River Cities Gazette

Miami Springs cops, city at an impasse over new contract

WHAT NOW: The Miami Springs police department and the City of Miami Springs have been in negotiations for a number of months and still have yet to come to an agreement.
WHAT NOW: The Miami Springs police department and the City of Miami Springs have been in negotiations for a number of months and still have yet to come to an agreement.
Gazette Photo/WALLY CLARK

River Cities Gazette

The Miami Springs Police union bargaining unit and the City of Miami Springs have reached an impasse on a contract. Actually, the city declared an impasse but other options are available for both sides.

While the main issue is money, as always, calculations and financial factors are extremely complicated and convoluted to outsiders, but certain facts are undeniable:

• Miami Springs officers haven’t had a contract with the city for more than five years.

• Springs cops haven’t had a raise in over five years.

• Due to mandatory retirement contributions, nearly all officers take home less pay than they did five years ago. For one veteran officer, that means he contributes over $500 per two-week pay period when it used to be around $250. That sometimes amounts to more than federal taxes.

• Springs cops’ retirement contribution rate of 18.6 percent of gross pay is higher than any other police department in Florida and possibly higher than any in the country. It is true the city contributes an even greater percentage. The police used to contribute more than the city but market factors have changed that situation.

• Miami Springs Police has one less officer than before because when Lt. Steve Carlisle retired last December, his position was eliminated at the request of city management and no new entry-level officer was hired.

• Since Miami Springs adopted the red light camera system along Northwest 36th Street, the program added a net of approximately $1 million to the general fund in two years. None of the money is directly earmarked for the police department.

The union reps are Sgt. Jimmy Deal and Officer Jennifer Casanova. Deal said the City of Miami Springs doesn’t negotiate; rather, it essentially says no. 

“Some of our proposals would actually save the city money,” said Deal. “We try to work with the city and we don’t outright reject offers like the city does. Changes need to be made but not by cutting our benefits. That doesn’t fix the problems.”

Deal said 25 percent of the current force (10 officers) is retiring in the next four years.

“If pension benefits are cut, the department will have a hard time hiring 10 new officers,” said Deal. “I mean quality officers. We don’t get take-home cars and our overtime doesn’t count in our pension like at other agencies. The pension is the only real benefit we have. People appreciate us and what we do, but there’s a cost for it.”

Deal said, currently, when he retires, he will get 100 percent of his pay, with an average of three years. But the city wants to lower the maximum to 80 percent with an average of five years of base pay and eliminate the 20-year retirement, replacing it with 25 years. He said that would force some veteran officers to retire. 

“The city’s priorities are not straight. The city paid out over $875,000 for golf course expenses last year such as golf carts and lawn equipment,” said Deal. “But nothing was budgeted to benefit the police.”

City Manager Ron Gorland issued the following statement regarding the impasse:

“The police bargaining information posted on our website clearly states that the City's negotiating objective is to begin lowering the cost of the police pension plan to both the police and our residents. The cost of the police retirement plan is escalating out-of-sight to both the police and residents due to a combination of new life expectancy actuarial tables and investment losses. Unfortunately this cannot be achieved without a reduction in benefits.  For instance, currently a policeman joining our force at age 21 can retire  at age 49 with 100% of their average highest pay. The Actuary has provided a report that shows the contribution cost for both sides will increase to 29.2% of payroll beginning October 1, 2014. This represents an annual cost to the City of  $713,037 or an average of approximately $16,582 for every officer in the City.

“The City's latest offer is a pension package that is similar to the benefits offered under the Florida Retirement System (FRS). The City Council has also offered to use the City's savings from this proposal over the next three years to further reduce Officer contributions.  According to the Actuary, beginning October 1, 2014 the City's current proposal lowers the contribution rate for the Officers by approximately. 10% from the 29.20% under the current plan to 19.34% under the City's latest  proposal.. The PBA's counter offers do not decrease the contribution rates as significantly as the City's proposal. 

“To date the bargaining unit has not offered any alternatives in bargaining which would sufficiently lower contribution rates in the future.”

Read more River Cities stories from the Miami Herald

YUM!: 10-month-old Priscilla Hernandez had more than just picking up eggs on her mind. Hernandez was one of the many kids who took park in this year’s City of Miami Springs Easter Egg Hunt on April 19.

    City of Miami Springs Easter Egg Hunt moved indoors

    Early morning rains almost washed out the annual City of Miami Springs Easter Egg Hunt last Saturday, April 19 but always-resilient Program Supervisor Patti Bradley moved the event into the Community Center gym to salvage the day.

WHAT'S NEXT?: The former bridal path through the middle of the old James Medical Center property was the subject of the April 8 referendum on the sale of golf course property that did not pass leaving the question of what will local architect and property owner Manny Perez-Vichot.

    Local Miami Springs architects ponder next move after referendum fails to pass

    The “no” vote on the Miami Springs golf course referendum took place more than two weeks ago, but it is still heavy on the minds of Manny Perez-Vichot and Enrique Aguerrevere and both had plenty to lose when 53 percent of the voters did not approve the sale of less than one-quarter of an acre of golf course property, and they are undecided about what to do next.

CLUTCH HITTER: Miami Springs senior Austin Voeller contributed to the Hawks district semifinal win over Norland on Monday with a base hit and an RBI.

    Miami Springs baseball team tops Norland in district semifinal contest

    Thanks to a great pitching performance from David Cervantes, the Miami Springs Golden Hawks baseball team qualified for the regional playoffs for the first time in five years when the Hawks knocked off Norland 3-1 in a district semifinal contest at Shelly Dunkel Field on Monday afternoon and will take on Goleman on Thursday for the district title.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK