The Orlando shooting massacre at the Pulse gay nightclub that led to the deaths of 49 victims has led to more national attention about hate crimes targeting the gay community.
U.S. Attorney General Loretta Lynch spoke about the attack hours later on Fox News Sunday.
“I think we have to keep our eye on a larger picture here, which is the victims of this crime were from a community that is often marginalized and that, frankly, the LGBT community is more often the victims of hate crimes than any other recognized group,” she said.
Lynch is correct if we examine per capita rates for hate crimes, although there are some caveats about the data — mainly that there are gaps in how law enforcement reports hate crimes.
Sign Up and Save
Get six months of free digital access to the Miami Herald
The FBI defines hate crimes as “criminal offenses motivated, in whole or in part, by the offender’s bias against” a particular group such as a religion, race or sexual orientation.
Data on hate crimes
A spokesman for Lynch said she was referring to an analysis by the New York Times published days after the Orlando shooting. Using data from the FBI and the U.S. Census, the newspaper compared hate crimes per capita in two years: 2005 and 2014. The newspaper found “L.G.B.T. people are twice as likely to be targeted as African-Americans, and the rate of hate crimes against them has surpassed that of crimes against Jews.”
Mark Potok, an expert on extremism at the Southern Poverty Law Center, did a similar analysis of 14 years of hate crime data in 2011.
He found that LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender) people are far more likely than other minority groups to be victimized by violent hate crimes.
Potok examined the percentage of the population represented by these groups: LGBT, Jews, blacks, Muslims, Latinos and whites. Then he compiled the total number of hate crimes against persons (excluding crimes against property) between 1995 and 2008. Then he compared the level of hate crime aimed at each group to the group’s percentage in the population to determine the rate of victimization.
He found that LGBT people were victimized at 8.3 times the expected rate. Jews were victimized at 3.5 times the expected rate, blacks at 3.2 times, Muslims at 1.9 times, Latinos at 0.6 times, and whites at 0.2 times.
An important caveat: There are several holes in the reporting of hate crimes to the FBI. Local law enforcement agencies voluntarily report their data to a state agency that compiles the information for the FBI. Some local agencies report no hate crimes or don’t submit a report.
A study by the federal Bureau of Justice Statistics found that 60 percent of violent hate crimes were not reported to police in 2012.
A 2016 Associated Press investigation found that more than 2,700 city police and county sheriff’s departments have not submitted a single hate crime report to the FBI during the past six years — about 17 percent of all city and county law enforcement agencies nationwide.
Among the agencies that reported zero hate crimes in 2014 were several major cities, including Jacksonville, Miami and Tampa.
Another way to look at the data about hate crimes rather than per capita is the sheer number of crimes. By that measure, there were more hate crimes against African-Americans than LGBT residents. But that’s not surprising since African-Americans represent about 13.2 percent of the population according to the U.S. Census, while the LGBT community represents about 2.3 percent of the population, according to a survey done by the Centers for Disease Control (other surveys found a slightly higher rate.)
Why would LGBT be victimized at a higher rate
Answering the question as to why the LGBT community would be victimized at a higher rate is more complex.
Some of the crime, paradoxically, may be motivated by more widespread acceptance of gay rights.
“We are seeing lots more gay people getting married,” said Jack Levin, a sociologist at Northeastern University and expert on hate crimes. “I think what hate crimes represent is a reaction to that.”
Some are motivated by fear.
“There is a visceral hatred against LGBT people in large part connected to fears about sexuality,” Potok said. “Sexuality is an incredibly fraught topic for some people and especially those people who fear they might have same-sex attraction themselves.”
Law enforcement is still investigating the Orlando shooting, but based on information so far, experts said that the shooter appeared to be motivated in part by bigotry and self-loathing. Omar Mateen, who was married to a woman, regularly visited the gay nightclub and used gay dating apps, according to reports by patrons at the club.
Lynch said, “The LGBT community is more often the victims of hate crimes than any other recognized group.”
It’s worth noting that there may be widespread underreporting of hate crime incidents in general. However, the best available research shows that the LGBT community is victimized at a higher rate than other minority groups, according to FBI data.
We rate this claim True.
The statement: "The LGBT community is more often the victims of hate crimes than any other recognized group."
The ruling: It’s worth noting that there may be widespread underreporting of hate crime incidents in general. However, the best available research shows that the LGBT community is victimized at a higher rate than other minority groups, according to FBI data.
We rate this claim: True.
Politifact Florida is a partnership between The Tampa Bay Times and the Miami Herald to check out truth in politics.