After a series of paperback thrillers that have landed on the bestseller lists, Jennifer McMahon makes her foray into hardcover with one of the year’s most chilling novels. She melds the mystery genre with the supernatural for a psychological thriller that is as scary as it is enthralling.
Every small town has a ghost story that stems from an abandoned house that children avoid, a dark wood into which no one ventures, a graveyard where the fog seems to settle or an unsolved murder. West Hall, Vt., has all that and more. Back in 1908, Sara Harrison Shea and her husband, Martin, lived on an unproductive farm outside of town. Every day Martin sees the dying crops, the bare root cellar and feels “the sour creep of failure work its way . . . into his chest” while Sara believes their land is cursed. The bright spot in their lives is their daughter Gertie. When Gertie is found dead in an abandoned well, Sara is convinced that she can bring her child back to life.
That story of Sara and her family resonates in the present day with 19-year-old Ruthie Washburne, who now lives in Sara’s former house. When Ruthie’s mother disappears, the teenager looks into West Hall’s dark past that includes a string of disappearances and unexplained happenings.
McMahon’s in-depth exploration of each character elevates The Winter People, making each aspect of the story believable, even when things go bump in the night, and she makes a smooth transition as she alternates the story between the past and the present.
Oline H. Cogdill reviewed this book for the Sun Sentinel.