Argentina’s devaluation may signal more to come


There’s been plenty of fussing since Argentina’s biggest currency devaluation in 12 years, with much effort being made to assign blame.

What’s missing is the government’s recognition of the role it played in bringing Argentina to this sorry state. Deficit spending has helped push inflation to an estimated 28 percent last year, the highest in more than two decades. Add to that the government’s practice of imposing price controls and nationalizing companies without compensating owners, and it’s no wonder foreign investment has been scared off.

Amid this government-induced turmoil, it should be no surprise that Argentines are going to great lengths to safeguard their money by purchasing a strong currency like the U.S. dollar. Demand for dollars is a big reason the Argentine central bank’s dollar reserves have declined by almost a third to $29 billion. To limit the drain on reserves, the government had little choice but to devalue the currency to 8 pesos a dollar from 6. Moody’s Investors Service reckons Argentina may devalue the currency another 50 percent before the year is out.

Top Argentine officials seem oblivious, as if government policies had nothing to do with the health of the economy. On Sunday, Economy Minister Axel Kicillof told the leftist daily Pagina 12 that “Argentina has a cultural problem with the dollar,” adding that “it’s not just large speculators or wealthy sectors who are playing with the currency but, culturally, in the Argentine mentality there is a desire to own dollars.” This should be no surprise in a country with a history of currency devaluations.

The following day, President Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner, during a trip to Cuba for a Latin America summit, accused banks of manipulating the currency in a Twitter post: “The banks, only through them can market manipulation maneuvers be done.” In a separate post, Fernandez said she had a chat with Brazilian President Dilma Rousseff concerning “speculative pressures over the exchange rates of emerging countries. (Sound familiar?)”

Still, Fernandez’s own government last week eased restrictions so Argentines can buy dollars and save them in local bank accounts. Cabinet Chief Jorge Capitanich said the government would sell as much as $2,000 a month to individuals, depending on their monthly earnings. The dollar purchases will be taxed at as much as 20 percent unless buyers hold onto their dollar deposits for one year.

The move, meant to ease demand in a black market for the greenback, didn’t appear to work. Shortly after Capitanich’s remarks, the black-market rate rose to 12.25 pesos a dollar. Meanwhile, the government institute charged with selling dollars received more than 121,000 purchase orders for $59 million in U.S. currency. Banks and brokerage houses had to turn away customers.

Weakening the currency clearly isn’t a popular thing for a government to do. Kicillof tried to downplay the devaluation’s negative effects on the economy when he told Pagina 12 that “some speculative sectors sought a mega devaluation, but they didn’t get it, because this is far from a mega devaluation.” The devaluation of 1989 weakened the peso’s value 2,038 percent and was much worse, he said.

The main worry is what comes next. Lawmaker Margarita Stolbizer posed a question many have in mind when she told Radio America: “In November a dollar sold for 6 pesos and now it’s at 8 pesos per dollar. We’ve had a devaluation of more than 30 percent in two months, and this has a terrible outlook, of 50 percent or 60 percent” more this year. “Where are we headed?”

Fernandez’s administration likes to blame inflation on greedy capitalists. In an interview published Tuesday, Capitanich disavowed any government responsibility for inflation when he told Ambito Financiero, “many times prices go up in Argentina for mere sport.” Business and finance groups, he insisted, take “psychological actions” to manipulate the economy and markets for their benefit.

If inflation is a headache for Argentina now, weakening the currency probably will only make it worse. Moody’s forecasts inflation of more than 30 percent this year. But the Fernandez camp is hoping that intimidation will prevent prices from rising, as imports become more expensive. Capitanich said that businesses that use higher costs for foreign goods as an excuse to raise prices “will suffer an urgent opening of imports” manufactured by their overseas competitors.

Or as Kicillof put it over the weekend: “The business person that says that there was a 16 percent devaluation,” and increases prices “lies and steals.” This kind of bluster isn’t conducive to foreign investment or to restoring confidence.

La Nacion, a newspaper critical of Fernandez’s administration, said in a Saturday editorial that “One doesn’t need to be an economist to understand that the government has destroyed our national currency.” The paper attributed the problem to “out of control fiscal and monetary” policies.

Some Fernandez allies recognize the trouble ahead. The Paco Urondo news agency, which usually defends Fernandez and her policies, said: “The reality in the slums is dramatic. And it’s easy to foresee that the situation will generate even more discontent.”

Fernandez’s policies of price controls, devaluations and asset seizures may be meant to help her low-income supporters. But when they lead to accelerating inflation there’s a problem. And although the market manipulators that Fernandez’s government loves to hate might exist, telling people that prices rise out of mere whim amounts to ignoring reality.

The idea that economic forces can be curbed by tough regulations is part of Fernandez’s political credo. But Argentina’s history shows that when flawed government policies are the source of those forces, such an approach goes nowhere.

Raul Gallegos is the Latin American correspondent for Bloomberg View’s World View blog.

© 2014, Bloomberg News

Read more From Our Inbox stories from the Miami Herald

  • The great reclining seat wars

    There’s an old Seinfeld episode where Jerry and Elaine are about to board a plane and the gate attendant tells them she can bump one of them into first class. Jerry immediately takes the offer, explaining to Elaine that he’s flown in first class before — she hasn’t — so he knows what he would be missing. Sure enough, Jerry spends the flight sipping champagne with a super-model while Elaine sits in a middle seat squeezed between two fat guys who fall asleep on her.

  • D.C. government guilty of abusing drivers

    “You are guilty until you have proven yourself innocent. … That has worked well for us.”

  • Domestic violence puts some women on the path to incarceration

    Domestic violence is a hot topic right now — a conversation being fueled by what we’ve witnessed inside a fancy hotel elevator and on the stage of the Miss America pageant.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category