Jewish voters concerned more about Medicare than Iran
Voters and speakers in Boca Raton’s Century Village and Tamarac’s Kings Point spent relatively little time talking about Israel and Iran, and far more about Medicare and Republican plans to change it.
09/28/2012 8:00 AM
09/28/2012 5:13 PM
Barack Obama ... Oy vey!
The Republican signs greeted Vice President Joe Biden as he began campaigning Friday in the heart of South Florida’s Jewish community.
The visit came 24 hours after Israeli Prime Minister Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s United Nation’s speech when he held up a drawing of a mock-Iranian atomic bomb and drew a red line through it.
But voters and speakers in Boca Raton’s Century Village and Tamarac’s Kings Point spent relatively little time talking about Israel and Iran, and far more about Medicare and Republican plans to change it.
It was another sign that, for all of the Republican efforts to sway Jewish voters, they remain a solidly Democratic bloc of the electorate.
“Netanyahu was speaking to the converted to the degree he was being political at all,” said Ken Werden, a 73-year-old resident of the mammoth retirement community.
“Jewish voters back Obama because, historically, we didn’t see Republicans as friends of the Jewish community, especially when it comes to civil rights or Medicare.”
Werden, though, acknowledges he’s a minority of sorts: An Orthodox Jewish voter who’s siding with President Obama.
“For many Orthodox, the number one issue is Israel,” Werden said.
That was clear across the street at the Orthodox Chabad Weltman Synagogue, where congregants feel that President Obama hasn’t been tough enough on Iranian leader Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.
“Obama is courting Ahmadinejad; he’s not standing up to him,” said Simon Mizrachi, a Republican member of the synagogue.
“The leader of the United States and the nations of the world have not done enough about Iran,” he said.
In speaking to the 850 or so speakers in Boca Raton, Biden tried to rebut that idea by talking about the "special obligations" of the United States.
"One of those is Israel," Biden said.
"I want to tell you how proud I am to stand shoulder to shoulder with a guy who has done more for Israel’s physical security than any president I have been able to serve under," Biden said.
Most of his speech was about Medicare and Social Security — an issue that dominates the political discourse.
Biden stood by the campaign’s decision to criticize Republican Mitt Romney and his running mate, Paul Ryan, for voting for a congressional budget plan that could have raised out-of-pocket costs for future Medicare recipients by an average of $6,400.
Romney and Ryan have repeatedly said it’s an old plan and that they support a different proposal.
But Biden said Ryan’s vote was enough to prove that Republicans would hurt seniors and Democrats wouldn’t "willingly and knowingly" do that.
Biden cited a Harvard study showing how future seniors might have to pay more under Romney and Ryan’s plans. Republicans pointed to a University of Minnesota study showing how Obamacare cuts benefits for seniors in every state.
But polls suggest that most voters in must-win Florida have already made up their minds. Democrats are voting for the Democrat. Republicans for the Republicans. And the independents are splitting down the middle, but seem to favor Obama right now.
Republicans like Mizrachi conceded that the Jewish vote will overwhelmingly break for Obama.
“I hope not,” his wife, Caroline Mizrachi, chimed in. She said she voted as a Democrat for Obama in 2008. But like her husband, Mizrachi said she plans to vote for Mitt Romney in November.
“I’m disappointed in the position Obama has taken on Netanyahu and Israel,” she said. “And the economy really hasn’t felt like it has improved.”
For years, Republicans have tried to make inroads into the Jewish community and have met with limited support. They’re still trying.
One Republican group is running an ad in Florida featuring Netanyahu expressing grave concerns over Iran’s nuclear program. Another group has erected billboards along Florida’s Turnpike that says “Barack Obama … Oy Vey!” And the Republican Party of Florida is sending Jewish voters mailers that feature Mitt Romney praying at the Western Wall.
At the entry to Century Village, one Republican held up a sign that said "Obama hates Israel." On the other side, it said "Obama loves Iran."
It’s a decidedly minority view among Jewish voters. A survey last week of Florida Jewish voters, conducted by the American Jewish Committee, showed Obama winning 69 percent of the vote compared to 25 percent who sided with Republican Mitt Romney’s ticket.
Though strong, however, Obama’s Jewish support may be lower now than it was in 2008, when he won 76 percent of the Florida Jewish vote, according to the survey.
It found that 51 percent approved and 36 percent disapproved of the way President Obama is handling the Iranian nuclear program. And 79 percent said they’re “very concerned” over the situation with Iran. Jewish voters favored Biden as Obama’s running mate, with 76 percent supporting and 14 percent disapproving his selection.
Romney’s selection of Ryan was far less popular: 30 percent approved and 59 percent disapproved.
Ryan’s one-time proposals to trim back Medicare and eventually transform the program into a voucher-like system that subsidizes private health insurance is highly unpopular among Democrats.
Ryan has promoted a number of revised plans and most note that current seniors’ Medicare benefits wouldn’t be affected at all.
But that’s not a persuasive argument for voters like Martin Whitelaw, a 67-year-old Century Village Democrat.
“I’m thinking about the next generation and what they’ll have. And they should get the Medicare I get,” Whitelaw said.
“I’m not voting over Israel,” he said. “I’m voting over Medicare.”
In Tamarac, where Biden spoke at the Palace Theater at Kings Point, the feelings were similar.
Jewish Democrats like June Friedman, an 85-year-old from Kings Point and a retired Miami-Dade schools art teacher, said she’s convinced Romney and Ryan want to dismantle Medicare.
"If they give us a voucher very quickly it will be obsolete. The costs will go up faster," she said.
Biden will be in Fort Myers on Saturday to wrap up his two-day Florida trip. His visit marks once again the importance of Florida in this year’s presidential race as the nation’s biggest battleground state. Romney, Ryan and Obama have recently begun visiting the state at least once a week.
The reason, Biden says, is simple: "We win Florida, this race is over."
Oops, you haven't selected any newsletters. Please check the box next to one or more of our email newsletters and submit again.
Oops, you didn't provide a valid email address. Please double-check the email field and submit again.
Join the Discussion
Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.