Must I go to work?
08/29/2006 4:02 PM
09/17/2007 4:38 PM
Each hurricane season workers have to juggle their jobs with preparing for a storm. But many have three big questions about work: Do I have to go? Will I be paid? What do I do with my kids? The Miami Herald spoke to a few local labor lawyers to get their input.
Q: I need to miss work to prepare for the hurricane. Can I be fired? Will I be paid?
A: Yes, you can be fired. Florida is an employment-at-will state, which means that an employee can legally be terminated for any reason other than discrimination or actions like whistle blowing. Getting paid will depend on your job classification. Hourly workers are paid only for time worked, so employers aren't legally obligated to pay you anything if you're not at work. If you are a salaried employee (and don't get overtime), an employer can force you to use your vacation time.
Q: My boss says I have to work during the storm. Can I be fired if I refuse?
A: Yes. Again, because Florida is an employment-at-will state. Still, while several lawyers say they can't think of a law that makes it illegal to force employers to work during a storm, they often advise common sense on the part of employers during a hurricane. A good rule of thumb is if the people in charge of the business don't want to be out on the roads, no employee should have to be. Employers should post a hurricane work policy so everyone gets treated the same. If your employer isn't doing that, ask for a policy. Mark Cheskin, a lawyer who represents employers, said he would approach the boss by asking what the policy is to make clear everyone understands the rules.
"That puts the employer on the spot to make sure it's a clear understanding for everyone, " he said.
Q: Can I be forced to use vacation days or personal days during a hurricane, even if the business is closed?
A: Yes, if you are a salaried employee (and don't get overtime) and your place of business is closed because of the hurricane for less than a week. According to the new Department of Labor opinion, employers can ask workers to use vacation time, which can include personal days, even if the workplace is closed. The only good news: According to the new opinion, if you have run out of vacation time, or won't have enough left to make up the time missed, then your employee has to pay you for the entire week.
Q: School is closed, most day-care centers are closed, and I don't have a place to put my kids. Can I bring them with me to work?
A: Your boss isn't obligated to provide room for your children. In fact, labor lawyer Cheskin thinks he would tell his clients that's not a great idea. "I'd probably advise my clients not to do it, we don't want to have that kind of liability, " said Cheskin, who heads the Florida labor and employment law practice for Hogan & Hartson. But, he says, that's "completely up to the employer".
Ryder System, with more than 1,000 people working at its West Miami-Dade headquarters, said children are not welcome. David Bruce, Ryder spokesman, said those who don't come in because of child-care issues will not be docked vacation or sick time.
Meanwhile Murton Roofing, a Miami commercial roofer with 300 people in South Florida, will allow working parents to bring their children to work with them.
Q: My workplace is closed before the storm and says it will reopen afterward. Will I be paid?
A: Again, it depends on whether you are a hourly or salaried worker. Companies aren't obligated to pay hourly workers, although after last year's storms, several did. In most cases, employers are obligated to pay salaried workers a full week's salary, even if they are closed, but they can make you use your vacation or personal days.
Many labor lawyers, even those who represent employers, say that companies that follow the letter of the law risk seriously damaging employee morale.
While it often depends on the size of the company, if an employer can afford to pay the workers, it's probably best to do so, says Epstein Becker & Green's Michael Casey.
"It's more difficult for small employers to pay people who don't work a couple of days. Larger companies are better positioned to absorb those extra costs, " he said, but added: "Most employers want to treat people fairly and help them. This would be a good time to do that."
Join the Discussion
Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.