NSA SCANDAL

NSA scandal: Americans don’t like ‘Big Brother’

 

davidignatius@washpost.com

The National Security Agency survived a legislative challenge in the House of Representatives last week. But senior NSA officials still face an uphill fight to convince the American public that its operations can enhance security without jeopardizing privacy.

The Obama administration had to lobby aggressively to defeat a bipartisan House proposal to defund the NSA’s collection of Americans’ telephone call records. The narrow 217-205 vote shows how fragile public support has become for the agency’s surveillance programs.

Gen. Keith Alexander and other top NSA officials are considering ways they could reassure the public without damaging key programs, according to U.S. officials. They think that forcing Congress to decide between security and privacy is an unfair choice, since the country would lose either way. They’d like an agreement that protects both, but that’s a tall order.

The controversial program the House nearly voted to kill allows the NSA to obtain “metadata” — basically the numbers of all telephone calls — from all major U.S. telephone providers. The companies are compelled to furnish this information by court orders issued in secret by the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court. The call records are then held for five years.

The reason the NSA wants this vast library of records is to have a complete inventory to check for calls from suspected terrorists overseas. When the agency identifies a suspicious number in Pakistan, say, analysts want to see who that person called in the U.S., and who, in turn, might have been contacted by that second person. It’s like having a full deck of cards, so that you can match any particular one if you need to.

The widespread fear that NSA is recording the calls themselves is false, say the U.S. officials. “It would take 400 million people to listen and read” global traffic, estimates one official — obviously an impossibility.

To NSA officials, this access to calling records is supremely valuable. The problem is that many Americans are uncomfortable with it, despite repeated NSA assurances that under this program, only the calling data is collected, not the calls themselves. Public uneasiness was suggested by a Washington Post-ABC News poll last week showing that 74 percent of those surveyed believe NSA surveillance of telephone records intrudes on the privacy rights of some Americans.

So how could the NSA reassure the American public? Already, the NSA keeps the calling records in what’s described as an electronic —lockbox” that can only be accessed by a small number of people when there is a “reasonable, articulable suspicion” that numbers need to be checked. What other protections could be offered? The U.S. officials cite three different issues:

• Who should hold the calling data? Under current procedures, it’s turned over to the NSA and stored in government data files. The records could instead be retained by the phone companies and accessed only when there’s a particular need, described in a legal order. Or the records could be held by a third party — a consortium like the SWIFT system that handles bank transfers.

• How long should the records be held? The NSA could purge the records sooner than five years, but officials worry that the shorter the retention period, the less effective the metadata will be as a way of tracking dangerous links.

• How can oversight be improved? The NSA thinks the rules are already pretty good, with Congress and the courts joining the executive branch in detailed reviews of compliance with the law and its privacy protections. Judging by the poll data, the public isn’t convinced. Greater transparency — at the FISA court, in the congressional intelligence committees and at NSA itself — would help. In reality, however, no level of scrutiny would be tight enough to reassure everyone.

A final, delicate challenge for the NSA is maintaining its relationships with telephone companies that are anxious about customer and shareholder concerns, and have brought lawsuits challenging the program. U.S. officials believe the best defense for the companies is simply to claim that they have no other choice -- that they are compelled by legal orders to give up the data.

But the companies would be happier, surely, with a softer, more transparent and customer-friendly wrapper for a program that makes many Americans nervous.

(c) 2013, Washington Post Writers Group

Read more Other Views stories from the Miami Herald

  •  
Victor Guzman has been helping farmers in Palm Beach County since 1952.

    VICTOR GUZMAN

    100 years old, and still growing

    Victor Guzman showed up at the Everglades Research and Education Center in Belle Glade in 1952 with what he remembers as simple instructions from his boss in Gainesville: “Go down to the Glades and solve the problems of the farmers.”

  •  
MCT

    BORED?

    Help kids’ imaginations soar

    On a rainy drive home a few days ago, I heard an age-old complaint from my daughter, one that most parents hear this time of the year: “Dad, I’m bored.”

  •  
WAHID

    RELIGION

    ‘Islamic terrorists’ are thugs, not theologians

    There have been several recent examples cited as evidence that Islam has a violent belief system and that Muslims, therefore, are a scourge that need eradication. Many saw the killing of three innocent Israeli teens through this filter of a violent Islam.

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category