History

Revisiting the past

 

T.D. Allman takes issue with some of the myths in Florida’s history

Meet the author

Who: T.D. Allman

When: 8 p.m. Tuesday

Where: Books & Books, 265 Aragon Ave., Coral Gables

Information: 305-442-4408 or www.booksandbooks.com


History, they say, is written by the victors, and in his new book author T. D. Allman sets out to resurrect some forgotten heroes while poking holes in much of the state’s accepted history as written by some of the white supremacists and tourist trap operators. The book is interesting and infuriating, sometimes shrill and tedious. Some of the myths of Florida’s accepted history clearly bother Allman so much that he can’t help but repeatedly look back to his version.

Many of the myths are well-known: Ponce de Leon wasn’t looking for a fountain of youth and certainly never found one. Julia Tuttle didn’t persuade Henry Flagler to extend his railroad to Miami by sending him an orange blossom after a freeze. Other myths, including much of the Civil War history of the state, are still popularly accepted as fact.

In Finding Florida: The True History of the Sunshine State, Allman’s excavation of those myths and his uncovering of some true Civil War history is intriguing and deserves more attention. Florida’s Civil War “heroes” were not the genteel Southern gentlemen painted by the neo-Confederates who erected monuments and wrote history. Even their supposed valor in battles is a glossed-over account that denies the rightful role of some of the true heroes during that period.

Allman, also author of Miami: City of the Future, devotes a lot of space to the 1816 massacre at Negro Fort, which he argues was a seminal event in the state’s history.

“Understand what happened at Negro Fort, and myriad future events become intelligible,” he writes. “Banish it from mind and memory, and two hundred years of conflict and pain become disconnected, impossible to understand.”

Allman goes back to the contemporaneous reports of the massacre there and shows that at the time the U.S. forces that bombed the fort on the banks of the Apalachicola River readily acknowledged they had killed many women and children, along with the black and Native American men. And though Gen. Andrew Jackson regularly referred to them as escaped American slaves, the contemporary reports note that the blacks there were Spanish speakers and thus were free Spanish citizens. Later histories would claim that the leaders there, one a black man and one a Native American, were sentenced to death because four American sailors “searching for water” were killed in earlier fighting.

“Not even those who killed them ever pretended there was a judicial process,” Allman notes. Instead, the contemporary accounts describe torture but no trial.

Sometimes, however, Allman’s liberal sensibilities are overwhelmed by Florida’s complexity. His portrayal of Miami’s Cuban population during the Elian scandal veers from cartoonish to offensive.

“The prospect of Elian being returned to Cuba profoundly offended the Miami Cuban sense of entitlement,” he writes. “The notion that America owed them whatever they wanted whenever they wanted it, in return for not having rid them of Castro, had been transgressed. At Save Elian rallies Cuban-Americans who owned two houses and four cars recalled the trauma of having to sleep in a garage on a mattress for a few weeks. People who had multimillion-dollar art collections proclaimed they, too, were but orphans of the storm.”

Meanwhile, he canonizes Sen. Claude Pepper as a true Southerner and right-thinking liberal who rose above the racism of his time, only to be defeated by a race-baiting carpetbagger from New Jersey. Allman fails to mention that Pepper joined his southern colleagues in the Senate in a filibuster that successfully blocked a bill to outlaw lynching in 1938. By some accounts, Florida led the nation in lynchings at that point.

Sometimes Allman’s assertions are simply hard to reconcile with reality, as when he described the manned space program as “failing to fulfill any scientific purpose.” Any? At all?

His description of Marjorie Kinnan Rawlings just seems silly. He’s offended that Rawling’s Pulitzer Prize-winning novel The Yearling doesn’t include stories of black Floridians and doesn’t mention the fact that poor whites in Florida were “denied land, opportunity and education because Florida’s political and financial oligarchs grabbed everything for themselves.”

In Allman’s telling, Rawlings’ fortunes take a turn for the worse, and she has to resort to “taking in boarders.” Allman’s suggestion that Rawlings was reduced to changing sheets “with her literary endeavors failing” is itself a glossed-over account that denies reality. Rawlings’ husband was a wealthy hotelier, and though The Yearling was her most successful work, her 1942 nonfiction book Cross Creek was a Book of the Month Club selection, and she was far from destitute or forced to take in boarders.

Allman makes a powerful argument for revisiting Florida’s past, unpeeling the layers of myth wrapped up in biases and prejudice that have been written into the history books. Yet his own political prejudices tend to blur his focus.

Susannah Nesmith is a writer in Miami.

Read more Books stories from the Miami Herald

  •  
 <span class="cutline_leadin">THE BOOK OF LIFE.</span> Deborah Harkness. Viking. 559 pages. $28.95.

    Fantasy

    Deborah Harkness’ All Souls trilogy comes to a satisfying conclusion

    A witch in love with a vampire comes into her full powers in the final satisfying installment of the All Souls trilogy.

  •  
 <span class="bold">Courtney Maum</span>

    What are you reading now?

    “I’m reading Brando Skyhorse’s Take This Man. Several years ago, I applied for a scholarship at the Can Serrat residency program in Spain and got a letter back saying that the stipend had gone to a writer named Brando Skyhorse. I remember pacing around the house yelling, ‘Who the hell is this Brando Skyhorse?!’ I’ve calmed down in the years since and am glad that the scholarship went to a writer as fearless and funny as Skyhorse. The things his mother put him through as a child could have destroyed a man’s integrity, but Skyhorse saved himself through writing, and in that, he is a role model for me.”

  •  
 <span class="cutline_leadin">A MOST IMPERFECT UNION: </span>A Contrarian History of the United States. Ilan Stavans. Illustrated by Lalo Alcaraz. Basic. 269 pages. $26.99.

    History

    Collaboration takes a more colorful look at U.S. history

    A New England college professor and a California cartoonist collaborate on a colorful look at our storied past.

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category