The perfect eyeliner can make your eyes pop from across the room, framing the windows to your soul. Many eyeliners use chemicals, dyes, artificial colors, and toxins in order to deliver high-pigmented colors and long-lasting capabilities.
That’s why looking for organic and all-natural eyeliners is not only important for your health, but will also help your eyes pop naturally. Here are 10 of what we believe to be the best organic eyeliner out there.
Our Top Picks for 2024
- Best Overall: Gabriel Cosmetics Classic Eyeliner
- Best for Sensitive Eyes: BaeBlu Natural Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Pencil
- Best Budget Eyeliner: Almay Eyeliner Pencil
- Best for Smooth Application: Ilia Clean Line Gel Liner
- Best for Rich Pigment: INIKA Organic Eye Pencil
- Best for Soothing Eyes: Physicians Formula Organic Wear all-natural Liquid Eyeliner
- Best for Eyelash Growth: Au Naturale-Essential Eye Pencil
- Best for Eye Health: TATSAT Wellness Through Ayurveda 100% Natural Eye Liner
- Best Long-Lasting Eyeliner: PureBIO Certified Organic Black Eyeliner
- Best for Eyelashes and Eyebrows: True + Luscious Brow Definer Pencil
Best Overall: Gabriel Cosmetics Classic Eyeliner
Key Specs
- Black
- Pencil
- 0.04 oz.
What We Love About It
Packed with all-natural ingredients that are non-GMO, vegan, gluten-free, and at an affordable price, we recommend this as the best organic eyeliner overall. It’s a long-lasting eyeliner that is easy to blend with a creamy consistency. The main ingredient is jojoba oil, which gives it a smooth texture but there is also Carnauba wax and candelilla wax which protect the skin.
We appreciate that the natural ingredients keep the skin around the eyes hydrated and therefore avoid drying or irritating the skin. It’s also a great choice for those who are prone to allergies or reactions since it is suitable for all skin types.
Best for Sensitive Eyes: BaeBlu Natural Hypoallergenic Eyeliner Pencil
Key Specs
- Black
- Pencil
What We Love About It
Eyeliners can have chemicals in them that can irritate the eyes and the surrounding area, or even the natural ingredients can cause irritation. This is the best organic eyeliner for sensitive eyes because it avoids all harsh additives and uses antioxidant-rich jojoba and castor oils in order to make for a smooth application and a gentle and soft touch.
Although this eyeliner only comes in black and brown, we find that the clean ingredients make it worth the purpose, including the hydrating oils that take care of the skin. We also enjoy this eyeliner for sharp lines as the pigmented color helps the liner stand out with little thickness.
Best Budget Eyeliner: Almay Eyeliner Pencil
Key Specs
- Pencil
- 5 colors
- Shimmery finish
What We Love About It
This eyeliner is great for those who don’t want to spend much for quality; at $7.11 it’s the best organic eyeliner on a budget, but it uses beautiful colors that are enriched with Vitamin E so that the area around your eyes will be protected and nourished.
We love that this has a built-in sharpener that keeps the point of your eyeliner fine so you can work with detail around your eyes. Best of all it can last up to 16 hours and since it is water-resistant, it will be able to stand up to the rain, sweat, and tears. For an affordable price, you get an eyeliner that will hold up all day and night and will provide nourishment to your eye area.
Best for Smooth Application: Ilia Clean Line Gel Liner
Key Specs
- Pencil
- Brown and black
- Water resistant
- 0.01 oz.
What We Love About It
Avoid ingredients that can be detrimental to your health with the Ilia Gel Liner; this organic eyeliner pencil is the best for smooth application because it has a soft tip that glides effortlessly and blends easily. The gel quickly dries and stays resilient throughout the day, especially since it is water-resistant.
We love the built-in sharpener on the end so that you can travel with it and adjust if you need to. This eyeliner is designed consciously, and made of cruelty-free, gluten-free, and vegan ingredients.
Best for Rich Pigment: INIKA Organic Eye Pencil
Key Specs
- Pencil
- Silky finish
- Cocoa and emerald color options
What We Love About It
We love the emerald color option of this eyeliner, which can also double as an eyebrow pencil. The emerald jumps out to us because of the richness of color, which is why we find this to be the best organic eyeliner with rich pigment. The other color option is cocoa, which also shows off a rich and long-lasting color.
Since it can be used as both eyeliner and an eyebrow pencil it cuts down on the size of your makeup bag. Ingredients such as coconut oil and carnauba wax ensure that the pen applies smoothly but is also easy on the skin, providing healthy nutrients.
Best for Soothing Eyes: Physicians Formula Organic Wear all-natural Liquid Eyeliner
Key Specs
- Pencil
- Matte finish
- Hypoallergenic
- Brown and black
What We Love About It
This affordable natural liquid eyeliner is approved by dermatologists and for good reason. The ingredients used in this including botanical cactus flower, organic chamomile oil, organic jojoba oil, and organic aloe vera allow the eyeliner to go on smooth and provide a soothing application.
This is why we find it to be the best organic eyeliner for soothing, especially since the ingredients provide much-needed nourishment to the applied area. It is healthy for combination skin types and it is a reliable eyeliner that lasts all day long.
Best for Eyelash Growth: Au Naturale-Essential Eye Pencil
Key Specs
- Pencil
- 10 colors
- Soft tip
What We Love About It
Aside from the beautiful array of colors that this eyeliner has to offer, we appreciate that this eyeliner is infused with castor oil. Castor oil promotes the growth of lashes and also fosters more volume and curl, which is why we recommend this as the best organic eyeliner for eyelash growth.
We love that this nourishes the skin and goes on smoothly, providing defined lines that last all day. Best of all, there are 10 different colors to choose from, all of which use natural mineral pigment from the earth that avoids the absorption of nano-particles into the bloodstream but also promotes beautiful, vibrant color.
Best for Eye Health: TATSAT Wellness Through Ayurveda 100% Natural Eye Liner
Key Specs
- Balm
- Metallic finish
- Unscented
What We Love About It
In the style of Ayurvedic medicine, this eyeliner uses natural ingredients to boost the health and vitality of your eyes. We find this to be the best organic eyeliner for eye health because the result can make you improve your eyesight and can soothe and nourish the eyes.
Thanks to ingredients like almond oil, castor oil, and ghee (an ayurvedic addition that fights eye disease), your eyes will feel hydrated instead of dry or irritated. The eyeliner is so delicate that it is safe to use on babies. Best of all, this eyeliner is made through a delicate process using a medicated cloth that is burned down into a medicated soot, which is mixed with other ingredients to make this revitalizing eyeliner.
Best Long-Lasting Eyeliner: PureBIO Certified Organic Black Eyeliner
Key Specs
- Pencil
- Opaque finish
What We Love About It
Since this eyeliner can last smudge-free without caking for 8 hours we had to recommend it as the best organic eyeliner that lasts the longest. The rich and creamy color of this eyeliner goes on smoothly and can create nicely defined lines, and it can be blended to create a nice shadow effect.
Ingredients such as jojoba oil, avocado oil, and coconut oil create a creamy consistency but also provide nourishment to the eye area, preventing irritation or dry skin. We love that this is certified organic through the CCPB, NATRUE, and VEGANOK.
Best for Eyelashes and Eyebrows: True + Luscious Brow Definer Pencil
Key Specs
- Pencil
- 3 colors
- Natural finish
What We Love About It
Using castor oil as an agent that helps to grow and thicken lashes and eyebrows, this brow definer pencil is also the best organic eyeliner for eyelashes and eyebrows. It comes with a pencil end to use for eyeliner and a spoolie side to groom eyebrows. It’s waterproof so that it can resist sweat and stand up to a long day of wear.
We love that this comes in various shades for all ethnicities and there is no smudging. This organic eyeliner pencil uses skin-loving ingredients to ensure you are nourished and healthy as well as vibrant and defined.
How We Chose the Best Organic Eyeliner
Something that defines eyeliner is a vibrant and full color, which can be difficult when dealing with all-natural ingredients that could risk being muted. So, we wanted to find eyeliners that had rich pigment using natural ingredients. It was also important to find eyeliners that provided nutrients and hydration so that you could wear them for a long time without causing any damage or drying.
Other aspects we looked for were ease of application, cleanliness, and sustainability. Many of the companies we chose used vegan, cruelty-free, and sustainable practices that ensured not only the health of the customer but also of the planet. Hopefully, this list of the best organic eyeliner has something special to make your eyes pop.
