Declaring Miami-Dade’s system of funding political campaigns “broken,” a coalition of union workers, activists and politicians moved to drastically change how countywide elections are fought and won Tuesday by submitting more than 125,000 signed petitions to the county clerk of courts and potentially forcing a November referendum.
The petitions — enough to fill two U-Haul trucks — were delivered to the county’s elections headquarters in Doral, where they will be counted and vetted. If enough signatures are verified, county commissioners will have to decide in the coming weeks whether to adopt proposed campaign finance legislation themselves or put the issue before voters.
Under the proposal sponsored by political committee An Accountable Miami-Dade, campaign contributions to candidates for county commission, mayor and school board would be capped at $250 a person or corporation, down from $1,000. Major county vendors and their lobbyists and principals would be barred from contributing to candidates. And a system that affords candidates matching public contributions for donations of up to $100 by county residents would potentially enable candidates to multiply those donations six-fold.
“This is about restoring balance to our political process,” said Gihan Perera, executive director of The New Florida Majority, an independent nonprofit that works to politically empower marginalized populations. “Our communities often don’t exercise their rights because they often feel the political process is rigged, corrupt or not in their interest.”
This is about restoring balance to our political process
Gihan Perera, executive director of The New Florida Majority
The proposed changes wouldn’t take effect until the next county election cycle if the measure passes, but come during an election season in which millions have been raised to fund campaigns for county office. More than $5 million has been raised in the race for county mayor alone between incumbent Carlos Gimenez and challenger Raquel Regalado.
David Donnelly, CEO of Every Voice, a nonprofit that seeks to implement campaign finance reform around the country, said the goal in Miami-Dade was not only to reduce the influence of businessmen holding and seeking government contracts but also to create greater value for the contributions made by the average voter and help grass-roots candidates have a puncher’s chance. Donnelly’s organization provided more than $250,000 in cash and resources to the petition drive, led by leaders of local groups from Service Employees International Union, the League of Women Voters of Miami-Dade County, and Engage Miami, among others.
“If this law passes in the fall, we believe it will be one of the strongest policies found anywhere in the country when it comes to lifting up the voices of regular people,” Donnelly said.
I think it’s a solution in search of a problem right now, however well-intentioned it is
J.C. Planas, elections attorney
But some question the wisdom of what’s being proposed. J.C. Planas, a former state representative and attorney specializing in election law, said the effort is well-intentioned but won’t improve elections or make them more transparent.
Planas said the proposal could run afoul of the U.S. constitution by placing disproportionate restrictions on specific classes of people, and could actually further empower unions and political parties, who aren’t limited in their contributions to political committees by the legislation. Critics of past campaign finance reform proposals related to government vendors have also worried that donors blocked from contributing to campaigns will simply find other, less transparent means of contributing money.
“I think it’s a solution in search of a problem right now, however well-intentioned it is,” said Planas. “Right now, with the campaign finance system we have, everything is transparent. We have monthly reporting. Everyone can go and find out who’s contributing to any group.”
The fate of the petition drive now rests in the hands of county commissioners, who under county law have 30 days to direct the elections supervisor to begin vetting petition signatures. Commissioners are currently on August recess, so it’s likely Chairman Jean Monestime would need to call for a special meeting.
The supervisor of elections has 30 days to verify petition signatures. If enough are verified, the county commission would then need to decide whether to adopt the proposed legislation itself, or place a ballot question during the next eligible election.