Condo Line

Liability insurance on common areas is required


Q: Our HOA board of directors has not carried general liability insurance on our common areas for almost 18 months. The homeowners found this out when one could not close on his unit sale because the title company wanted insurance. The homeowner paid for the insurance so closing could take place.

The builder controls the board of directors and said there was not enough money to pay the insurance. In your opinion, is this criminal negligence on the part of the board?

J.J., Broward

A: The failure of the developer/board is more of a poor business decision than criminal neglect. An attorney would need to answer your question about civil liability versus criminal neglect.

Not having enough money to pay for insurance is not a valid answer. When boards are short on funds to pay for required items, they are then obligated to increase the budget or pass a special assessment.

I believe the major reason the developer did not have the funds was strictly his economic position in this slow market. He feared that increasing the budget or approving a special assessment would hurt his sales.

As the statutes and I’m sure your documents require liability insurance, he was clearly in violation of these requirements. Since there were alternative methods to raise the funds to pay for necessary insurance, he made a poor business decision.

Q: I am on a homeowner association committee to decide what to do with our tennis court. It was in the original documents from 30 years ago and needs to be resurfaced. We have only 40 units. Some owners want to remove it and make a parking lot, a park, etc., and some want it to remain a tennis court.

Can you tell me whether you are allowed to remove one of the original amenities and if so, what kind of vote needs to take place?

E.M., Minneola

A: What you are addressing is a common area that you are trying to eliminate. When you start altering common area elements, it can create a serious liability for the association and for that reason I strongly recommend you seek legal guidance.

Most documents would define how the removal of a common area would be conducted. The major reason that I recommend legal guidance is because I have seen one owner sue the association when it removed a common element.

Say one owner purchased in the community primarily because he had use of the tennis court. If you remove the tennis courts and he did not vote for the removal, you may find that he sues the association because you took away the one amenity that was very important to him.

An attorney would research documents as to the correct procedures, draft a legal motion, and assist with the required votes.

Q: At our HOA monthly board of directors meeting we have a member who attends every meeting and asserts that she can address and discuss any business that the board members discuss. Her interference sometimes has caused dissent and has predisposed some of the board members’ votes. Do the statutes say that any member can sit in on all board meetings and talk to those items placed on the agenda?

B.S., Stuart

A: The statutes allow the board to establish meeting policies. Those policies could include allowing members to address any agenda items up to three minutes. They can also require that a request to talk on a specific agenda item must be in writing and presented to the secretary before the meeting is called order. They can also limit when the owner can speak — just after the motion has been made and directors have discussed it but before the vote.

If an owner does not submit a request in writing to discuss an agenda item before the meeting is called to order, the owner can be denied the right to talk. Using such a policy will limit discussion from the floor but allow an owner to present their information or concerns.

Write to Condo Line, Richard White, 6039 Cypress Gardens Blvd., #201, Winter Haven, FL 33884-4115, or e-mail Include name and city.

Read more Condos stories from the Miami Herald

  • Condo Line

    Confusion over reserve funds and insurance deductibles

    Q: Our condominium has a line item in the budget for an insurance deductible of $5,000. Our actual deductible is $112,000 per building, and we have three buildings. Each year the amount is rolled over to the general fund as surplus because it has not been needed for several years.

  • Condo Line

    Unhappy with management firm

    Q: As an owner not on the board of my homeowners association, I have taken time to research the community association managers’ (CAM) educational requirements. The educational hours required are very small compared to other professionals that are licensed real estate agents.

  • Condo Line

    Can homeowners association donate to charities?

    Q: I live in a homeowners association that is one of a number of associations separately run with individual boards, all under the umbrella of a master association. The master association takes care of streets, sidewalks, entry gates, security and other mutually shared expenses. The master association includes a representative from each individual association.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category