As Obamacare site stalls, consumers get dubious pitches


Buyers, beware

The troubled website isn’t your only legitimate avenue into the health care marketplace:

•  The National Marketplace Toll-Free Call Center at 1-800-318-2596 is open 24/7.

•  Certified navigators and application counselors can offer in-person assistance. Go to this site and plug in your ZIP code to find help near you:

Tips on finding help

•  Many independent agents are trained to help consumers in the marketplace. Ask to see proof of their training and be sure they’re really independent.

•  Don’t deal with anyone who wants to be paid for helping you; navigator services are free to you.

•  Never respond to unsolicited pitches.

Herald/Times Tallahassee Bureau

“Obamacare Enrollment Center,’’ announced the banner hanging from the pulpit. It even bore the “O” logo from President Obama’s campaign.

But the self-proclaimed “Obamacare Enrollment Team’’ that rolled into Florida’s capital this week has no official connection with the president or his signature health law. It is a front for a Stuart-based insurance agency now accused of trying to dupe consumers into buying health insurance.

Affordable Care Act advocates long have worried about unofficial sales efforts, and with the law’s continued technical problems, frustrated consumers may be increasingly vulnerable to promises of easier access to the system.

Dealing with an unofficial pitch carries at least two problems: First, you could be scammed entirely. Secondly, even if you buy a legitimate insurance policy, you might lose out on tax subsidies offered under the healthcare law.

The only way lower- and middle-income consumers can get a subsidy is through official channels.

“Obamacare Enrollment Team’’ is the brand used by the Fiorella Insurance Agency to market policies during the healthcare rollout, especially to minorities in urban areas. The group solicits through a network of websites, none of which disclosed ties to the insurance agency until after reporters started poking around. Attorney General Pam Bondi’s office received a complaint from a woman who said she worked for Illinois’ official health insurance marketplace and became concerned after watching the Obamacare Enrollment Team in action at a Chicago job fair earlier this month. It also has held events in Detroit.

“The website is trying to collect [Social Security numbers],” the complaint said.

About 20 people, all of them African American and many of them elderly, attended the Obamacare Enrollment Team’s forum in Tallahassee. They all were encouraged to provide their names, addresses, signatures — and Social Security numbers.

It wasn’t until reporters at the meeting began asking questions that the two presenters — Lakeland pastor H.B. Holmes and self-described “lobbyist” Katrina Copeland — admitted they were affiliated with the Fiorella agency.

“I don’t have to be licensed because I am a registered lobbyist with the Senate and the House, so I don’t have to have a navigator’s license,” Copeland declared when asked whether she was a navigator.

But though she has submitted paperwork in the U.S. Capitol, she is not an active lobbyist. And even if she were, lobbyists don’t receive the training, background checks and certifications that official healthcare navigator must have. Copeland’s presentation suggested she doesn’t understand the law.

“The same individuals who have Medicaid could then go under the Affordable Care Act and get private insurance, and then that Medicaid will go back to the states,” she told the crowd.

But that’s not true. Private insurance is for people who cannot qualify for Medicaid, the government health insurance for the poor. And further, the seniors in the crowd should have been told that Obamacare is not for them — Medicare, the program for seniors and the disabled, has nothing to do with the health insurance marketplace.

Nick Fiorella Jr., a vice president at the agency, said in a phone interview that the company’s goal is not to confuse people. He noted that the company — after media reports of his team’s tactics — has changed its website to say it isn’t tied to the federal government and no longer asks for Social Security numbers.

So, why create a so-called “Obamacare Enrollment Team’’?

“We’re going into mostly urban communities and targeting people who haven’t had health insurance,” Fiorella said. “They associate these changes with Obamacare. That’s what they know the law as, and that’s the brand that has rolled out nationally.”

Jackson Youmas, executive director of a St. Petersburg nonprofit that works with HIV/AIDs patients, had his whole staff complete federal training to guide consumers through the marketplace. Youmas said he’s not surprised to hear people are being misled. He found a suspicious website even before the federal system went live on Oct. 1.

“I think it does open up an opportunity for people who are not honest to take advantage,” said Youmas, adding that consumers want to buy insurance.

“If they can’t get in [to the marketplace] one way, they might look for another,” he said.

Tallahassee Urban League President Ernest Ferrell, a pastor, agreed to host the forum at his church when Holmes reached out to him. But after reporters asked questions, he encouraged the audience not to share their Social Security numbers.

He pledged to look into allegations against the group, but stood by the Obamacare Enrollment Team’s mission. “The point is the information is critically important to the people that we serve,” Ferrell said, “and whatever we can do to get that to them we are trying to get.”

Indeed, numerous people in the audience said they need information about insurance and don’t know where to get it.

The need for outreach is apparent. Top Obama administration officials are being sent to Miami, Tampa and other major cities across the nation to encourage people to sign up through proper channels. Nonprofit organizations like Enroll America have dispatched thousands of volunteers across the nation to aid the effort, including a big push coming this weekend.

Melanie Hall, executive director of Tampa’s Family Healthcare Foundation, which received federal funding for 15 navigators, said her crew is doing its best to reach out — and make sure people know they are legitimate.

Her navigators wear name tags with small replications of their licenses. When the group is out at health fairs, it puts a logo on its table.

Said Hall: “We’re going to make sure we’re well identified.”

Tampa Bay Times staff writers Alex Leary and Jodie Tillman contributed to this report.

Contact Tia Mitchell at

Read more Florida stories from the Miami Herald

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category