To Mandalay and Beyond: Behind Myanmar's bamboo veil
Posted on Tue, May. 06, 2008
By JANE WOOLDRIDGE
Special to the Miami Herald
JANE WOOLDRIDGE / MIAMI HERALD STAFF
Bagan, Myanmar, November 2001. The region contains 3000 temples dating from the 11-13th Centuries.
Yangoon, Myanmar --
Editor's note: Myanmar -- also known as Burma -- was recently devasted by a massive cyclone. This 2002 story by Miami Herald Travel Editor Jane Wooldridge offers a glimpse into this isolated country.
-----
YANGON, Myanmar - The broom ladies appear at dusk, dozens of women in long dark skirts sweeping the
dusty day from the cool stone terrace. The last orange glints of sun sparkle against the mountainous
gold-leaf dome of Shwedagon, Yangon's vast temple. The terrace takes on a greenish hue, overflow
from the fluorescent bulbs now lighting literally thousands of Buddha statues standing sentry about
the platform.
Incense, tart and sweet, drifts past. Beneath a pavilion, a half-dozen monks swathed in cotton
the color of koi chant before a swirling image of a Buddha surrounded by flashing lights and
another, on a video screen.
A gong tones.
A bald-shaven teenager in monk's orange approaches, firmly shakes hands.
"Hello. Where are you from?" 'America' brings a wide grin. Here, at least, it's not a dirty word.
Here, China plays the heavy.
'Here' is the land known by British Colonials as Burma, a flame-shaped wedge of Southeast Asia
that is touched by Thailand, India, Bangladesh, China and Laos. Slightly smaller than Texas, it lays
claim to 21/2 times the population - about 50 million. Since 1988, when a military junta took
control, the country has been called Myanmar, though the U.S. - which bans investment there by U.S.
citizens - still calls it Burma.
Among rights activists, taking a holiday in Myanmar / Burma is generally considered sleeping with
the enemy. Visit the country, they argue, and you contribute financially to a repressive junta that
has ignored election results and silenced opposition leader and Nobel Peace Prize winner Aung San
Suu Kyi.
WHY GO?
Why, you might ask, would someone even want to visit a poor, overpopulated country with limited
facilities and a government philosophically aligned with Attila the Hun? But adventure is as
personal as the novels you sneak when no one from work can see you. For some, adventure means some
physical challenge; for others, it's a chance to let go of caution and let happen what may. For me,
it's dipping a toe into the relative purity of cultures not yet devoured by an insane pace, stock
market fever and Survivor. And places where Buddhism dominates hold special appeal for me.
Myanmar - largely secluded from the West for much of the Old Century - surely fits the bill. But
visiting felt treacherous, like going to South Africa during the apartheid years or taking a holiday
in a posh Havana hotel when so many of my neighbors' lives have been ripped apart by the Castro
regime.
Recently, though, things seemed to be looking up. In October 2000, the junta began closed-door
reconciliation talks with Aung San, who remains under house arrest. Two dozen offices of Aung San's
National League for Democracy, closed in the mid-1990s, have reopened. Some believe a recent shakeup
within the junta indicates the government is serious about eliminating corruption. And while it is
illegal for U.S. citizens to visit Cuba without permission from the U.S. government, Myanmar is fair
game for Americans.
Final absolution came from Lonely Planet founder and independent travel guru Tony Wheeler,
roundly criticized for publishing a guide to Myanmar. Last January, he and his wife returned to
Myanmar to decide for themselves if tourist dollars were going to local people or simply propping up
the government. His findings: that local people were better off now than in the late '80s, that
contact with outsiders was important to them, that locals often talked openly about the government,
that even supporters of Suu Kyi see tourism as a protection against the military. And yes, that
much of the money spent goes directly to their pockets.
Conscience salved, my husband and I were off for 11 days in The Golden Land, the centerpiece of
an Asian vacation. Our journey would take us to the capital, Yangon, to traditional villages
surrounding the vast and shallow Inle Lake, on to the mythical Mandalay, into the mountains to an
old British hill station, and down the muddy Irrawaddy to the archaeological center of Bagan. It
wouldn't be nearly enough.
THE CAPITAL
Jeffrey Meyers, author of a biography on writer George Orwell, who spent five years in Burma
during the 1920s, recently described Yangon as "a rich widow fallen on hard times . . . a
broken-down and depressing city - more like Calcutta than the thriving capitals of Southeast Asia."
True, Yangon is far from the catch she might have been in her debutante days. But the crow's-feet
and wrinkles are testament to a vigorous life filled with contradictions and conundrums, and she has
plenty yet to come.
The long road from airport to town is, surprisingly, a greenway leading past lakes and lush
gardens and closer to town, signs advertising MacBurger - an impostor - and a local rip-off of
Denny's. A swing past the huge park that is home to Shwedagon temple leads to the town center, a
bustle of hawkers and orange-robed monks, bicycle-powered trishaws and belching autos, Colonial
architectural delights covered with grime.
For expats and travelers, the nexus of life here has always been the Strand, an outpost of the
Raj built in 1901 that, in its day, was considered "the finest hostelry east of Suez." Time and
history brought the usual havoc. During World War II, the Japanese used part of the hotel for a
stable, and at one point a bomb came careening through the roof and landed unexploded - a local
curiosity before it was hauled away. In the mid '90s, The Strand was restored to its former polish,
a retreat of ceiling fans and teak inlays in a marble floor, of afternoon tea and traditional
Burmese music that lingers, sweet and sad, like a stolen kiss. On Friday nights the bar hops with
jazz music.
The hotel faces Strand Road, a ribbon through the Colonial district that edges the park
separating city from shipping industry along the Irrawaddy. This is Asia as it has been for
centuries. A huge fish tail hangs out of a large basket strapped to the back of a man striding past,
dressed in the traditional sarong-like longyi. Another carries a wooden yoke across his shoulders,
balancing baskets of oranges and limes. Every sidewalk is a market, books to bananas. A long queue
waits to buy bread from the back of a truck.
A trishaw wheels past, flowers sprouting jauntily from a vase strapped to the handlebars. Traffic
stops as a line of monks clutching rattan fans crosses the busy road. A child-nun in pink robes
hurries past.
It's undoubtedly arrogant to think of some place as poor as Yangon as charming; it's only that
way if you're a foreigner for whom the $1 taxi fare or $4 lunch for two is so cheap its laughable.
Still, there is something beguiling about it all. Melancholy, too. If you have traveled Asia in
recent times, you can guess what this place will become. Already, a few soul-less towers have
cropped up like overgrown weeds, like the condos and malls and offices that have replaced
once-traditional neighborhoods in Bangkok, Hong Kong, Beijing, Singapore. Billboards advertise
English lessons and classes in Microsoft computing, the Cash Box karaoke bar and the international
Mr. Universe bodybuilding contest held there last November.
"Toward a new, modern, developed nation," reads the official government slogan posted outside the
airport - a government that claims 2001 as a "winning" year despite a recent report by the Asian
Development Bank that the country spends only .17 percent of its GDP on education and .3 percent on
healthcare, with an annual inflation rate of 27.2 percent. Already, a sign announces the entrance to
the government's Department of Medical Sciences Stress Management Center.
But not yet.
We wander the crowded streets, stopping in a country music bar and eatery called City Point,
where fried fish sandwiches are served up with cuts of Me and You and A Dog Named Blue and Let Me Be
There in the Morning.
A friendly taxi driver - many speak decent English - takes us to Shwedagon. We pull off our
shoes, climb a wide stair lined with shops selling Buddhist prayer beads and statues - and up to the
temple for the end-of-day ritual and a sprinkle of broom lady dust.
INLE LAKE
The flight from Yangon takes less time than the taxi ride from the small airport to the lake
itself, a bumpy sway past ox carts, military transport trucks and the occasional tourist bus. Fields
glow with yellow blooms and the gold of stupas that dot every sweep of landscape. The earth is red
enough to make Georgia clay cry with jealousy.
The lake is a yawning but shallow inland sea, the Lake Okeechobee of the land stretching some 14
miles long, ringed by mountains and sheltered with a sky that, by night, seems filled with glitter.
Our hotel is two-thirds of the way down lake; the ride in a motorized canoe takes an hour.
We aren't alone. Dozens of other water taxis hum about the lake, loaded with monks, farm wives
with huge baskets of tomatoes and beans, tourists. Surprising numbers of tourists.
Our hotel is an upmarket version of a traditional lake village, a series of simple woven grass
cottages on stilts. (Ours have indoor bathrooms; the locals mostly use the lake.)
The lure of Inle - along with its physical beauty - is the traditional ways that dominate.
Fishermen angle with wooden fish traps tall as Michael Jordan. The lake's chief crop is tomatoes
grown on fertile floating islands of seaweed and soil anchored with bamboo poles.
Men - never women - row flat-bottomed canoes in the region's traditional way, standing with one
leg wrapped around the oar for a powerful stroke that doesn't tire arms and shoulders. In October,
crews of 40 or more men race this way on ornate ceremonial barges at the annual Phaung Daw U
festival.
The daily market rotates among five villages. Most farmers and shoppers come as we do, by boat;
others by foot or ox cart, loaded with emerald chilies and saffron-colored corn and beans the size
of a child's fist; tomatoes, fish fresh or dried or salted; tangy fried tofu snacks. The country may
be poor but the land is rich, and no one seems hungry. Tribal women - there are eight major primary
ethnic groups living near the lake - wrap their heads in bright plaid cloths to block the sun. Men
and women both wear longyis and carry bright woven shoulder bags.
The people are friendly, laughing with us, happy to have us snap their photos, delighted when we
show them their images in the video display of a digital camera. All, that is, except the man who
runs the gambling booths, where shoppers plunk down their kyat on a decorated square and hope the
giant falling dice will land with a matching symbol. "No photos!" he snarls. A new security recruit
for Vegas.
A dozen or so tables are covered with souvenirs - a recent phenomenon, says our guide, a college
student who works at the hotel and studies by correspondence at the regional university, thanks to
his tribe's scholarship program. The tables are piled with aged temple carvings, accordion-folded
prayer books, Buddha images, small touristy weight sets - all illegal to remove from the country, we
later learn. But their owners are anxious to sell; items initially priced $120 drop by 80 percent
with haggling.
For two days, we motor from market to village to "factories" - cottages where silver jewelry,
brilliant silks, cigars, ironwork and parasols are made with careful hands, one by one. Fascinating
to watch as the silver beads are cast into molds, the umbrellas shades dotted with pressed
wildflowers; cheaper, we learn, to buy in the markets.
Religious monuments in white or gold leaf dot villages and riverbanks; there are more than 200
monasteries here. The 120-year-old wooden Nga Phe Kyaung is noted theoretically for its Buddha
images, but tourists come as much to see the jumping cats, who leap on command through small hoops.
The holiest of the temples is Phaung Daw U, home to five 12th Century statues, so revered that the
gold leaf rubbed on them as offerings have obscured their shape. During the annual fall festival,
the statues are carried about the lake on ceremonial barges; it is said that some years ago, when
one of the barges capsized, only four of the statues were recovered. Yet when monks returned with
them to the monastery, the fifth was already in its proper place.
In a place like this, you can almost believe such magic is real.
MANDALAY
Despite posh hotels and a new airport slicker than MIA, Mandalay is something of a
disappointment. The Mandalay Fort - a huge walled compound built in the mid 19th Century - is a poor
reconstruction of the original wooden palace, devastated by fire in 1945. The temple atop the 977
steps - yes, we counted - of Mandalay Hill offers great views but is otherwise uninspiring; the walk
is dotted with temples and statues but seems shabby. The busy streets were dustier and less
interesting than in Yangon. Better was the area around Mahamuni temple, where craftsmen carve the
giant Buddha statues that appear throughout the country.
Come evening, we visit the underground a-nyeint pwe performance of the Mustache Brothers. Pwe is
a traditional form of entertainment involving music and comic skits about everyday life. In the case
of the Mustache Brothers, this has sometimes involved jokes that point at the foibles of the
government - a practice that has landed one of the brothers in prison and put others under watch,
which is why their performance is slightly underground. But it's not hard to find - the Lonely
Planet guide features it on a map - and the family of performers welcomes publicity. It was the
adverse publicity attracted when director Rob Reiner got involved, says a brother, that led to the
early release of the jailed Par Par Lay two years shy of his seven-year sentence.
Indeed, Mandalay seemed less buoyant, a bit more restrictive than Yangon. Though we were welcome
to go nearly everywhere we wanted on our rented bikes, huge signs at the Mandalay Fort made it clear
we would be arrested and deported if we deviated from the main palace road to other parts of the
fort grounds. A massive billboard on a main road proclaim "The People's Desire" - English-language
propaganda reminding visitors of the official line.
We follow the British Raj and head for the hills just beyond the city.
Warned of the long train ride from Yangon to Mandalay, we substitute a four-hour chug to Pyin U
Lwin, a summer retreat for heat-weary Brits at the turn of the last century. Even in first class,
the granite-hard benches are barely padded. Lwin is a sweet and dusty town, with horse carts as
taxis, a smattering of Colonial houses and a pretty but unremarkable botanical garden. The music
blaring from the speakers outside the temples prevented us from venturing inside.
One reason to come here is to stay at Candacraig, once a British officers chummery where the Raj
lives on - without the glamour. The wide porches invited a book and a cup of tea, though we never
managed the second. The food was traditional English, which is to say overcooked and bland. The
high-ceilinged rooms were spare and, at night, downright cold, with none of the cheery warmth the
fireplace would have thrown off in days of the Raj. Still, it was a chance to sleep in history.
Sore, we pass on the train ride back to Mandalay in favor of an hour-long taxi ride. It is
morning, school time, and the potholed road is lined with children whose parents can afford to pay
for school. In crisp white shirts and deep green longyi, they travel on bicycles, on foot, packed
into group jitneys. Families with small children arrive on trishaw - dad peddling with a child in
his lap, two wedged into the forward-looking sidecar seat and one or two wedged on the seat looking
back. The family minibus. Women in fuchsia, morning-glory blue, sunflower yellow glow against the
green fields. A queue of monks in ocher robes snakes along the road, stopping for morning alms of
rice from locals along the road.
A worthy show for $10, taxi ride included.
BAGAN
On the Irrawaddy, the tourist ferry is middle ground, a leap up from the crowded local ferry and
a long step down from The Road to Mandalay luxury cruise-tour operated by Orient Express. With
reclining seats and a restaurant, it offers comforts enough for the eight-hour trip through the
misty sunrise, past iridescent fields punctuated with stupas. At Bagan, though, the dock is no more
than a long plank down to a mud bank; well worth the dollar to help with bags.
Bagan is to Myanmar what Ankor Wat is to Cambodia, Giza is to Egypt, Tikal is to Guatemala,
Chichen Itza is to Mexico - a testament to a time when their cultures were the cultures, and others
looked on in awe.
It is true that in 1975, an earthquake rocked the area, bringing many temples to rubble. But, to
paraphrase Mark Twain, reports of its demise have been overstated. Today some 2,000-3,000 of the
stupas and temples remain over 19 square miles, though many are reconstructions.
The monuments date from the 11th to 13th centuries, when wars were commanded from atop elephants
and kings were said to be felled by magic bows. Some monuments are short and stout, molded mounds of
clay; others reach 200 feet and shimmer with gilded promise. A few retain intricate ceiling
paintings - most were chiseled out long ago. One is used in ordination ceremonies when a young man
or woman enters the monastery or nunnery. In another, the huge Buddha statues seem to be smiling or
frowning, depending on the angle from which you view them.
But it's not the individual stupas and temples that tickle the imagination, but the sheer number
of them. Stand at sunset on a high terrace, watch from a balloon at sunrise, meander through them on
the back of a horse cart or the seat of bicycle - the place feels like an illusion, but it is real.
And serene.
Villagers were uprooted from their homes in the archaeological zone - rudely, with two weeks'
notice - some years back. Today the monuments sit alone in tall grass, by muddy paths more suited to
ox carts than tour buses. Cars are few, and there is only a handful of delightful hotels and small
restaurants at the edge of the temple complex, along the river. The only distraction is the souvenir
hawkers, nudging you to buy cheap lacquer coasters or cloth paintings. You can't blame them; a man
may work a day or more on a cloth painting that sells for a few dollars.
Far better ware comes from the nearby village of Myinkaba, center of Myanmar's lacquerware
industry. Here, lacquered pieces are made as they have been for centuries, with time and care on a
dirt floor beneath the shade of a wooden lean-to. The base vessel - a small box, large platter, vase
or stand - is woven from horsehair or bamboo; some are made from hard bamboo. The lacquer - from a
tree in a neighboring state - is painted on in a single color, then a design scratched upon it. Each
color of the design requires a different layer of lacquer. A piece of the best quality takes 14
coats, in a process that can take seven months.
Prices aren't cheap - a large, high-quality piece can cost hundreds of dollars, even here - but
they are negotiable. And so we find ourselves traipsing from family to family, examining the quality
and designs and prices. By days' end, we've convinced a shopkeeper to build a crate that will hold
not only the bowl we've bought from him, but also the giant puppet from Mandalay, the hat and
platter from Inle Lake, the lacquer that will be Christmas presents, the pots we hope to make into
lamps.
The holidays are past, and the crate - promised weeks ago - has yet to arrive. We've got our
fingers crossed. Meanwhile, we've got our memories, and the wonder that comes with a modern-day
visit into that National Geographic pages of decades past.
And yes, some sadness. People here may speak their minds, but quietly. "We'd rather have Aung
San," one said, "but people want peace, too."
Join the discussion
The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from personal comments and remarks that are off point. In order to post comments, you must be a registered user of MiamiHerald.com. Your username will show along with the comments you post. Not a registered user? It's Free!
Register here. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.