Government regulations and barking dogs

Montreal city councilor Bonoit LaDouce has proposed a new law requiring all dogs in that Canadian city to understand commands in both English and French.

The councilor explained that the law is necessary to counter the “untenable chaos” at public parks when dogs understand commands in only one language. LaDouce’s proposal requires all dogs in the city to learn at least 80 commands in both languages as attested by a city employee who would administer a test to certify the dogs’ bilingual comprehension.

South Florida cities are considering similar legislation requiring all dogs to be trilingual in Spanish, Creole and English commands.

Seriously, the original Montreal story was intended as satirical and went viral on social media before people figured out it was fiction, and I made up the South Florida connection (I think), but the story serves to illustrate the exponential growth of paternalistic regulations at all levels of government. Over the past three years, the Code of Federal Regulations alone has increased by 11,327 pages to over 169,000 pages.

Paternalism embodies the view that other people cannot be trusted to make good decisions impelling government regulators to step in. Curiously, we rarely demand that government make decisions about our lives. It is only other people that cannot make good decisions. Social psychologists label this cognitive bias as an “attribution error,” where we emphasize the internal characteristics of a person in explaining their behavior while under-valuing external situational factors.

Oddly, we take the opposite view when evaluating our own behavior. For example, according to my wife, if I have an automobile accident it is because I am a bad driver (dispositional); if she has an accident it is because it was raining and visibility was poor (situational).

Underlying the motivation for many paternalistic regulations are the twin mythical convictions that most individuals make bad decisions when allowed to think for themselves, and that businessmen, acting out of greed, endanger the gullible public by cutting corners to make an extra buck. Regrettably, political rhetoric turns regulatory policy into a caricature, ignoring its serious ethical concerns; Democrats warn of the wholesale evils of deregulation and Republicans emphasize the job-killing effects of regulations.

There is more to regulations. Regulatory policy imposes the judgment of a small group of regulatory wise men over a process of voluntary exchange that reflects the needs and preferences of the population at large. In a free market economy, every voluntary exchange guides resources to their highest value use. Thus, every regulation that impedes voluntary exchanges reduces the effectiveness of resource use.

Regulatory policy should be viewed with extraordinary suspicion and used frugally.

Effective and appropriate regulations are necessary in a market system and inherent to the rule of law. Unfortunately, most of the regulations promulgated by legislative and administrative bodies do not meet the appropriate and necessary criteria. It is not that lawmakers are evildoers, as most new regulations are advanced with the sincere belief that they are in the public interest. Lawmakers seek to enact regulations to improve safety in consumer products, to assure the efficacy of pharmaceutical drugs, and countless other reasonable goals.

Commerce is a self- interested pursuit that encourages and rewards selfish behavior. It does not follow, however, that business is about harming, or exploiting customers. In a free enterprise system, profits result from creating superior value, not from exploitation. Demonizing the profit motive implies the absurdity that business losses are admirable.

This is not to suggest that regulations are always unnecessary. Policies that seek to protect children and those unable to make reasoned judgments are clearly defensible, but regulations that aspire to protect individuals from themselves undermine the very concepts of personal responsibility.

Accepting responsibility for our own lives is a moral and intellectual achievement. It is a celebration of our individual freedoms. Parodying Don Quixote’s quip to Sancho Panza: Allow the dogs to bark, and in any language.

José Azel is a senior scholar at the Institute for Cuban and Cuban-American Studies, University of Miami and the author of the book, Mañana in Cuba.

Read more Other Views stories from the Miami Herald


    The imperative is to educate our children

    When the two of us were graduated from high school, nobody seemed to be worrying about China or Brazil or India competing with us as an economy or in education. We took for granted that we were the best in the world in education and the economy and had no reason to believe that would ever change. Everyone seemed to be able to get a job — and to do so with not much more than the bare basics of education.


    Learning alongside my daughter, Bela

    My daughter, Bela, who has autism, doesn’t go anywhere without a pair of socks, which is odd because she never wears socks. Rather she carries them around as if they were dolls.


    His words dazzled the world

    Gabriel García Márquez has left us. His was also a death foretold, but no less shocking, because we resist saying farewell to our heroes. And García Márquez, the immense writer, was a superhero of literature.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category