The S&S Diner will remain open — for now.
The iconic diner, operating since 1938 and designated a national and Miami historic landmark, can stay in business while the court decides whether its lease allows it to remain through 2019, a judge decided Thursday.
“I don’t know for how long, but we’re staying,” longtime manager Maria Linares said.
Sign Up and Save
Get six months of free digital access to the Miami Herald
The restaurant was facing eviction Thursday after it was a day late with its July rent, while it disputed its landlord’s claim that S&S Diner’s current lease is not valid.
In dispute is a lease extension the S&S Diner signed in January 2015 that would allow it to remain open through 2019. The restaurant’s owner of 17 years, Simon Elbaz, said he signed a lease in 2010 with a previous owner that included the extension option.
But current landlord 17th and Second Avenue Properties Corp., which purchased the S&S building in 2012, said it never agreed to the extension, according to court documents. In April, the company filed suit against S&S, saying the diner’s lease had expired at the end of 2014 and that Elbaz had refused to move out when told his month-to-month lease would not be renewed in March.
17th and Second agreed to sell the S&S and other neighboring properties for $33 million in February, according to the Real Deal. That sale is set to close next July but was contingent on the building being sold without a tenant, Elbaz said.
Elbaz, 68, is fighting those claims in court. And for now, the case is pending.
Elbaz said Wednesday that at worst he would like time to find a new location for the S&S Diner. It would be without its iconic facade, which has the city’s legal protection as a historic landmark.
“What I want is to keep my restaurant running and for the people of Miami to enjoy it,” Elbaz said. “We are a little restaurant, but we deserve a little more respect.”