WAR COURT

USS Cole defense lawyers argue against capital case at Guantánamo with secret evidence

 
 
Defense attorney Rick Kammen of Indianapolis sported a kangaroo lapel pin to the court's national security session on Friday, June14, 2013 at the U.S. Navy base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, in a photo approved for release by the U.S. military. CAROL ROSENBERG/THE MIAMI HERALD
Defense attorney Rick Kammen of Indianapolis sported a kangaroo lapel pin to the court's national security session on Friday, June14, 2013 at the U.S. Navy base at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, in a photo approved for release by the U.S. military. CAROL ROSENBERG/THE MIAMI HERALD
CAROL ROSENBERG / MIAMI HERALD

About Abd al Rahim al Nashiri

Born: Jan. 5, 1965 in Mecca, Saudi Arabia.

Captured: October 2002, United Arab Emirates.

Arrived Guantánamo: September 2006, after waterboarding in secret CIA prison.

Profession: Told a 2007 military review that he was a merchant in Mecca who by 19 was a millionaire. CIA profile released by the White House in 2006 said he was al-Qaida operations chief in the Arabian Peninsula at time of his capture.

Paramilitary background: CIA profile said he fought in Chechnya and Tajikistan and trained at the Khaldan camp in Afghanistan in 1992.

ABOUT THE USS COLE

The 8,300-ton warship is based in Norfolk, Va. It was commissioned, a formal ceremony, at Port Everglades in 1996.

It was on a refueling stop in October 2000 when two al Qaida suicide bombers drove a bomb-laden boat into the side, killing themselves and ultimately claiming the lives of 17 Americans. They were:

Hull Maintenance Technician 2nd Class Kenneth Eugene Clodfelter, 21, of Mechanicsville, Va.

Electronics Technician Chief Petty Officer Richard Costelow, 35, of Morrisville, Pa.

Mess Management Specialist Seaman Lakeina Monique Francis, 19, of Woodleaf, N.C.

Information Systems Technician Timothy Lee Gauna, 21, of Rice, Texas

Signalman Seaman Cherone Louis Gunn, 22, of Rex, Ga.

Seaman James Rodrick McDaniels, 19, of Norfolk, Va.

Engineman 2nd Class Marc Ian Nieto, 24, of Fond du Lac, Wis.

Electronics Warfare Technician 2nd Class Ronald Scott Owens, 24, of Vero Beach.

Seaman Lakiba Nicole Palmer, 22, of San Diego.

Engineman Fireman Joshua Langdon Parlett, 19, of Churchville, Md.

Fireman Patrick Howard Roy, 19, of Keedysville, Md.

Electronics Warfare Technician 1st Class Kevin Shawn Rux, 30, of Portland, N.D.

Mess Management Specialist 3rd Class Ronchester Manangan Santiago, 22, of Kingsville, Texas.

Operations Specialist 2nd Class Timothy Lamont Saunders, 32, of Ringgold, Va.

Fireman Gary Graham Swenchonis Jr., 26, of Rockport, Texas.

Ensign Andrew Triplett, 31, of Macon, Miss.

Seaman Craig Bryan Wibberley, 19, of Williamsport, Md.


crosenberg@MiamiHerald.com

Defense lawyers in the USS Cole bombing case asked the judge Monday to strip the trial jury of the power to hand down a death sentence because the accused mastermind can’t see secret evidence in his case.

In an illustration of the issue, the accused bomber, Abd al Rahim al Nashiri, could only hear part of the argument in open court. The judge, Army Col. James L. Pohl, ordered lawyers to resume their arguments in secret session Tuesday — with the public and accused Saudi terrorist excluded — to prevent disclosures that could “pose a grave danger to national security.”

Tuesday’s will be the third classified pretrial hearing in the case of Nashiri, 49, who is accused of orchestrating al-Qaida’s suicide bombing of the $1 billion warship off Yemen in October 2000. Seventeen sailors were killed in the attack; the prosecutor wants him executed, if convicted.

But his death-penalty defender, Rick Kammen, said the Guantánamo war court structure denies Nashiri the U.S. constitutional right to an effective assistance of counsel. Nashiri can’t guide his legal defense, Kammen said, if he can’t see all the evidence against him. And, because it’s a national security trial, defense lawyers are forbidden to show the accused terrorist anything marked “Secret” — especially information about the four years he spent in CIA custody, at one point being waterboarded by U.S. agents, because doesn’t have a security clearance.

Kammen called it a “crossroads” moment for Nashiri’s judge, who’s responsible to be “the bulwark” that protects Nashiri’s rights.

“Because if he does not have effective lawyers, if all he has is folks in uniforms and suits sitting there, you know, this is just a Potemkin village, this is just a façade without any real meaning,” he said.

A civilian case prosecutor, Justin Sher, disputed the thesis. The prosecution would not use classified evidence at the trial itself, he said, and nearly all the classified information Nashiri’s lawyers had gotten was at their request, because they have security clearances.

Sher quantified the classified disclosure at 14 percent of the pretrial discovery; Kammen said it was more than that.

“The government is not going to rely on classified information,” he said.

Sher argued that Kammen and four uniformed military defense counsel got most of the classified information because they specifically asked for the state secrets, not because the Pentagon prosecutor offered it them. Those lawyers have security clearances and are forbidden to discuss secret information with Nashiri — unless he happens to already know it from his personal experiences, and voluntarily mentions it without his lawyers probing.

Nashiri, said Sher, “can access all of the discovery that's not classified, and only 14 percent of what's produced is classified. And the accused can talk, again, with his attorneys about whatever information he knows.”

To which Kammen retorted: “You can't exclude 14 percent of the case from pretrial preparation, from meaningful trial preparation, and still try and kill this guy.”

Nashiri appeared to listen intently to an Arabic translator through a headset. He wore his typical war court attire —the white prison camp uniform of a complaint captive, topped by a suit jacket.

To provide an adequate death-penalty defense, Kammen said, lawyers need to show Nashiri and discuss with him every bit of discovery in the case so he can guide them. Additionally, Kammen posed, what happens if he wants to invoke classified information while cross-examining a trial witness? The prosecutor said Nashiri would not be excluded from his own trial, and the government would devise a work-around.

Kammen added that he would amplify at Tuesday’s secret session. But, for the record, he added, Nashiri objected to being excluded from it.

Sher said the provision that prohibits a defendant from seeing all the evidence against him is similar to those at federal national-security trials. He cited the 2003-06 capital trial of suspected “20th hijacker” Zacarias Moussaoui — to which Kammen retorted that the judge at one point struck the possibility of the death penalty after discovering the CIA had “lied” about “whether videotapes of torture had existed.”

There were videotapes at the time of the trial; the CIA later destroyed them.

Moussaoui for a time acted as his own attorney, even though he couldn’t see classified evidence. In the end, the jury did have the option of choosing execution but gave him a life sentence instead.

A key issue that has pervaded Nashiri’s pretrial hearings is his lawyers’ efforts to uncover classified details about his four years in secret CIA custody. In a bid to break him, to get him to spill al-Qaida’s secrets, agents waterboarded and interrogated him nude, threatened him with a revving power drill and made threats to rape his mother among a list of harsh, now forbidden interrogation techniques.

His lawyers want the information both to perhaps challenge unclassified evidence against him as tainted and also to argue he deserves leniency because of his pretrial treatment.

Read more Guantánamo stories from the Miami Herald

  •  
Algerian Djamel Ameziane, a 42-year-old ethnic Berber, has been approved for release but wants to go to Canada, or another country, rather than the nation he fled in 1992. His lawyers have chosen Canada because he lived there for five years, and filed a failed application for political asylum. From Canada he went to Afghanistan, where he was captured in the U.S. invasion.

    IN THE COURTS

    Ex-Guantánamo detainee can’t get his money back

    Federal judge concludes a former Guantánamo detainee may no longer be a threat, but his money is.

  •  
The Kremlin.

    Russia bans congressman, 12 other Americans

    Russia has placed a U.S. lawmaker and 12 other people connected with the Guantanamo Bay detention camp and the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq on its list of those banned from entering the country.

  •  
In this image from video, Eugene R. Fidell, the lawyer representing Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl said Wednesday, July 16, 2014, in an interview with The Associated Press that his client has been vilified by some people, but the public should not leap to conclusions before the Army finishes its investigation into how and why the soldier left his post in Afghanistan before being captured by the Taliban.

    Bergdahl hires lawyer for military investigation

    The lawyer representing Sgt. Bowe Bergdahl said Wednesday that his client has been vilified by some people, but the public should not leap to conclusions before the Army finishes its investigation into how and why the soldier left his post in Afghanistan before being captured by the Taliban.

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category