Zimmerman Trial: Trayvon Martin was not Emmett Till

Hard cases make bad law and even worse fodder for the chattering classes. Most of the so-called lessons of George Zimmerman’s acquittal on charges of murdering Trayvon Martin amount to educational malpractice.

• There is no war on black men, at least not by white men. Last year, the Scripps-Howard News Service studied half a million homicide reports and found that killings of black victims by white attackers have actually dropped over the past 30 years, from 4,745 during the 1980s to 4,380 during the first decade of the 2000s. There were nearly twice as many white victims killed by black assailants: 8,503 in the 1980s, and 8,530 in the 2000s.

•  Why isn’t Stevie Wonder boycotting California? Wonder says he won’t play in Florida until it “abolishes” its stand-your-ground law. But California, the state where he lives, also allows a stand-your-ground defense in murder trials.

When defendants claim to have killed someone in self-defense, California juries are instructed that “a defendant is not required to retreat. He or she is entitled to stand his or her ground and defend himself or herself and, if reasonably necessary, to pursue an assailant until the danger of [death or serious injury] has passed. This is so even if safety could have been achieved by retreating.”

Although it’s not clear that it had much to do with Zimmerman’s acquittal, critics of stand-your-ground have delighted in labeling it a redneck Frankenstein unleashed by Florida and the NRA. In fact, it’s neither.

The old legal standard that the potential victim of a crime must first retreat if possible — the so-called Castle Doctrine, which oddly drew its name from its biggest exception, for victims attacked in their own homes — began to erode over a century ago at the hands of American judges who believed it was too narrow.

As early as 1877, the Indiana Supreme Court ruled that “a person, being without fault and in a place where he has a right to be,” had the right to “repel [attackers] by force. ” Since then, elements of stand-your-ground have been embedded in dozens of state legal codes, either by legislation or judicial doctrine.

And while the NRA has certainly put resources into strengthening stand-your-ground around the country in recent years, it has done so with the enthusiastic support of liberals. Feminist legal thinkers who believed the old Castle Doctrine discriminated against domestic-violence victims helped win several key legal battles against it in the 1980s and 1990s.

Barack Obama, when he was in the Illinois Legislature, voted to bolster the state’s 1961 stand-your-ground law. One of the politicians who’s been grabbing the most TV time denouncing Florida’s stand-your-ground law, U.S. Rep. Frederica Wilson, actually voted for it in 2005 when she was in the state Senate — as did every other senator.

•  Trayvon Martin is not Emmett Till. The most nauseatingly overheated rhetoric has been the comparisons of Martin to Emmett Till. Till was a 14-year-old black kid from Chicago who, in the summer of 1955, went to visit relatives in a tiny Mississippi Delta town called Money. He either whistled at or flirted with (accounts vary) a white woman at the counter of a grocery store.

A few nights later, her husband and brother-in-law (and perhaps some of their neighbors, though that’s uncertain) dragged Till from his home, beat him to an unholy pulp, shot him in the head, tied a 70-pount weight to him with barbed wire and dumped him in a river.

When his body was fished out of the water three days later, the photos — published in Ebony magazine — made America vomit. Well, that part of America outside Money, Mississippi, where the men who killed Till were acquitted by jurors who deliberated just over an hour and confessed it wouldn’t have taken that long if they hadn’t paused to have a soda.

The murderers, once they were safely protected by the constitutional sanction against double jeopardy, boasted of their own guilt. And several jurors admitted they voted for acquittal because they didn’t believe killing black people was a jailable offense.

In what conceivable way does that story resemble the Trayvon Martin case? Zimmerman didn’t know Martin, has no history of racism and, when he called police to report what he thought was a suspicious character in his neighborhood, wasn’t even sure the person was black. Martin wasn’t dragged from his home by a mob but was killed during an altercation in which Zimmerman says he feared for his life and there was little evidence to contradict him.

And in post-verdict interviews, the Zimmerman jurors have come across not as flippant racists but thoughtful citizens who were agonized by their decision but did their best to enforce the law as they understood it. You may think they got it wrong. But that doesn’t mean they were a lynch mob, or that 2013 America is 1955 Mississippi.

Read more Other Views stories from the Miami Herald



    Barbaric methods appeal to mankind’s worst instincts

    YouTube is dripping blood nowadays. Viewers of these videos are as numerous as horrified.



    ‘An ideal put down in words’

    Wednesday is Constitution Day! No, it’s not the day we test how many hot dogs your constitution can handle in 12 minutes. It’s not even a memorial for the USS Constitution, which is the world's oldest floating commissioned naval vessel.

 <span class="cutline_leadin">SHE’S BAAACK:</span> Former Sen. Hillary Clinton is introduced by Sen. Tom Harkin during the Harkin Steak Fry in Indianola, Iowa.


    Hillary needs to tell us her vision

    Judging by her weekend appearance in Iowa, it looks as if Hillary Clinton is indeed running for president. Now she has to answer one simple question: Why?

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category