Germany marks Kristallnacht’s 75th anniversary asking: What tips a society into madness?
11/08/2013 3:08 PM
12/23/2013 4:36 PM
Seventy-five years ago, Nechama Drober, a German Jew, looked out her bedroom window in the medieval port city of Koenigsberg to see her synagogue in flames.
Drober, now 86, recalls the horror. “The large temple with its golden cupola, it was the most beautiful synagogue I have ever seen.”
But she also remembers that it was only the beginning. “The next day, my dad was arrested, and our landlord evicted us. All I could think of was the song we had sung in summer camp the years before, ‘Jew, where in this world can you go?’”
Saturday marks the 75th anniversary of what Germans now call Reichspogromnacht, but which the rest of the world knows as calls Kristallnacht, or the Night of Broken Glass. By the time it was over, Nazi thugs had killed 91 Jews and taken 30,000 others prisoner, for deportation to concentration camps. Thousands of businesses and synagogues were burned or destroyed. It was far from the beginning of Nazi persecution of German Jews, but it is fair to say it was the beginning of the end, a single night of animalistic violence in Germany, Austria and the occupied region of Czechoslovakia.
It began Nov. 9, 1938, and bled over into the early hours of Nov. 10, and then into the next six and a half years. Nazi storm troopers kicked it off, smashing windows painted with “Jude” in white letters, battering some Jews. Others joined in, looting, taunting and spitting on the Jewish victims.
Deidre Berger, director of the American Jewish Committee in Berlin, works to ensure Germans don’t forget that night, and the descent into inhumanity it represented.
“It’s important to understand why the veneer of civilization was so easily cracked,” she said. She notes that there were many who stood against “this mass orgy of violence” against their longtime friends, neighbors and associates.
But there were more who joined in or stood by passively. That, she said, has to be an enduring lesson of Kristallnacht.
“It takes so little to tip the scales,” she said. “It really shows the fragility of political systems. In one night, so many who had grown up together, turned and attacked the dignity and the safety of their neighbors, laughed as they were arrested.”
At an event this week at the aptly named Topography of Terror documentation center built on the grounds of the Nazi Gestapo headquarters, Berlin Mayor Klaus Wowereit spoke about that lesson. Wowereit is openly gay, and while he did not make this point in his talk, Berliners know he, too, would have been targeted by the Nazis.
“At the same time, many neighbors remained indifferent, and I’m asking myself why over the years, so few came out and admitted: ‘I saw it, and looked the other way. Today, I am ashamed,’” he wondered about those who had witnessed the events.
“Many may have felt uncomfortable but also relieved when the victims had disappeared to camps,” he said. “Those who watched and kept silent when the synagogues were burned 75 years ago were aiders and abettors of the Holocaust.”
As such, he noted, “Today, it is part of our democracy that synagogues have to be protected day and night. We have to ask ourselves today, looking back, what would I have done?”
German historian Joerg Friedrich said in an interview that that question has been asked many times before. He noted American slavery as an example, and the century of racial violence that followed. “The scale of what the Nazis did is without parallel, of course,” he said. “But the human nature it exposed, for that there are other examples.”
German reactions on Reichspogromnacht (the Germans changed the word to “Reich Massacre Night” fearing that “Night of the Broken Glass” didn’t adequately sum up the horror of that night) are little different from what is seen today during a subway mugging.
“Some were appalled and moved to act,” Friedrich said. “Most were passive.”
Andreas Nachama, a historian and director of Topography of Terror, said in a talk about the lessons learned that it’s too easy to dismiss the events of the Nazi madness as simply that, a period of insanity.
“The night of Nov. 9, 1938, not only the Germans stood and watched, but so did the world,” he said, noting that photos of what had happened, and news reports of the night, were published around the world. “That is why we need to confront the past, to learn how to respond and warn whenever similar things happen in the world.”
For instance, he noted that since 1990, right-wing extremist violence has led to 184 deaths in Germany. While these numbers pale in comparison to Nazi atrocities, historians note that it’s important to remember that when the Nazis took control, they didn’t represent a majority of Germans. And there is evidence that Kristallnacht didn’t have full support even among Nazis.
Nachama said there have been periods of genocide and religious intolerance in other nations in the years since, despite the horrible example of the Nazis.
“Under the Nazis, there was murder and manslaughter from the very beginning, and Jews were marginalized and stripped of their civil rights,” he said. “But until Nov. 9, there was still scope for life, albeit a limited one. . . . We are commemorating the events all over Germany, in many ways. But not all is well yet.”
Experts say knowing exactly where the tipping point into madness sits is impossible. It clearly involves the loss of civility, of respect, of tolerance. Germans have spent the last year very publically remembering this night 75 years ago. Public art exhibits and concerts and speeches have focused on what was lost in the years following Kristallnacht, their tipping point.
Drober didn’t need the events to remember, though. That night, sitting up and watching her world burn marked the beginning of decades of suffering. “From 1941, we had to carry the yellow star on our clothing that said ‘Jew’ in the middle. Thus marked, people spat at us and pushed us from the sidewalk,” she remembered.
Her father survived the war as a slave laborer. When the Nazi world collapsed and the Soviets took over, he was sent to a Siberian labor camp. Her mother and brother died of starvation. It wasn’t until the Soviet Union collapsed and she was able to move to Israel that she felt free of oppression.
“Throughout my life, I could never forget what happened that night of Nov. 9, 1938,” she said. “It is good that Germany, my fatherland, remembers and commemorates what happened.”
McClatchy special correspondent Claudia Himmelreich contributed.
Join the Discussion
Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.