
Best to Spoil Yourself: ATHR Crystal Eyeshadow
Key Specs
- 4 Shades
- Metallic/Shimmer/Matte Finish
- Light Coverage
What We Love About It
If you are looking to splurge and get something special for yourself, the ATHR Crystal Eyeshadow is the best organic eyeshadow for just that. This eyeshadow is made with exotic organic ingredients such as desert-derived moringa seed oil, which helps to smooth fine lines and wrinkles, and shea butter which moisturizes the skin.
What makes this palette special is the addition of rose quartz, which restores radiance to the skin, reducing redness. Although it’s on the more expensive side, we find that the design of the compact as well as the vibrancy and smoothness of the colors makes it well worth it.
How We Chose the Best Organic Eyeshadow
When looking for the best organic eye shadow we wanted to find palettes or companies that had various color options so that individuals could match their tone, skin color, or aesthetic. The price had to be affordable with a reasonable amount of product for the price, but also high-quality. We also made sure that these products were loved by the majority who purchased them.
Of course, the main goal was to find organic and natural eyeshadows that were free of toxins and ingredients that could irritate or create prolonged damage to the skin. All of the eyeshadows on our list are made of a high percentage of organic ingredients that help maintain the health and vibrancy of the skin. Hopefully, our list of the best organic eyeshadow has something perfect for you.
