Why is this Florida man chest deep in swamp water? Because the Glades are drowning

Record rain is drowning the Everglades

Record rain generated by a severe wet season, a hurricane and a tropical storm have left marshes and tree islands submerged for longer than they have been in decades.
Up Next
Record rain generated by a severe wet season, a hurricane and a tropical storm have left marshes and tree islands submerged for longer than they have been in decades.

Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commissioner Ron Bergeron, a lifelong Gladesman also known as Alligator Ron, slipped off his camouflaged snake boots Friday and, for the second time since June, slid off a dock outside his Everglades hunting camp into inky black swamp water.

This time water reached his chest. Back in June, when he summoned reporters to draw attention to flooding across the watery marshes, it only reached his waist.

“There’s not one wading bird that can land in the Everglades right now,” he said. “The Everglades is in serious condition, actual catastrophic conditions.”

bergeron in deep water
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commissioner Ron Bergeron stood in chest deep water Friday to show how water has risen even higher since June, when a record-breaking week of rain sent levels soaring. Jenny Staletovich Miami Herald Staff

An early start to the rainy season, followed by Hurricane Irma, a punishing record-breaking wet season, and an October lashing from a tropical storm have for weeks left South Florida’s water conservation areas — vast wildlife refuges used by air-boaters, hunters and nature-lovers — flooded. The Francis S. Taylor Wildlife Management Area, which covers 1,125 square miles in western Miami-Dade and Broward counties, has been shut down since mid June. Tree islands that formed thousands of years ago, and provide habitat for deer, bears, raccoons, rabbits and even a panther spotted last year, have been under water for close to 21 weeks, a period of inundation that could start to threaten their very existence.

This weekend’s king tides might be drawing attention eastward to Miami Beach and the state’s urban coast, but Bergeron and others say it’s Florida’s wilderness where unprecedented flooding is threatening more dire problems.

bergeron tree
Water has completely submerged an Everglades hunting camp belonging to Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commissioner Ron Bergeron. Weeks of flooding are now threatening to wipe out wildlife and kill tree islands. Jenny Staletovich Miami Herald Staff

“Trees are not used to being inundated for 120 days,” said Tom Reinert, the FWC’s South Florida regional director. “Trees start to die.”

Over the decades, flood control has gradually whittled away at the number of trees islands, leaving only about 600 in the conservation areas west of the urban coast. Now, unless water is lowered and islands dried out, even more could die, according to the South Florida Water Management District’s chief Everglades scientist Fred Sklar.

“We could lose another 50 to 60,” he said. “That’s 10 percent.”

sklar tree islands
Since the 1940s, about 60 percent of the tree islands that provide habitat for wildlife and nesting birds have been wiped out by flood control. High water that has left many of the islands flooded since June, a prolonged period not seen since the 1990s, is now threatening to drown them. South Florida Water Management District

Everglades restoration is supposed to fix the problems. But projects remain years away from being finished. So Bergeron, who has been meeting with the U.S. Corps of Army Engineers, is asking for a more immediate remedy: raise water levels in the massive canal that runs along the Tamiami Trail and dumps into Everglades National Park.

“That’s the last avenue we have,” he said.

But Friday evening Corps spokesman John Campbell said the agency does not plan to raise canal levels due to flooding concerns in neighborhoods further south.

“Obviously, it’s a very challenging situation,” he said.

WCA water shot
Since June, water levels have been high in the water conservation areas west of Miami-Dade and Broward counties. Prolonged flooding is now raising concerns about the wildlife and tree islands. Jenny Staletovich Miami Herald Staff

As with all things Everglades, fixing one thing could break something else. Bergeron is pleading for a little more “shared diversity” under the current crisis. But the Corps, which since Hurricane Katrina has made flood safety a priority, has no plans on altering course, Campbell said.

“We have the authority … to raise it to 8.5 feet. However, we also have an obligation to provide flood mitigation to the 8.5-square mile community, so we’re making an operational decision not to raise the water level at this time.”

bergeron high water
In June, FWC Commissioner Ron Bergeron, left, and Executive Director Nick Wiley, right, stand in waist high water to demonstrate flooding in the water conservation areas. CARL JUSTE cjuste@miamiherald.com

Since the beginning of the rainy season, both the Corps and the Water Management District have been working to flush water off the peninsula without wreaking havoc. To protect the aging dike around Lake Okeechobee, water was released down the St. Lucie and Caloosahatchee rivers, which regularly raises the risk of toxic algae blooms. Last month, rising lake water finally began falling, ending the releases.

But the water in the conservation areas — WCA3 west of Miami-Dade was 2.5 feet above where it should be at the end of October — has remained persistently high. That’s despite the Corps waiving most operational rules that normally prevent moving water to protect wildlife. Flood gates intended to keep nesting grounds for Cape Sable seaside sparrows dry and which should have closed Nov. 1 are still open, and water managers continue to move water into the Big Cypress National Preserve, where water is more than a half foot higher than normal.

The only option left is the L-29 canal along the Trail, Bergeron said. But raising water to 8.5 feet, which would increase flushing from the conservation areas to nearly a billion gallons a day, raises concerns about flood protection for the 8.5-square mile Las Palmas neighborhood of ranches, nurseries and homes.

WCA closed sign
More than 1,100 square miles in the Everglades and Francis S. Taylor Wildlife Management Area west of Miami-Dade and Broward counties has been closed since June because of high water. Jenny Staletovich Miami Herald Staff

The Corps is in the midst of improving flood control as part of a restoration project intended to deliver more water south into Florida Bay, where everyone agrees more water is needed. Lack of freshwater from the marshes combined with a regional drought triggered a massive seagrass die-off in 2015 that killed between 40 and 60-square miles of meadows, a hit to marine life and the bay’s lucrative sport-fishing industry.

But this year’s rainy season put a stop to the work. Last week, Bergeron said he flew over the area and found standing water only on vacant land.

“Ninety-eight percent of the 8.5-square mile area, under all these conditions, looked, in my opinion, very good,” he said. “I do understand the Corps’ concern with safety and welfare. I do understand that,” he said. “But now that we’re in the dry season I’m hoping the Corps evaluates what I personally observed in the 8.5-square mile area to be reasonably dry.”

Without the relief, Bergeron warns prolonged flooding in the wildlife management area could trigger a repeats of high water events in 1982 and 1994, when high water caused deer to drown, starve or die from crippling hoof rot. Today, Reinert said wildlife are managed to keep populatons healthy if flooding occurs. But that won’t help the islands.

“Deer and rabbits can all swim away,” he said. “Trees don’t move.”

Follow Jenny Staletovich on Twitter @jenstaletovich