Florida Supreme Court overturns high-profile Miami murder conviction



The Florida Supreme Court on Thursday overturned the conviction of a man accused of breaking into a posh Miami Lakes home and strangling a mother of three.

The reason: A Miami-Dade judge refused to boot a potential juror who said she could not be fair and impartial because as a child, a burglar broke into her home and stole Christmas gifts.

The high court’s opinion means Rafael Matarranz, 37, will get a new trial for the 2003 high-profile slaying of Lidia Giangrandi.

He had been serving a life sentence after jurors convicted him of first-degree murder and burglary with assault.

Miami-Dade police said Matarranz, a petty burglar, rode his bicycle into the gated Miami Lakes community and broke into the home of Giangrandi, 46, a mother lauded in the community for her work with homeless people.

Matarranz strangled Giangrandi after she awoke and started screaming inside the house in the 6900 block of Gleneagle Drive, police said. After killing Giangrandi, Matarranz escaped, taking several credit cards and valuables, such as jewelry.

Homicide detectives tracked down Matarranz, who was not believed to be acquainted with Giangrandi, after he gave his sister a credit card stolen from Giangrandi’s house. He gave a full confession to police.

At his November 2009 trial, he claimed the confession was coerced.

The Florida Supreme Court overturned the verdict because Circuit Judge Mary Barzee Flores, who has since retired from the bench, refused to boot the potential juror who had been victimized by a burglar as a child.

The potential juror said she would harbor a “grudge” against Matarranz because of the experience. “It was during the holiday season and it was just crazy and it just makes me sad about it and it beings back bad memories,” she told the court.

During the jury selection process, lawyers can ask a judge to strike a possible juror “for cause” because they have indicated they cannot be fair and impartial.

Through repeated “skillful” questioning, Judge Barzee Flores, however, “embarrassed” the juror into saying she could be fair, justices said in their opinion.

Ultimately, the woman did not even serve on the jury that convicted Matarranz. His defense lawyer used a “peremptory challenge” to strike her from the panel — lawyers are generally allowed 10 challenges to excuse a juror for any reason as long as it is not because of race or gender.

But the court ruled that one of those challenges could have been used to excuse one of the jurors that wound up convicting Matarranz.

Quoting Atticus Finch, the lawyer hero of the classic novel To Kill a Mockingbird, justices said the Matarranz case was important in maintaining “the integrity of our courts, the soundness of our juries, and the men and women who ‘make [them] up.’”

Two justices dissented, saying “branding” of jurors based on their life experiences was “wholly unjustified.”

“Most human beings possess the capacity to overcome bad experiences and the ability to cast aside opinions and attitudes that — upon reflection — are shown to be irrational or unwarranted,” Justice Charles T. Canady wrote.

Read more Miami-Dade stories from the Miami Herald

  • Friends and Neighbors

    Friends and Neighbors: Campaign raises money to feed hungry school children

    Local food banks want to help children who often go hungry get what they need to thrive in school. Community support is needed.

  • Friends and Neighbors

    Florida Mayors join forces to say no to bullies

    Looking back at my growing up days, I can remember how school bullies tried to made life miserable for me and a lot of other youngsters. I remember being followed home one day by a bully who wanted to start a fight. When I kept ignoring her, she soon turned, with her followers and went home. Unlike some of today’s bullies, she didn’t try to hit me. She was just all mouth, spitting out insulting remarks.

  • Crime Watch

    Crime Watch: How to protect your children online

    School will be starting soon and many of you emailed me regarding the social network sites that your kids will be using this year. Nowadays it’s not just the computer at home but also their smartphones. You need to consider blocking your kids’ phones from some of these sites. Check with your telephone carrier to see what programs they have to offer in protecting kids.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category