Hurricane

If path holds, Irma could swamp Southwest Florida, Tampa coast with surge

Evacuees stand in line to enter the Germain Arena, which is being used as a shelter, in advance of Hurricane Irma, in Estero, Fla., Saturday, Sept. 9, 2017. With the window closing fast for anyone wanting to escape, Irma hurtled toward Florida with 125 mph winds Saturday on a projected track that could take it away from Miami and instead give the Tampa area its first direct hit from a major hurricane in nearly a century.
Evacuees stand in line to enter the Germain Arena, which is being used as a shelter, in advance of Hurricane Irma, in Estero, Fla., Saturday, Sept. 9, 2017. With the window closing fast for anyone wanting to escape, Irma hurtled toward Florida with 125 mph winds Saturday on a projected track that could take it away from Miami and instead give the Tampa area its first direct hit from a major hurricane in nearly a century. AP

As Hurricane Irma began assaulting Florida’s west coast Sunday, it threatened to hit the nation’s most vulnerable target for storm surge: Tampa.

Tampa is especially prone to flooding because it is low lying with a big bay and inlets that face the shallow, warm waters of the Gulf of Mexico. And just about every other Gulf Coast community in Irma’s track — Everglades City, Naples, Cape Coral, Bradenton, Sarasota — is also at high risk.

Tampa leaders are all too aware of this scary natural phenomenon.

“Storm surge is real. I think it’s ‘You run from the water and hide from the wind,’ ” Hillsborough County Commissioner Sandy Murman said, urging residents to take all precautions at an emergency briefing on Saturday.

“Well, you better run from this water because if that storm surge hits six to nine feet, I know I’m going to have six feet in my house.”

Based on its track coming off the Lower Keys on Saturday, the National Hurricane Center projected storm surge — the difference between normal high tide and storm tide — reaching as high as 10 to 15 feet along Southwest Florida’s coast from Cape Sable to Captiva. The Tampa Bay area could see four to eight feet.

“If you’re in an evacuation zone, you do not want to be there when the surge comes,” NHC specialist Mike Brennan warned Gulf Coast residents. “You can lose your life. It’s as simple as that.”

The Tampa-St. Petersburg metro area — Florida’s second largest — has been rated as the nation’s most vulnerable region to a major storm surge with estimated property losses of $175 billion in the event of a 100-year hurricane, according to a Boston company that specializes in assessing the risk of catastrophes.

In Tampa, the 100-year hurricane would be a Category 4 storm with winds as high as 150 miles per hour. The last major hurricane to strike the Tampa Bay area — a Category 4 with maximum winds of 140 miles per hour — was in 1921.

“A severe storm with the right-track orientation will cause an enormous buildup of water that will become trapped in the bay and inundate large areas of Tampa and St. Petersburg,” with 50 percent of their population living on ground elevations less than 10 feet, according to a 2015 report by Karen Clark & Company.

The company rated Fort Myers No. 5 in vulnerability with estimated losses of $70 billion, and Sarasota at No. 7 with losses estimated at $50 billion.

By comparison, Miami came in at No. 4 with estimated losses at $80 billion. Miami’s coastal profile is less prone to storm surge than other areas because the continental shelf falls off steeply, the report said. But its potential property losses are still high because the city boasts some of Florida’s most expensive real estate.

Irma, which earlier in the week was projected to strike South Florida, started shifting to a northwest track on Friday toward Southwest Florida. Typically, in this region, storms travel east to west or southwest to northeast — as Hurricane Charley did in 2004, when the Category 4 storm made landfall west of Fort Myers.

Satellite imagery shows Hurricane Irma moving through Cuba before it veers toward Florida on Saturday, Sept. 9, 2017.

However, Irma’s path appeared to be heading parallel to the Southwest coast from Naples to Tampa — and that would cause the Gulf’s shallow bays to bulge.

If Irma’s eye wall cuts across the Tampa-St. Petersburg metro area, it would not only bring destructive winds to the densely populated cities but could also fuel a catastrophic storm surge into Tampa Bay, according to a worst-case scenario by The Weather Channel.

When Hurricane Charley threatened the same area in 2004, an oceanographer at the University of South Florida’s marine college said that highlighted an example that would cause widespread inland flooding.

“The worst case is if the storm parallels the coast and comes ashore north of the bay,” USF professor Robert Weisberg told the Miami Herald in August 2004, before Charley would ultimately make landfall 90 miles south of Tampa.

Weisberg explained that if Charley struck that end, its back side would drive storm surge well inland because the shallowness of the Gulf and Tampa Bay leaves no other place for the water to go.

Two things increase the Tampa area’s vulnerability, said then-National Hurricane Center oceanographer Stephen Baig: its low-lying coast and shallow surrounding waters. Even 25 miles off the coast, the Gulf of Mexico is only about 60 feet deep.

“The west Florida shelf is very broad,” Baig told the Herald. “That’s extremely conducive” to storm surge. In essence, water driven by a hurricane has no place to go but up — very quickly.

“Most people have no idea how fast water can rise up because most of us have never seen a 100-mile-an-hour wind lift up water,” Baig told the Herald in 2004.

Scientists and forecasters stress that surge impacts can vary widely depending on the intensity, speed, angle and landfall of a storm.

But one thing is clear: Storm surge is deadly serious. The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration has identified storm surge as the most damaging aspect of a hurricane, because it destroys buildings and drowns people.

On Sunday, U.S. Sen. Marco Rubio urged residents in Southwest Florida to follow Irma’s track and prepare for the worst.

“We’re concerned about it intensifying as it heads into Southwest Florida, into Naples, Fort Myers, Sarasota, Tampa Bay,” Rubio told CNN’s Jake Tapper. “That has always been our biggest fear, a massive storm headed into that region pushing all that water in there plus the wind.”

Miami Herald staff writer Charles Rabin contributed to this report.

Related stories from Miami Herald

  Comments