Landmark Supreme Court voting rights debate will have California impact


McClatchy Newspapers

WASHINGTON A Merced County legal victory has unexpectedly pulled it into one of the biggest Supreme Court cases in years.

The county’s 2012 triumph was to successfully bail out from federal control under the Voting Rights Act. But now some conservative skeptics charge that legal victory was tainted by Justice Department politics. The claims, in turn, compelled the county to invest in a Supreme Court brief to defend itself in advance of a key court argument on Wednesday.

“The county was surprised to become a subject of discussion in the (voting rights) case,” Merced County Counsel James N. Fincher said Friday. “One of the reasons the county chose to pursue the bailout was to avoid being a political football in unrelated legal battles.”

The bailout, or escape, from certain Voting Rights Act obligations means Merced County and some 84 political entities included within it, from school districts to city councils, no longer need Justice Department permission before making voting-related changes. A three-judge panel approved the bailout in August 2012, after the Justice Department assented following a two-year study.

“Assertions that Merced County was not eligible for the bailout are incorrect,” declares the brief, for which the county hired the San Rafael-based firm, Nielsen Merksamer Parrinello Gross & Leoni.

The county’s 49-page brief was one of about 50 so-called amicus briefs filed in the case.

The Voting Rights Act case, called Shelby County v. Holder, has attracted more of such debate than most cases because the stakes are so high. The Alabama county is challenging a key provision in the 1965 voting rights law, which requires approval by Justice before any changes to local voting procedures.

Nine states are covered by the provision in their entirety, and seven states, including California, are covered in part. Merced County fell under the law in 1975 because of a combination of English-only ballots and low 1972 voter turnout that county officials attribute to the large transient military population at the former Castle Air Force Base.

The requirements in Section 5 of the act, referred to as preclearance, cover everything from the purchase of new voting machines to the redrawing of new political boundaries. The law, though, also includes an out. If a covered jurisdiction can show that it hasn’t engaged in discriminatory practices during a 10-year period, it can escape preclearance, just as Merced County and about 190 other jurisdictions have.

“Congress included a structure that has a door that swings both ways,” NAACP Legal Defense and Education Fund President Sherrilyn Ifill said Friday.

Voting Rights Act skeptics counter that the law’s preclearance section is too rigid and dated, and some contend recent bailout approvals were stage-managed to show Supreme Court justices that the law is flexible.

“The Department of Justice now thinks a flurry of bailouts, some of them obtained improperly, will convince the Supreme Court that Section 5 is not much of a burden and should survive,” former Justice Department official J. Christian Adams wrote last December, adding that Merced County was “ineligible for bailout.”

Similar arguments have been made in National Review Online and in legal pleadings, with conservatives specifically criticizing the bailout expert hired by Merced County, attorney J. Gerald Hebert.

The attacks, in turn, prompted Merced County to spell out the bailout details dating back to 2009. These specific efforts ranged from county officials twice flying to Washington, D.C., to numerous interviews with local residents, and a sweeping search to determine past compliance with the preclearance requirements.

“I will not speculate as to the Justice Department’s motivations,” Fincher said, but “Merced County’s bailout was justified on the law and facts.”

Email:; Twitter: @MichaelDoyle10

Read more Politics Wires stories from the Miami Herald

In this undated photo provided by the US Army, Donald Paul Sloat is pictured.   President Obama will bestow the Medal of Honor at theWhite House on Monday.

    Civil War officer's heroism earns Medal of Honor

    After an act of Congress and years of lobbying by descendants and admirers, a Union Army officer who made the ultimate sacrifice more than 150 years ago will be recognized for his heroism when President Barack Obama grants him the nation's highest commendation for battlefield valor.

Brenda Brink, of Huxley, Iowa, looks on before listening to former Sec. of State Hillary Rodham Clinton speak at U.S. Sen. Tom Harkin's annual fundraising Steak Fry, Sunday, Sept. 14, 2014, in Indianola, Iowa.

    Iowa Democrats react to Hillary Rodham Clinton

    Iowa Democrats gave a warm welcome to Hillary Rodham Clinton at retiring Sen. Tom Harkin's annual fundraiser. But not all party loyalists from the early-voting state were ready to hand her the 2016 presidential nomination just yet.

Former Sec. of State Hillary Rodham Clinton, former President Bill Clinton and U.S. Sen. Tom Harkin work the grill during Harkin's annual fundraising Steak Fry, Sunday, Sept. 14, 2014, in Indianola, Iowa.

    Clinton embraces Iowa, Obama in return to state

    Hillary Rodham Clinton's third-place finish in the 2008 Iowa caucuses seemed but a fading memory when the former secretary of state took the stage in front of roughly 10,000 loyal Democrats at outgoing Iowa Sen. Tom Harkin's annual fall fundraiser south of Des Moines.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category