Privately, Israeli officials wary of Morsi presidency in Egypt
06/26/2012 12:00 AM
06/27/2012 9:18 AM
Israeli officials are eyeing warily the ascendancy of Mohammed Morsi to Egypt’s presidency, but they say for now that they think Egypt’s military has effectively tied his hands in one of the areas of greatest concern to Israel: cooperation in isolating the Hamas-ruled Gaza Strip.
Longer term, however, they think that Morsi, a member of the Muslim Brotherhood who’s been sharply critical of Egypt’s peace treaty with Israel, is likely to have a negative influence on Israeli-Egyptian relations and on Israel’s relationships with other countries in the region.
“This is a man we don’t feel will be interested in enhancing the ties between Israel and Egypt. This is a man who might want to weaken those ties,” said an official in Israel’s Foreign Ministry who spoke only on the condition of anonymity because Israel’s official line toward Morsi’s election has been positive. “There is a lot of concern that Israel will be dealing with a new reality on the ground.”
Israeli officials fretted particularly about what Morsi’s approach might be to the Gaza Strip, which had celebrated the victory of the Brotherhood, long a close ally of the Islamist group Hamas. Medics in Gaza reported that the celebratory gunfire was so intense that one Palestinian was killed and three others wounded Sunday night after Morsi’s win was announced.
"We will look to Egypt to play a big, leading role, a historic role, regarding the Palestinian cause, in helping the Palestinian nation get freedom, return home and totally end the Gaza siege," Ismail Haniyeh, the head of the Hamas government in Gaza, said in welcoming Morsi’s victory.
But Israeli officials think it’s unlikely that Egypt will move quickly to break Israel’s blockade of Gaza by opening the crossing point to Egypt at Rafah, where Egypt has long restricted the movement of goods and people in cooperation with Israel. They note that Egypt’s Supreme Council of the Armed Forces blocked any change in the Rafah situation last week, when it removed foreign policy from the new president’s authority.
“Israel would be in a very difficult position if Egypt chose to do this, to legitimize Hamas in this way,” the Israeli Foreign Ministry official said.
Legislator Benjamin Ben-Eliezer, Israel’s former defense minister and a close friend of ousted Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak, said it was likely that Egypt’s military would maintain whatever ties with Israel were necessary to continue receiving $2 billion in aid annually from the United States.
Ben-Eliezer said Morsi was likely to chip away at the Egypt-Israel peace treaty through a series of public referendums: “Morsi will want to do as little as possible with Israel while making sure he keeps the American billions.”
He said that one of the tenets of the treaty – a deal that provides Israel with 40 percent of its natural gas – would be the first to be “re-evaluated.”
Over the last year, frequent attacks on the gas pipeline that runs from Egypt’s northern Sinai peninsula into Israel have forced Israel to turn elsewhere for fuel. In April, the Egyptian side of the joint venture that sells natural gas to Israel announced that it was terminating the deal.
“This was the first sign, the first indicator, that the peace deal was unraveling,” said Zvi Mazel, Israel’s former ambassador to Egypt. “It does not bode well.”
The gas deal was unpopular among many Egyptians, who thought that Mubarak’s cronyism with Ben-Eliezer and others had given Israel a favorable rate at the expense of state coffers.
“What they felt about the gas deal, many feel about the peace deal,” Mazel said.
While Israeli officials stressed that they don’t expect relations with Egypt to descend into outright hostility, the new political dynamic in Egypt is forcing Israeli defense planners to “reconsider priorities.”
Over the last decade Israeli has fought a war against the militant Islamist group Hezbollah in the north and within the Gaza Strip. Both wars, Israeli military officials said, were made possible because Israel could rely on its southern border with Egypt remaining quiet.
“You can only fight on so many fronts at once,” said a military commander in Israel’s south who also spoke to McClatchy on the condition of anonymity. “We could commit ourselves against threats in the north partially because we could leave the southern border a little less secure.”
He said that when Israel launched Operation Cast Lead, a monthlong military assault on Gaza that started in December 2008, it knew that Egypt would keep its border with Gaza shut. “If we have to start thinking of that southern border as a question mark, as a possible border for hostilities, it will limit the military’s capabilities to fight elsewhere,” he said.
On Tuesday, unconfirmed reports quoted Morsi as telling the Iranian news agency Fars that strengthening ties between Egypt and Iran was a priority for the new Egyptian government. Israeli officials have yet to respond to the report, which some called “a fabrication.”
“If the report is true,” the Israeli military commander said, “then Israel has a whole new world of problems.”
Join the Discussion
Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.