Horse racing | South Florida’s track battle

Gulfstream has early lead over Calder in summertime faceoff


More than twice as much money was wagered at Gulfstream than at Calder on a lazy Sunday as the tracks slug it out with each other for business.

“C’mon, big boy!”

Bill Kaplan rises to his feet as the field of horses turns into the stretch. It is the second race at Calder Casino & Race Course, a nondescript claiming race on a lazy Sunday.

There are no more than a handful of fans seated in the second-floor grandstand, and even if the horse could understand what his trainer was saying, he can’t hear him. The grandstand is enclosed by glass.

That doesn’t stop the trainer.

“Dig in,” Kaplan exclaims, encouraging his horse, Preponderate, in the final strides.

But it does no good. Preponderate loses by a neck.

What few fans there are discard their losing tickets and turn the page in the program to do their homework on the next race.

These are the dog days of horse racing in South Florida and, for the first time ever, Calder isn’t the only game in town.

About eight miles due east, Gulfstream Park is also running.

And based on the early returns, winning the battle for fans and their money.

Even though the two tracks carded eight-race programs of equal quality Sunday, more than twice as much money was wagered on Gulfstream’s races ($2.1 million) than on Calder’s (about $973,000).

Long content with being a “winter” track, Gulfstream, for the first time since its opening in 1939, is racing in the summer on a weekends-only basis.

Most of the summer horse population in South Florida is stabled at Calder.

To entice Calder’s horsemen, Gulfstream is dangling a bigger carrot in the form of higher purses. On Sunday, Gulfstream paid out $167,000 in purses compared with the $116,000 in purses offered at Calder.

Calder has countered by restricting many of its horses from racing at Gulfstream. The potential penalty: A Calder horse that races at Gulfstream might not be allowed back on the grounds.

As a result, some trainers are moving their stables from Calder to Gulfstream, which has no such restriction. Hundreds of horses have already made the move, and more are expected to do so.

Trainers say they are caught in the middle.

“There just aren’t enough horses to support head-to-head competition,” Kaplan said. “I can’t see them going all summer running head to head. I don’t think it’s possible.”

Neither track’s racing cards Sunday were what most bettors would consider attractive. Small fields were the norm. Not a single race at either track featured as many as nine horses. A total of only 50 horses raced Sunday at Gulfstream. The number was only marginally better at Calder: 55.

Executives for the tracks are pointing fingers at one another.

Calder vice president John Marshall said the whole mess could have been averted had Gulfstream not acted in “bad faith” during recent negotiations to solve the issue.

Marshall said Calder was willing to condense its meet to 40 racing dates — exactly enough to keep its casino license — until the deal collapsed at the last minute because horsemen weren’t privy to a new purse arrangement.

Gulfstream president Tim Ritvo scoffed at that Sunday.

Ritvo said Gulfstream’s offers to Calder — one to purchase the other track outright and the other to lease its dates — were so lucrative that “we thought they’d be drinking champagne in Kentucky.”

Calder is owned by Louisville-based Churchill Downs.

Ritvo said Gulfstream offered to pay Calder a yearly amount that was more than what the track had been making.

“It was a good deal for them,” Ritvo said. “What it came down to was making them whole. The difference was in their version of making them whole and our version.”

Ritvo said Calder demanded that Gulfstream pay its taxes, insurance and maintenance on the building — demands that Gulfstream refused.

And so the two tracks, once allies in South Florida racing, are at war.

Said Howie Tesher, another longtime trainer, of the two thoroughbred tracks duking it out: “It’s like two drunks standing outside arguing with each other, and they’re both ready to fall down. It’s an embarrassment that this should happen.”

Read more Horse Racing stories from the Miami Herald

  • Fair Grounds cuts purses for 2014-15 season

    A pending lawsuit by a group of quarter horse owners, trainers and jockeys has forced the Fair Grounds Race Course to substantially reduce purses for the upcoming thoroughbred meet, including a 40 percent cut for the Louisiana Derby.

  • Kenzadargent wins Belmont feature

    Kenzadargent, the 2-5 favorite, easily won the $78,400 allowance feature for fillies and mares at Belmont Park on Wednesday.

  • California Chrome returns in 35th PA Derby

    California Chrome, winner of the Kentucky Derby and Preakness, will become the first Run for the Roses champ to start in the $1 million Pennsylvania Derby as he leads a field of eight into Saturday's 1 1/8-mile race at Parx Racing.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category