Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission Meeting

Anglers split on plan to ban gear


Commissioners voted to move forward with a measure to ban a popular gear used to catch tarpon, drawing praise and condemnation.


Tarpon, bonefish, and snook were the stars of a long and contentious meeting of the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission on Wednesday.

Basically, commissioners adopted increased protections for tarpon and bonefish and eased up on snook restrictions.

After listening to nearly four hours of emotional testimony from scores of speakers, commissioners voted 4-3 to move ahead with a controversial proposal that would effectively ban a popular type of tournament fishing gear used to catch and release tarpon in southwest Florida’s Boca Grande Pass.

If the rule receives final approval in September, competitors in the Professional Tarpon Tournament Series — as well as other anglers — would be prohibited from using jigs attached to the bottom of circle hooks for targeting tarpon in the Pass.

FWC staffers recommended the rule change after finding evidence the gear snags tarpon instead of enticing them to bite — a position enthusiastically backed by live bait anglers who have been feuding with jig fishers for more than a decade. That feud has degenerated into name calling and threats, both in person and on social media.

Scores of anglers on both sides of the controversy implored commissioners to side with them.

Jiggers defended their favorite gear, insisting it hooks most tarpon in the jaw — not elsewhere on the body — and does not have a negative impact on tarpon stocks. Live baiters claimed the onslaught of jig fishers during the tarpon’s pre-spawning aggregation in the Pass during spring and summer hampers reproduction and changes their movement patterns.

“There are maybe 20,000 fish packed in a football field-sized area,” said tarpon angler Rick Hirsch. “Tarpon are bonked on the head by jigs and snagged by jigs. It has negatively impacted the fishing for the entire southwest region. It disrupts the tarpon to such an extent they no longer return to Boca Grande Pass.”

Countered captain Dave Markett: “We entice a fish to bite for a variety of reasons. Lures, by their nature, entice a fish to take it and sometimes they don’t get it just right. The overwhelming majority of fish have been caught in the corner of the mouth. It sets a precedent for other people with other agendas that you eliminate a piece of gear with no scientific evidence that it snags fish.”

An attorney representing the PTTS threatened legal action if commissioners went ahead with the gear ban, but they voted to proceed to a final public hearing in September.

Said chairman Kenneth Wright: “As a legal matter, we don’t have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt with scientific certainty that it’s snagging fish. We’d be studying this to death. I think we have compelling evidence of the need for the rule.”

In a separate and final rule to take effect Sept. 1, commissioners voted unanimously to place even more restrictions on tarpon. The species was designated catch-and-release only — except for harvest of one per person per year with a tag to pursue an IGFA or state record. Large tarpon would have to be kept in the water for measurements and photos, and the new regulations would extend into federal waters. In the same rule, bonefish also became catch-and-release-only and an exemption to transport them to tournament weigh-in stations was eliminated.

For snook, commissioners voted unanimously to reopen the fishery in the Gulf, Keys and Everglades National Park on Sept. 1 following a three-year closure stemming from a massive cold kill in early 2010.

Commission staffers said west coast snook have largely recovered, and that juveniles harmed the most by the deep freeze, along with large spawners, will receive continuing protection through tight bag and slot limits implemented six years ago.

Wright said commissioners had pledged to anglers a year ago that they would re-open the harvest if the numbers supported it.

“We made a deliberate effort to be conservative and it looks like it paid off,” Wright said.

Commissioners also declared a permanent open season for divers spearing lionfish — an exotic, venomous predator from the Indo-Pacific. The new rule waives the requirement for a recreational fishing license to take lionfish with pole spears and similar devices. There is no size or bag limit.

Read more Outdoors stories from the Miami Herald

 <span class="cutline_leadin">A helping hand: </span>South Florida Congressman Joe Garcia helps Lloyd Louis, 9, cast his bait at the Rickenbacker Causeway during a recent outing with the Mahogany Youth Corporation.


    Youth group teaches life lessons through fishing

    Mahogany Youth Corporation steers inner-city youngsters away from crime and drugs by introducing them to fishing.

  • Notebook

    Snook harvest season begins Monday

    Besides being Labor Day, Monday marks the opening of snook harvest season throughout Florida, following the summer spawning closure.

  • Fishing report

    Captain Glyn Austin of Going Coastal Fishing Charters out of Sebastian reported that catch-and-release fishing for snook with live baits and artificial lures day and night has been outstanding in and around the Sebastian Inlet all the way north to the Patrick Air Force Base. Redfish and a few permits are biting in the Sebastian Inlet and are being caught on small blue crabs. Along the beaches, tarpon, bonito, jacks and sharks can be targeted all the way to Port Canaveral. These fish have been feeding along the big baitfish schools. Offshore reef fishing has been good for cobias and mangrove snappers up to 12 pounds.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category