Military will look into whether judge’s comments meant tainted trials

 

McClatchy Washington Bureau

A former Marine Corps judge who allegedly called those accused of sexual assault “scumbags” who deserve to be “crushed” is at the center of a widening inquiry into the impartiality of his court-martial rulings.

Convictions or sentences in at least 10 trials in South Carolina and other states face challenge because of the incendiary comments attributed to Marine Lt. Col. Robert G. Palmer. As lawmakers urge more aggressive actions against military sexual assault, military officials are convening an unusual hearing to discover what Palmer said and whether it tainted military justice.

What happens next matters to men such as Richard T. Pearce, a former chief warrant officer based at one time in Beaufort, S.C. Pearce, like other convicted Marines now challenging Palmer’s actions, says the judge’s alleged statements revealed a prejudice against defendants.

The impending hearing will uncover more details, but at least one case has already been turned upside down. On Thursday, citing questions about Palmer’s impartiality, the U.S. Navy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals ordered a new sentence for a former lance corporal, Ian C. Bremer, who was convicted last year at Parris Island, S.C., on drug charges.

“On this extraordinary record, the military judge’s comments cannot be deemed harmless,” the appeals court wrote. “His actions undermine public confidence in the military justice system.”

Palmer, an Iraq War veteran who’s been praised by some of his fellow officers, is now stationed at the Marine Corps Recruit Depot at Parris Island, though he’s no longer serving as a judge. He declined to comment Friday, citing the ongoing nature of the cases in question.

More broadly, the Palmer cases illustrate the complications that can ensue when top military and political leaders try to stiffen an organization’s resolve. Sometimes, judges and attorneys warn, a rallying cry can go too far.

“You wonder whether the judge’s alleged comments are indicative of the broader impact of the internal and external pressures to convict and punish accused military members at all costs,” defense attorney Richard Stevens said Friday.

At the very least, the legal conflict underscores how words may be intended one way but interpreted in another. Palmer, for instance, was quoted by a junior Marine Corps officer as urging dogged prosecution of child pornography defendants; the impact, though, was ambiguous.

“If . . . he gets off because of your incompetence, you will go to hell,” Palmer said, according to the junior officer, who added that “I think he was trying to be humorous with this comment because he chuckled when he said it.”

The junior officer is not identified in court records.

The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces has ordered a fact-finding hearing before June 23 at the Marine Corps base in Quantico, Va. Though it could be applied in other cases eventually as well, the hearing was convened for an appeal by former Marine Staff Sgt. Dustin D. Kish. Kish was a recruiter in upstate New York in 2009, originally charged with having a relationship with a prospective female recruit. Palmer was the court-martial judge.

Kish initially challenged Palmer’s actions during the court-martial. The Navy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals rejected his claims last year, declaring that “we find no evidence from which a reasonable person would doubt the court-martial’s legality, fairness or impartiality.”

Kish followed up with allegations that Palmer’s statements during a June 2012 legal training session showed bias. These will be the focus of the upcoming post-trial fact-finding hearing, which military law experts call unusual for its attention to a miliary judge’s actions.

On June 21, 2012, Palmer was delivering a professional military education talk to five junior Marine Corps officers. Two officers subsequently filed statements about what he said.

“He encouraged the junior officers to aggressively charge and prosecute cases, stating that Congress and the commandant of the Marine Corps wanted more convictions, and opined that trial counsel should assume the defendant is guilty,” the Navy-Marine Corps Court of Criminal Appeals summed up in a decision last November.

The Navy and Marine Corps appellate court, though, until now has generally declined to second-guess Palmer’s decision-making. For instance, the appellate court last November upheld the conviction of Pearce, the former chief warrant officer accused of fraternization and other charges, in a court-martial overseen by Palmer.

“We do not countenance the comments made by the military judge, however, we are convinced that (Pearce’s) court-martial was a fair and impartial proceeding,” the appellate court said.

The same court took a different tack Thursday in ordering a new sentence for Bremer, the former lance corporal and weapons specialist who judges say was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder. The Bremer case differs from the others, in part because the June 2012 trial involved Palmer’s aggressive attempt to defend his judicial reputation once questions arose about his statements.

Palmer’s actions, the appellate court concluded Thursday, “would lead a reasonable person to question whether he lost his fairness and impartiality and became primarily focused on protecting himself.”

The fact-finding hearing in the Kish case is supposed to be finished by late June, after which appellate judges will decide the next step for Kish and, in time, the other convicted Marines who want another chance.

Email: mdoyle@mcclatchydc.com; Twitter: @MichaelDoyle10

Read more Politics Wires stories from the Miami Herald

  •  
President Barack Obama visits the Dutch Embassy in Washington to sign a book of condolence, joined by Deputy Chief of Mission Peter Mollema, Tuesday, July 22, 2014. Most of the 298 people aboard the Malaysia Airlines plane that was shot down near the border between Ukraine and Russia were Dutch citizens.

    Obama pledges justice in visit to Dutch embassy

    President Barack Obama says Americans were heartbroken by the loss of so many citizens of the Netherlands in the downed Malaysia Airlines flight that was shot down in Ukraine.

  •  
In this July 12, 2014, photo, Central American migrants ride a freight train during their journey toward the U.S.-Mexico border in Ixtepec, Mexico.   The last time so few people were arrested at the country’s borders was 1973, when the Border Patrol recorded just fewer than 500,000 arrests. And the volume of people being arrested at the border remains dramatically lower than the all-time high of more than 1.6 people in 2000.

    Despite crush of children, illegal immigration low

    Border Patrol agents stationed in South Texas are the busiest in the country, arresting tens of thousands of children illegally crossing the border without their parents and thousands more families with children.

  • US to present intelligence data on plane crash

    The United States says it's preparing to present data from the U.S. intelligence community laying out what's known about the Malaysian Airlines plane that was shot down in Ukraine.

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category