With IRS embroiled, time is right to repeal federal income tax


The Philadelphia Inquirer

A high-level official of the Internal Revenue Service declares her innocence before a congressional committee and then asserts the Fifth Amendment right that she had effectively just waived. Incriminating emails have surfaced, while others are declared lost. An arrogant IRS commissioner declares that none of this amounts to anything for which he should apologize on behalf of his agency.

Widespread corruption, and stunning technological incompetence and ineptitude, some of it possibly criminal, are all quite awful for confidence in our government and its tax agency — or are they? Could all of this actually present us with a golden moment for reform?

The problem began not with the targeting of conservative organizations by the IRS, but in 1913, with the passage of the 16th Amendment, which allowed Congress to levy an income tax.

A toxic stew of class envy had formed in the late 19th century, when the combination of labor strife from the onset of the Industrial Revolution mixed with the ascendant Prussian progressive idea that government bureaucracies of experts could run society better than free citizens making their own choices. In that environment, a movement to redistribute income from the rich to the not-as-rich gained enough momentum to allow for the passage of a federal income tax. After that income tax was declared unconstitutional, the 16th Amendment expressly permitting one was ratified.

By allowing Congress to tax incomes, the 16th Amendment gave the government the right to compel citizens to disclose their most private information. The Fourth Amendment, the “right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects,” was set aside. The federal government now had the power of a “general warrant” to compel the disclosure of Americans’ financial information and the production of their papers and effects.

The British use of “writs of assistance” — general warrants that gave an officer of the crown the power to search any house or person to look for evidence of a crime at any hour of the day or night — was among the complaints that led to the American Revolution.

The writs violated the English legal tradition on privacy that went back to the Magna Carta of 1215. The English jurist Sir Edward Coke (1552-1634) had famously written that “a man’s house is his castle.” Prime Minister William Pitt, popular in America during the French and Indian War, reinforced this tradition when he said, “(T)he poorest man may in his cottage bid defiance to all the forces of the crown. It may be frail – its roof may shake – the wind may blow through it, the storms may enter, the rain may enter, but the King of England cannot enter! All his force dares not cross the threshold of the ruined tenement.”

In 1886, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in Boyd v. United States that a federal revenue statute requiring a person to produce his personal papers was unconstitutional.

This long-standing principle in British and U.S. law of respecting privacy was compromised for ordinary citizens by the 16th Amendment. America turned its back on a 700-year Anglo-American principle.

Perhaps, then, the current IRS scandal, which threatens American liberty and undermines the Constitution far more than anything that happened in the Watergate scandal, presents us with a historic opportunity. Instead of merely investigating and holding committee hearings, we can seize the moment and recognize that 101 years ago, our nation made a terrible mistake. We can admit that the 16th Amendment, requiring people to disclose to the U.S. government information so personal that they wouldn’t ordinarily reveal it even to their closest family and friends, was a grave mistake, and reverse course.

Besides being unjust and an invitation to tyranny, the income tax is a demonstrably inefficient way to raise revenue for the government. For example, research commissioned by Americans for Fair Taxation found that the U.S. economy loses at least $200 billion every year just trying to comply with the income tax.

Let’s be done with the corruption, arrogance and waste of the IRS and recover our privacy and prosperity at the same time. Let’s sunset the entire unwieldy Internal Revenue Code at a date certain, like 2020 (has a certain visionary ring to it, doesn’t it?), and then work out a simpler, fairer system like the Fair Tax, or another consumption tax. Why not let Americans keep their money until they decide to spend it at the cash register for goods or services?

There’s a kind of delicious irony in the possibility that public shock at IRS abuses could lead to the agency’s own demise — and the restoration of principles of freedom and privacy that go back to 1215. The Magna Carta’s 800th anniversary next year is a worthy target for this reform to begin.

Colin Hanna is president of Let Freedom Ring, a Pennsylvania-based public policy organization focusing on constitutional government, economic freedom and traditional values.

©2014 McClatchy-Tribune

Read more From Our Inbox stories from the Miami Herald

  • Ten truths about day jobs

    1. Never look down on somebody who holds a job and rides the bus to the end of the line. These are the people who labor their whole lives but are never rewarded with tangible success. Not every dog has its day; some simply work their tails off. My father was one of those guys: never missed a day, never missed a beat and barely made a dime. But he taught my brother and me how to get a job done. Old Italians would grab their kids and say, “The more you have in there,” pointing to our heads, “the less you have to put on there,” pointing to our backs. My brother and I benefited from my father’s integrity, his stamina and his gratitude for having a job.

  • When the world blows up, blame hip-hop

    It was only a matter of time. A violent convergence of domestic and international events has us all feeling as if the world is falling off its axis. Headlines telling of rioters rocking Ferguson, Mo., are intersected with constant flashes of black-masked Islamic State marauders leaving bloody trails of decapitated heads as they pillage the Middle Eastern desert. And in the inevitable reach to explain the Four Horsemen chaos of assorted colored folk shaking it up, the best dissertation the mainstream media can find is that it must be hip-hop’s fault.

  • I studied engineering, not English. I still can’t find a job.

    When I graduated from Penn State a year ago, I thought I was perfectly prepared to succeed in the business world. I’d worked hard, graduated at the top of my class in computer science and managed to acquire lots of experience with the sorts of industry software that I was sure hiring managers were looking for. I’d even chosen a STEM degree, which — according to just about everyone — is the smartest choice to plan for the future (eight out of the 10 fastest growing job occupations in the United States are STEM jobs).

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category