U.S.-Cuba relations

‘Cuban Twitter’ raises question: Is it OK for U.S. to help Cubans?


The USAID programs are branded as subversive by critics, and by others as support for democracy.

According to documents obtained by The Associated Press and multiple interviews with people involved in the project, the plan was to develop a bare-bones "Cuban Twitter," using cellphone text messaging to evade Cuba's strict control of information and its stranglehold restrictions over the Internet. In a play on Twitter, it was called ZunZuneo — slang for a Cuban hummingbird's tweet.
According to documents obtained by The Associated Press and multiple interviews with people involved in the project, the plan was to develop a bare-bones "Cuban Twitter," using cellphone text messaging to evade Cuba's strict control of information and its stranglehold restrictions over the Internet. In a play on Twitter, it was called ZunZuneo — slang for a Cuban hummingbird's tweet.
STR / AFP/Getty Images


Does the U.S. government have the right to circumvent a dictatorship’s controls on information? And if Washington tries to help foster democracy in a country ruled by a dictator, is it pushing for “regime change?”

Those are the fundamental questions raised by an Associated Press report Thursday that the U.S. Agency for International Development, USAID, financed a “secret” Twitter-like system for Cubans “designed to undermine the communist government.”

Replies predictably ranged from a rotund no to a flat yes, largely reflecting the divisions over U.S. policies on Cuba and the more than half-century of animosity between the two nations.

White House Press Secretary Jay Carney said the AP was wrong in branding USAID’s “Zunzuneo” program as covert. In “non-permissive environments” it is “discreet” to “protect the practitioners and the public,” he said. “This is not unique to Cuba.”

State Department spokeswoman Marie Harf took aim at what she called the “misconceptions” in the “breathlessly written” AP report and said, “The notion that we were somehow trying to foment unrest … nothing could be further from the truth.”

But Max Lesnik, a Miami radio commentator who supports the government of ruler Raúl Castro, called Zunzuneo “an operation aimed at changing the Cuban government — regime change. This is a covert aggression through social networks.”

Cuba’s government has outlawed the USAID programs as subversive and calls all dissidents “U.S. mercenaries.” The agency says its programs promote democracy and support civil society, and notes that Congress approved $20 million for them this year alone.

USAID subcontractor Alan Gross is serving a 15-year sentence in Havana for giving Cuban Jews sophisticated communications equipment that would have allowed them to sidestep government controls on the Internet and telephone connections.

Ninoska Perez Castellon, a Miami radio commentator and Castro critic, said the USAID programs are needed. “Cuba is a dictatorship, and any program that helps a country where there is repression and censorship is justified,” she said.

She added that Cuba’s complaints that Washington is promoting subversion on the island are “total hypocrisy” because the Castro government trained and armed leftist guerrillas from throughout Latin America in the 1970s and ’80s.

But Washington should be careful in how it supports civil society in repressive countries, said Emily Parker, author of a book on Internet controls in Cuba, China and Russia and advisor on digital diplomacy to former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton.

“The U.S. needs to tread very carefully in countries like Cuba because to directly support [dissidents] makes it easy to call them mercenaries,” Parker said. “That sometimes does more harm than good.”

There are other ways for Washington to support the Internet in Cuba, she said, such as eliminating U.S. obstacles to access that are sometimes created by the trade embargo. Her book, Now I Know Who My Comrades Are, was published early this year.

Cuba democracy advocate Mauricio Claver-Carone, meanwhile, said it was no surprise for the U.S. media and some politicians to complain about U.S. policies in Cuba but praise the same policies when they are applied to other countries.

A global outcry followed Turkey’s ongoing attempts to cut off Twitter amid the ongoing anti-government protests, he said, and USAID runs similar programs to expand the flow of information in dictatorships such as Syria, North Korea and Iran.

“That’s not controversial. Everybody supports that. But it seems Cuba is the only place where we have to accept a totalitarian government’s control over communications,” said Claver-Carone, director of the U.S. Cuba Democracy political action committee.

Cuba’s communist government controls all newspapers, radio and TV stations, makes access to the Internet very expensive and and blocks access to many web pages and the transmissions of the U.S. government’s Radio/TV Marti stations.

“The story that needs to be told is the lack of access to the Internet and Twitter in Cuba,” said Marc Wachtenheim, a Washington consultant who has been involved with the Cuba programs. “All efforts to overcome that information blockade are valid and moral.”

Cuba blogger Orlando Luis Pardo Lazo said his complaint about the Zunzuneo program was that it was so ineffective in reaching Cubans — 40,000 in a nation of 11 million — that he only heard about it from a government supporter a few years back.

But he supports the goal of promoting democracy on the island.

“The U.S. government, and many democratic governments, have a moral debt with countries ruled by dictatorships,” he said. “They talk about a debt with slavery, a debt with colonies, but not a debt with despotic countries.”

Rep. Ileana Ros-Lehtinen, R-Fla., said USAID’s Cuba programs are not secret but have to keep a low profile to protect people in Cuba from government retaliation.

While bags of U.S. food sent to Haiti carry a U.S. stamp, Ros-Lehtinen said, a U.S. government program that sends books to independent libraries in Cuba does not put U.S. stamps on the books.

What’s more, the objective is not to change the Cuban government, she added in an interview with El Nuevo Herald, “but to provide information to an oppressed people.”

“And we will keep doing these programs,” she vowed. “We are trying every which way to penetrate Cuba’s hold on information, to foster a hunger for democracy. But in no way are we calling for regime change.”

Read more Cuba stories from the Miami Herald

This is the raft on which 16 Cubans sailed from Cuba to Alligator Reef Light off Upper Matecumbe Key this week.


    Cuban migrants found suffering from dehydration off the Keys

    Sixteen Cuban migrants were intercepted off the Upper Keys on Wednesday afternoon, and seven of them needed medical attention after suffering from extreme dehydration.

Sixteen migrants are found crammed in this tiny boat around Alligator Lighthouse, which is about four miles offshore of Islamorada in the FLorida Keys.


    More than a dozen Cuban migrants rescued at sea in Keys; several taken to hospital

    A small blue homemade boat with a blue-and-white sail was discovered floating near Alligator Reef Lighthouse, about four miles offshore of Islamorada, on Wednesday. Crammed inside the motorless vessel were 16 Cuban migrants lying down, suffering from dehydration, according to the U.S. Coast Guard.

Elsa Lopez looks at her clothes and shoes she wore when she left Cuba with her parents at the age of two at the time. Her items are among several donated by Exiles on display at the VIP opening and presentation of the The Exile Experience: Journey to Freedom, at the Freedom Tower. The exhibit is a pictorial account of the struggles that the Cuban exile community has endured since Fidel Castro's rise to power, and the successes they have achieved in the United States, organized and curated by the Miami Dade College and The Miami Herald, on Wednesday September 10, 2014.


    Exhibition chronicles Cuban exiles story

    More than 1,000 people crammed into the Freedom Tower Wednesday night for a peek at an exhibition that honors one of the city’s oldest buildings – and captures the tales of hundreds of thousands of Cubans who fled the island and made Miami their new home.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category