Argentina’s big loss at the Supreme Court

The world would be a much better place if Argentina were more like Detroit. Messed up as the Motor City’s finances may be, at least the city is covered by U.S. bankruptcy law, under which the municipal government and its creditors are working out a binding settlement under the supervision of a federal judge.

One way or another, Detroit’s debt nightmare will end, and the city will get a fresh start. No bankruptcy system applies to nations, though. “The entire sovereign debt system is set up around unenforceable contracts,” Anna Gelpern, a Georgetown University law professor who specializes in this arcane area, told me. Scary thought, that.

So, when a country like Argentina defaults, strange things can happen. In years gone by, the U.S. Navy might show up demanding gold. Nowadays, we have epic legal clashes such as the one between Buenos Aires and Wall Street hedge funds, which has just culminated in victory for the hedgies at the U.S. Supreme Court.

Fought out in courtrooms and the pages of major newspapers, where the two sides hurled vitriolic rhetoric at each other in paid advertisements, the case pitted the irresponsible populists who ran Argentina into the ground against financiers who insisted on every last dollar owed them. Argentina’s hard-pressed people will be the losers no matter what happens, you can be sure.

Still, the hedge funds’ victory may ultimately serve the global public interest, if there is such a thing. For both sovereign debtors and those who would lend them money, it amounts to a needed reminder about the actual risks involved in borrowing and lending on lightly regulated global financial markets and, possibly, an incentive to deal with those risks more transparently.

Absent global bankruptcy law, countries and creditors seek a second-best solution: bond agreements, a key provision of which is that any disputes get decided in U.S. courts. Humiliating as that may be to the Argentinas of the world, no one would lend them money without contractually guaranteed recourse to a venue where the rule of law is well established.

The Supreme Court left intact New York court rulings to the effect that a standard provision of Argentina’s bonds put a small minority of holdout hedge funds in line to get paid ahead of the majority that accepted pennies on the dollar when Argentina “restructured” its debts. And the courts put teeth in that ruling by forbidding other New York banks from facilitating bond payments by Argentina until the holdouts are satisfied.

The legal reasoning was complex but boiled down to this: Tough luck, Argentina. You knew — or should have known — what you were getting into when you sold the bonds, which included a waiver of your sovereign immunity.

Checkmated, Buenos Aires faces this choice: Pay the hedgies $1.3 billion, which might open the door to an additional $15 billion in claims by others, or lose access to the U.S. financial system. A separate Supreme Court ruling empowers the hedge funds to identify Argentine assets around the world, the prelude to seizing them.

This threatens Argentina’s economy but probably not the world’s. To be sure, the Obama administration and the International Monetary Fund argue otherwise; according to them, a victory for the hedge funds creates a dangerous precedent for future sovereign debt crises.

Their view is that tilting the legal balance in favor of potential holdouts would make it harder to negotiate restructuring deals when necessary for global financial stability. Certainly Greece’s creditors made the world sweat before finally accepting a “haircut” that enabled that country’s bailout.

But perhaps that status quo needed this shake-up. It may instill a new sense of caution in both borrowers and lenders, because now they’re on notice to deal with each other in frank anticipation of holdouts in the event of default.

Debt restructuring and IMF bailouts are, at best, a necessary evil. Along with preserving them as a last resort, we should be figuring out how to prevent them. And one way to do that is to discourage countries from living beyond their means in the first place.

Charles Lane is on the editorial board of The Washington Post.

© 2014, The Washington


Read more Other Views stories from the Miami Herald

Tony Lesesne


    Tony Lesesne: Overkill, and an apology

    Yes, it happens in South Florida, too — and it shouldn’t. Black men pulled over, needlessly hassled by police officers who give the rest of their colleagues a bad name, who make no distinction when a suspect has no other description than ‘black male,’ who harass residents because they can. A North Miami Beach officer pulls over a black man in a suit and tie — and behind the wheel of an Audi that simply had to be stolen, right? In another Miami-Dade city, an officer demands that an African-American man installing a vegetable garden justify why he has a shovel and seedlings. Detained for possession of cilantro? Here are five South Floridians who tell of their experiences in this community and beyond, years ago, and all too recently.

Delrish Moss


    Delrish Moss: Out after dark

    “I was walking up Seventh Avenue, just shy of 14th street. I was about 17 and going home from my job. I worked at Biscayne Federal Bank after school. The bank had a kitchen, and I washed the dishes. A police officer gets out of his car. He didn’t say anything. He came up and pushed me against a wall, frisked me, then asked what I was doing walking over here after dark. Then he got into his car and left. I never got a chance to respond. I remember standing there feeling like my dignity had been taken with no explanation. I would have felt better about that incident had I gotten some sort of dialogue. I had not had any encounters with police.


    Bill Diggs: Hurt officer’s feelings

    “I’m the first generation in my family to go to college, and if I wanted to do nothing else, I wanted to make my mom happy. I was living for my parents, I wanted to be that guy, I wanted to go to work and not have to put on steel-toe boots. And here I am in Atlanta, I have finally grown to a particular level of affluence. I wasn’t making a lot of money, but I was a college kid, wearing a suit, driving a nice BMW going to work everyday. Can’t beat that. I would leave my house, drive up Highway 78, the Stone Mountain area, grab some coffee, go to work. So on this particular morning, there’s a cop who’s rustling up this homeless guy outside the gas station where I was filling up. I’m shaking my head, the cop looks at me. This homeless guy is there every morning. I get in my car and on to the expressway. The police officer comes shooting up behind me. I doing 65, 70. He gets up behind me, I notice he’s following me. I get in one lane, he gets in the lane, I get in another lane, he gets in that lane. He finally flips his lights on, he comes up to the car. I’ve been pulled over for speeding before, I know the drill. Got my hands up here, don’t want to get shot, and I think he’s going to say what I’ve heard before: ‘License and registration, please.’ He says ‘Get out of the car!’ and he reaches in and grabs me by my shirt. He says, ‘So you’re a smart ass, huh?’ Finally he says, ‘License and registration.’ I tell him it’s in the car. He says, ‘Get it for me!’ He goes back to his car, comes back and asks, ‘So where did you get the car from?’ I say ‘It’s a friend of mine’s.” He says, ‘Is it stolen? What are you doing driving your friend’s car?’ I finally asked, ‘Is there a reason you stopped me? You followed me, what’s up, man?’ He says, ‘I’m going to let you go with a warning, but if you see me doing what I’ve got to do for my job, don’t you ever f---ing worry about it.”

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category