TRAYVON MARTIN CASE

Prosecutors hammer at inconsistencies in George Zimmerman’s story

 

ebenn@MiamiHerald.com

Prosecutors on Tuesday chipped away at George Zimmerman’s version of what happened the night he fatally shot a Miami Gardens teen.

They called to the witness stand the neighborhood-watch volunteer’s best friend, federal air marshal Mark Osterman, who wrote a book on the case that quoted Zimmerman saying something he never told investigators: that Trayvon Martin, 17, grabbed Zimmerman’s gun as they scuffled on Feb. 26, 2012.

And jurors heard from Dr. Valerie Rao, a former longtime assistant Miami-Dade County medical examiner, who consulted for the state on the case and concluded that Zimmerman’s injuries were “very insignificant.”

Zimmerman, who is charged with second-degree murder and is claiming self-defense, told police that Trayvon repeatedly punched him in the face and “slammed,” “bashed” or “wailed” his head into a concrete sidewalk.

“The injuries are so minor,” Rao testified. “To me, slamming implies great force.”

Tuesday, the seventh day of witness testimony in a case that has drawn national attention and sparked debates on race, brought a fair share of drama in and out of the courtroom.

Prosecutors filed a request that Seminole Circuit Judge Debra Nelson conduct an inquiry into an Instagram photo posted by defense attorney Don West’s daughter last week.

The photo shows West and his daughters holding ice cream cones with the caption: “We beat stupidity celebration cones,” followed by the hashtag #dadkilledit.

In court documents, prosecutors called the posting “inflammatory” and asked for the judge’s help “to ensure that witnesses and court proceeding are treated with respect and not as occasions for inappropriate jokes.”

They said the photo and caption appeared to be referring to the testimony of Rachel Jeantel, 19, of Miami, who spoke with Trayvon on his cell phone moments before he was shot.

The defense team responded by calling the state’s filing “irresponsible,” noting that the photograph was taken and posted before Jeantel’s turn on the witness stand. West, who signed the defense response filed Tuesday, asked Nelson for an inquiry into the state’s filing, fearing it may rekindle threats that he said have been made against his family.

In other sparring that happened outside the presence of jurors, prosecutors argued for the judge to strike part of lead investigator Chris Serino’s testimony from Monday. A previous motion stipulated that investigators in the case would not testify about their opinions, only facts.

Nelson ruled in favor of the state, throwing out Serino’s answer to defense attorney Mark O’Mara’s question about whether Serino believed Zimmerman was being truthful during questioning. Serino had answered yes.

Nelson instructed jurors to disregard the question and answer.

With jurors present, Serino finished the second day of his testimony, with lawyers on both sides vying to get in the last question. Nelson warned them to wrap it up when prosecutor Bernie de la Rionda stood for re-re-re-direct examination.

Serino acknowledged during questioning by de la Rionda that a phrase Zimmerman uttered while on the phone with a police dispatcher — “f-----g punks” — could be construed as profiling, and it did show “ill-will and spite.”

But under cross-examination, Serino said that he found no significant inconsistencies in Zimmerman’s statements to police — testimony that could help the defense. He also said he didn’t find it unusual or cause for concern when Zimmerman remarked that screaming heard on a 911 recording “doesn’t even sound like me.”

Osterman, Zimmerman’s best friend and the person who encouraged him to buy a firearm, testified as a state’s witness, focusing mainly on what Zimmerman told him on the ride back from the Sanford police station early on Feb. 27. That story largely followed the same one Zimmerman had told police.

But it was an excerpt from a book Osterman wrote last year, Defending Our Friend: The Most Hated Man in America, that contained something different than any of Zimmerman’s other statements.

“[Trayvon] took his hand that was covering my nose and went for the gun, saying, ‘You’re gonna die now, motherf-----,’ ” the book quotes Zimmerman as saying. “Somehow, I broke his grip on the gun where the guy grabbed it between the rear sight and the hammer. I got the gun in my hand, raised it toward the guy’s chest and pulled the trigger.”

No DNA from Trayvon was found on the gun, and a latent-fingerprint expert testified on Tuesday that she could not recover any identifiable fingerprints from the weapon.

Prosecutors played for jurors a televised interview Zimmerman did with Sean Hannity last year.

In it, Zimmerman responds to one of the interviewer’s questions about Florida’s Stand Your Ground law by saying he’d never heard of it until after the shooting. That may come into question on Wednesday as prosecutors seek to present evidence about Zimmerman’s criminal-justice studies and interest in law enforcement.

Zimmerman also mentioned several times during the Hannity interview that Trayvon broke his nose. Whether his nose was actually broken was a point of contention during testimony last week from Zimmerman’s primary-care provider and others who saw his injuries.

The trial will continue Wednesday in a fifth-floor courtroom in Seminole County. A six-person, all-female jury will decide Zimmerman’s fate. He faces up to life in prison if convicted as charged.

Read more Zimmerman Case stories from the Miami Herald

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category