University of Florida researchers find evidence that shows bass learn to avoid certain fishing lures

Anglers in saltwater and fresh water have been insisting for generations that fish get “smarter” — refusing to bite certain baits after repeated encounters.

But a team of researchers from the University of Florida’s Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences program has come close to proving this old axiom scientifically.

Graduate student Nick Cole and colleagues — all avid bass anglers — conducted an experiment in a private, 27-acre lake outside Gainesville in 2012 “to see if catch-and-release angling would make fish more or less vulnerable for subsequent catches and whether that vulnerability would be different between very different lure types,” Cole explained.

Devil’s Hole Lake had very little angling pressure when the scientists/fishermen got there. But before breaking out rod and reel, they used electro-fishing gear to gauge the bass population — 347 fish greater than 10 inches. Then UF technicians Matt Young and Davis Waldorf fished three days per week for four weeks using two very different lures — a chrome-and-black lipless Rat-L-Trap crankbait and a four-inch, plum-and-emerald-flake Gary Yamamoto Senko stick bait fished weightless with a 3/0 offset worm hook. Both lures were attached to 20-pound braided line with a four-foot, 20-pound-test fluorocarbon leader.

“We picked them because they are commonly used bass lures,” Cole said. “We wanted to look at two ends of the tackle spectrum.

“The Rat-L-Traps are loud and flashy. With the Senko, there’s not a lot of vibration going on.”

To eliminate bias over different angler skill levels, the researchers fished each lure for an hour and then switched for the next hour throughout the day. They tagged the bass they caught with individually marked electronic tags, then let them go.

Over a period of four weeks, they caught and released 260 bass ranging from eight to 20 inches.

“We found strong evidence that bass learned to avoid capture, particularly for the lipless crankbait,” Cole wrote.

He said recapture rates for the flashy Rat-L-Trap declined substantially — from 2.5 fish per hour to only .25 fish per hour. Recapture rates for the Senko also declined, but not as much — dropping from 1.8 fish per hour to about one fish per hour. The crankbait had the lowest number of recaptures, with only two bass caught twice. With the stick bait, 20 fish were caught twice.

To avoid capture, Cole said, bass might have recognized a lure once they ate it and declined to bite the next time they saw it, or they might have moved to a deeper area of the lake where it would be more difficult for anglers to reach them, or they simply might have become more passive and fed less on whatever came their way.

“We don’t know what that behavior was exactly, but we know there was an impact,” Cole said. “We were able to show very different rates in how vulnerability was changing and different catch rates between the lures.”

Future studies, he said, could test a broader array of fishing lures in a tank, for example, observing fish reactions to them. And he said scientists need to look at how angling pressure affects fish behavior.

“That’s an important topic for management in the future,” Cole said.

Bass anglers should probably take their cue from successful pros such as Kevin VanDam and others who change lures and tactics frequently and still manage to catch big bass consistently.

Read more Outdoors stories from the Miami Herald

Boaters and divers look for lobster off Cape Florida on Wednesday July 30, 2014.


    Ex-Penn football player dies on dive during lobster miniseason

    A Broward man lost his life diving on the first day of the lobster miniseason. He might have run out of air.

  • Fishing report

    Captain Gil Gutierrez of Lucky Fishing Charters out of TNT Marina in Keystone reported that nighttime snapper fishing on the reefs offshore of Miami has been red hot. Plenty of mangrove, mutton and yellowtail snappers are biting cut bait over the reef in depths of 25 to 60 feet of water. Captain Bill Hauck from the party boat Sea King out of Marathon reported the nighttime mangrove snapper fishing on the reef is off the chart. Nighttime snapper anglers are having no problem catching a limit of snappers, which are eating ballyhoo and threadfin herring.

  • Outdoors notebook

    Off-road vehicles such as swamp buggies, street-legal 4x4s, ATVs and UTVs will be allowed back in the Big Cypress National Preserve on Friday, marking the end of the annual 60-day recreational closure to ORV access. Only the designated primary trails in the backcountry will be open. All secondary trails will remain closed for an additional 60 days. The closure does not affect landowners’ access to private property using permitted trails. For more information, visit

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category