Dreams: Full of meaning or a reflex of the brain?

200 dpi 26p x 39p Earl F. Lam III color illustration of sleeping face dreaming of nature images, birds, fish, trees, tropics. Miami Herald 1999
200 dpi 26p x 39p Earl F. Lam III color illustration of sleeping face dreaming of nature images, birds, fish, trees, tropics. Miami Herald 1999
Earl F. Lam III / Miami Herald File

Los Angeles Times

It’s a question that has long fascinated those who study human behavior: From whence comes the impulse to dream?

Are dreams generated from the brain’s “top” – the high-flying cortical structures that allow us to reason, perceive, act and remember? Or do they come from the brain’s “bottom” – the unheralded brainstem, which quietly oversees such basic bodily functions as respiration, heart rate, salivation and temperature control?

At stake is what to make of the funny, sexual, scary and just plain bizarre mental scenarios that play themselves out in our heads while we sleep. Are our subconscious fantasies coming up for air, as Sigmund Freud believed? Is our brain consolidating lessons learned and pitching out unneeded data, as neuroscientists suggest? Or are dreams no more meaningful than a hot flash?

A study published last month in the journal Brain suggests that the impulse to dream may be little more than a tickle sent up from the brainstem to the sensory cortex.

The full dream experience – the complex scenarios, the feelings of fear, delight or longing – may require the further input of the brain’s higher-order cortical areas, the new research suggests. But even people with grievous injury to the brain’s prime motivational machinery are capable of dreams, the study found.

The research looked for sleep-time “mentation” – thoughts, essentially – in a small group of unusual patients. These patients – 13 in all – had suffered damage within their brains’ limbic system, the seat of basic desires and motivations – for sex, food and all manner of pleasurable sensations.

As a result, they had a neuropsychological syndrome called auto-activation deficit, or AAD: Even while fully conscious, they could sit idle and mute for hours if they were not prodded to action or speech by caregivers. When asked about their thoughts, they would frequently report that their minds were blank. When prompted, they could often do math, sing a song or conjure up memories. But left on their own, these patients might have no spontaneous thoughts at all.

Do these people dream? The answer might suggest the answer to the question of where dreams come from.

Indeed, they do dream – or at least some of them did, in an experiment that compared the nighttime mentations of normal, healthy subjects with this group. When awakened from rapid eye movement or REM sleep – the stage at which dreams are thought to be most common – four of the patients with AAD – 31 percent – reported mentations.

That was a lot less dreaming than was happening in the healthy subjects, 92 percent of whom reported dreams when awakened from REM sleep.

In the AAD patients, the dreams were rarer, shorter and less complex: They said they dreamed of things like shaving, taking a walk or seeing a relative. But even these rudimentary dreams cast them in situations that, in a conscious state, they were unlikely to think of unprompted.

That these inert patients could generate dreams was a “most unexpected result,” said the study’s authors, a team of French neurologists, neuroscientists and sleep specialists. It supports the hypothesis that “dreams are generated through bottom-up processes.”

The “top-down theory” – that dreams originate from the brain’s higher-order cortex, the place from which imagination springs – “is not supported here,” the authors said.

Of course, the dreams of healthy subjects may be embellished by input from the cortical areas that are the seats of perception, memory, emotion and reason, the authors said: That is demonstrated by the vastly richer dreams described by normal subjects.

A lot of dream research has been based on subjects with bizarre damage to the brain. It’s an imperfect method, since such subjects are rare and no two have exactly the same injuries. So, while the rest of us dream away, this intriguing debate is likely to remain open for some time to come.

Read more Lifestyle stories from the Miami Herald

  • Southern Cross Stargazer for Aug. 3-9, 2014

    First Quarter Moon occurs at 8:50 p.m. and floats 6 degrees to the right of silver Saturn — encircled in sunlit icy rings — in the south-southwest. Ruddy Mars grows dim about 8 degrees to the right of the moon. The planets set late evening.

  • Condo Line

    What happened to our annual meeting?

    Q: I would like your opinion on whether or not an association must have an annual meeting. As of now, the last annual meeting in our HOA was in March 2012. FS 720 states that the association “shall” conduct an annual meeting. Our current board and property management company are of the opinion that you only have to try to have one. If a quorum is not reached then the annual meeting is not held and no attempt is made to schedule another meeting.

A young angler fishes the waters off Key West.

    Key west: better in summer, after tourists go home

    Key Westers who live on the island year-round have a steamy little secret: Lots of us like the place better in the summer.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category