Voters overrule assault on Florida courts



The last few years have been tough on Florida’s court system. While the judicial branch is to be separate but equal to the other two branches of government, its budget is at the whim of the Legislature and its judicial vacancies are filled by the governor.

In the 2010 legislative session, the courts requested nearly $165 million to provide adequate funding for the state’s court system. They received slightly more than $8 million of their request. At the time they had not been authorized any new judges for four years, so their request included 80 new trial court judges.

When Rick Scott was elected governor, one of the first issues he faced was an emergency request by the courts for funding; it was granted. Hoping the worst was behind them, the courts seemed unaware of the onslaught to come.

First the powerful Speaker of the House proposed splitting the Florida Supreme Court. The plan included adding three new justices to the existing seven and splitting those 10 into a civil and criminal division.

Allegations of “court packing” immediately sounded, with the fear that the unpopular, extremely conservative governor would mold the court in his image.

The rationale for the change was to address the backlog of cases in the Supreme Court. However, the numbers painted a different story. The caseloads had actually decreased over the prior 10 years and at the end of 2010, there were only 953 cases pending in the Supreme Court with very little backlog.

The trial courts, on the other hand, had more than 3 million cases filed with a backlog of over 650,000. Their pleas for new judges and more funding fell on relatively deaf ears.

The court-changing effort easily passed the House, but in the Senate several Republican senators prevented it from going forward. In the 2011 legislative session HJR 7111 barely passed after amendments removed the most egregious court-splitting provision.

The next stop: the voters. HJR 7111 would become Amendment 5 on the 2012 ballot. It included three major provisions that granted the Legislature more power over the judicial branch, including Senate confirmation. It also authorized the Legislature to repeal court rules through the passing of a general law and allowed the House to review files of the Judicial Qualifications Commission, which collects information for use in considering possible impeachment.

This legislative power grab would have had a chilling effect on the independence of our state courts. Amendment 5 had three separate ballot summaries and required 60 percent of the vote to revise the state Constitution. An informed electorate, acting as judge and jury, objected to political interference in the judicial branch by soundly defeating the measure with over 63 percent of the vote.

In the past two years there have been numerous court challenges and appeals over legislative and executive branch action. Millions of state tax dollars have been used to defend legislation and executive authority. Millions more were spent to appeal decisions that didn’t go their way.

These challenges may have been the catalyst for the unprecedented political involvement of the Republican Party of Florida on merit retention of Supreme Court justices. Despite claims to the contrary, this action did not originate from the grassroots. The party announced the decision to recommend a “no vote” on retention of the three Supreme Court justices — Fred Lewis, Barbara Pariente, Peggy Quince — who were scheduled to appear on the 2012 ballot.

Some suspected this was a ploy to drain money from tight legislative races while others believed this was a concerted effort to allow the governor to reshape a court that had ruled against him on numerous occasions.

Regardless of the motives, many jumped to the aid of the embattled justices and turned a historically low-key retention vote into an emotionally charged defense of the judicial system.

In the end, the voters handed down the final verdict. Their ruling: Retain all three justices with over 67 percent of the vote.

Perhaps the assault on the court system will end after Florida voters sent a very strong message: Don’t mess with our courts.

Paula Dockery was term-limited as a Republican state senator from Lakeland after 16 years in the Florida Legislature.

© Florida Voices

Read more Other Views stories from the Miami Herald



    Jeff Bauman: All I want is a normal day

    It is a weekend for working around the house. My fiancée, Erin, and I have the baby’s room to paint and some IKEA furniture to assemble. I roll out of bed early — 10:30 — and get into my wheelchair. Erin is already making coffee in the kitchen.



    More lax gun laws coming our way

    In December 1983, Middlesex County, N.J., discontinued a policy that allowed police officers to fire warning shots at fleeing or aggressive suspects. The county was the only one in the state of New Jersey, and one of the last in the country, to permit such firearm discharges, which are considered too potentially dangerous to third parties to allow law officers to use.

 <span class="cutline_leadin">REBELS</span>: Ivan Marquez, left, heads the FARC delegation to the peace talks with the Colombian government in Havana. Jesus Santrich of the FARC stands next to him.


    Myths and realities about the Colombian peace process

    Some opponents of the peace process between the government of Colombia and insurgents have been circulating false versions about the talks underway in Havana and unbelievable myths about its actual scope. We will clarify the main legends right now.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category