Contest seeks South Florida’s best block
A Miami Herald competition seeks readers’ nominations for the best urban block in South Florida to spur discussion of what goes into making a great city street.
07/21/2012 5:00 AM
08/08/2012 1:53 PM
Pick a city block in a great American urban neighborhood. What comes to mind?
Soho, Times Square or Park Slope in New York, perhaps? Or Chicago’s Magnificent Mile and Wicker Park? Maybe San Francisco’s North Beach, or Georgetown and Adams Morgan in D.C.?
Very different places all. But what do they have in common?
They’re great to walk along. There’s lots to do and look at, not least of all the people going about their day. The buildings on the block are tightly packed, and a variety of shops, restaurants and other spaces display any number of interesting things and activities.
Now think about South Florida. There are places like those here, too. Maybe they’re not as well known as the above, or so iconic, and maybe there are not quite so many and those we do have are scattered around.
But they’re here, and we’re asking you to find them.
The Miami Herald is holding an open competition to identify the best urban block in Miami-Dade, Broward or Palm Beach counties.
The idea: to engage South Floridians in a discussion about what makes for a rich urban texture as downtowns and urban districts, once all but left behind in the rush to the suburbs, spring back to life across the region.
The Herald is sponsoring the contest in conjunction with WLRN/Miami Herald News, El Nuevo Herald, the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation and the Townhouse Center, a new Miami non-profit that promotes the development of urban neighborhoods in the manner of classic cities — through small, attached buildings that can be adapted over time to different uses.
We are soliciting photographs and short videos of your favorite urban block in the three counties, accompanied by a brief explanation of why it’s the best. Entries will be judged by five expert jurors. The winner will get a block party. Individuals will get cash prizes for best photo and video presentations.
What do we mean by a block?
Basically a street, one-block long, fronted by buildings on either side. The buildings could also front a plaza, a small park or square, or a pedestrian-only passageway. There should be ample sidewalks, good buildings and a mix of shops, homes and activities to draw people to it. It can be old, or new, or a smooth blend of both.
We’re looking in particular for that hard-to-define combination of housing, commerce, work, transportation, street life and architecture that makes a block a great South Floridaplace, one to come back to time and again, and one to emulate as our towns and cities seek to rebuild their urban neighborhoods.
“A great block is a microcosm of a great city,’’ said Howard Davis, a professor of architecture at the University of Oregon and author of Living Over the Store, a definitive history of buildings that mix living and working, which many urbanists believe to be the basic building blocks of cities.
Here’s what Davis said when The Herald and The Townhouse Center’s Andrew Frey asked him to outline key elements of an ideal great block:
“I would encourage people to look for people. A single block, to me, is potentially big enough and diverse enough so that you’ve got a real variety of people, old and young, rich and poor, and there is a real diversity of uses. I would want to see that diversity of a city’s population reflected on the block,’’ he said.
“To me the local component is really important — businesses that have not been completely taken over by Gap and Starbucks. I think there is a real sense of community. It feels safe because people watch out for each other.
“The block feels vibrant from morning until night. You can be there at midnight as well as 10 o’clock in the morning and feel safe. And small kids feel comfortable there.
“I wouldn’t want to say there is a formula. Each block is different. All the buildings are not the same. A great block might have a uniqueness to it, but enough of all the other characteristics to make it lively.
“I don’t think that a great block necessarily excludes the car, but it’s a great place to walk.“And a great block, of course, has people living over the store.’’
Here are some other things to look for, Frey said:• Continuous buildings, with no more than one narrow parking lot or vacant lot, garage entrance or loading bay to interrupt the flow.
• A mix of uses in the buildings, particularly on the ground floor but on upper floors as well, with various shops, offices, restaurants and/or residences. Hint: a convenient mix of uses is most likely found on a block with many separate, small, adaptable buildings, rather than one or two large, single-use buildings.
• Sidewalks wide enough for multiple human activities, such as walking and dining. Bonus: public transportation stop, bike lane, car sharing-space or other non-car transportation facility.
• Trees, canopies, or other sun and rain protection plus a sprinkling of intangibles like beauty, architectural style, sense of place, culture.
If all that sounds like a lot, it is. A great block packs a lot into a compact area.
Don’t be discouraged. That doesn’t mean that South Florida’s best block must have all those elements. But it should have at least some.
After all, Davis said, there are many great blocks in cities across the country — from Berkeley, San Diego and Portland on the west coast to Brooklyn in the Northeast — that may not be spectacular, or iconic, or even look that great in a photograph, but possess those special urban qualities and energy that many Americans are now hunting for.
“People are starting to understand what this is really about,’’ he said. “I think these ideas are really very much in the public consciousness now.’’
Join the Discussion
Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.