Greg Cote: NCAA loses moral high ground in UM investigation

WEB VOTE How do you think the NCAA's investigation of the UM program will eventually conclude?

I would never say this investigation of the University of Miami could not get any more ridiculous, because there is always the chance we will find out that Manti Te’o has been on the NCAA payroll interviewing nonexistent witnesses.

Short of that, though, yes — the NCAA’s probe of UM athletics officially sank Wednesday to a level of absurdity that left you unsure whether to be angry, bewildered or simply howling with laughter.

Investigators are now investigating the investigators who were doing the investigating.

No. Seriously.

I think if you Google the phrase “inmates running the asylum,” up might pop Wednesday’s extraordinary admission by NCAA president Mark Emmert that the investigation into wrongdoing by UM has itself been contaminated by wrongdoing.

You can’t make this stuff up, folks.

UM’s accuser, Nevin Shapiro, is a convicted liar and thief presently serving hard time in a $930 million Ponzi scheme.

Now we learn Miami’s judge and jury, the NCAA has in its two-years-plus investigation engaged in what Emmert admitted was “improper conduct” that he called “grossly inappropriate” and “shocking.”

Suddenly, then, somehow, the university being investigated — the accused – looks like the least guilty of all the parties in this mess, which isn’t easy considering Hurricane athletes were alleged to have been lavished with stripper parties on yachts among years of undetected Shapiro skullduggery.


Call a mistrial.

Reach a settlement.

End this now.

When the NCAA starts cheating to catch cheaters, it has abdicated the moral authority to pass judgment.

I appreciate the transparency in Emmert’s astounding admission and the steps being taken to make sure this doesn’t happen again, but in the short-term, as relates to UM and this investigation, there is sufficient cause to not move forward.

The NCAA circumvented its lack of subpoena powers by improperly hiring Shapiro’s defense attorney, Maria Elena Perez, to depose witnesses and obtain information against UM that would not otherwise have been accessible. It isn’t enough that Emmert says no information improperly obtained will be held against Miami.

This was a corruption of power. The entire case is poisoned.

UM president Donna Shalala was right Wednesday to call herself “frustrated, disappointed and concerned” by the NCAA’s gross ethical breach. Attorneys for both sides should be working to conclude a matter that both sides now surely want behind them fast. Miami lawyers now have some leverage in that discussion.

The integrity of the entire investigation has been compromised by this outrageous misconduct.

The NCAA owes the University of Miami credit for time served, in effect, and a gavel to end this case now with minimal or no further punishment.

Heck, the NCAA owes UM an apology while it’s at it.

Miami already has self-imposed the suspensions of eight involved football players, withdrawn itself from two bowl games and an ACC Championship Game and voluntarily reduced the number of scholarships it will award next month.

That strikes us as enough punishment already served considering the despicable reputation of the accuser and now the damnable actions of the NCAA itself.

And you have to wonder: How much of those self-imposed punishments happened perhaps because Miami got word the NCAA had obtained damning information that it should never have legally had in the first place?

Supposedly the university still will be receiving its official Notice of Allegations.

You know what, though?

There will be nothing among those allegations against Miami — nothing – quite as wrong as what college sports’ governing body has just admitted of itself.

Read more Greg Cote stories from the Miami Herald

Miami Heat's Dwyane Wade signals a big three pointer in the fourth quarter in Game 1 of the Miami Heat's NBA Playoff matchup with the Charlotte Bobcats at AmericanAirlines Arena in Miami on April 20, 2014.

    In My Opinion

    Greg Cote: Miami Heat needs Dwyane Wade of Game 1 to three-peat

    The Heat this season put together videos featuring every player that are shown on the home arena’s giant scoreboard screen during games. The one on Dwyane Wade happened to air Sunday during a timeout in the second half of the playoff victory over Charlotte that opened Miami’s postseason bid for a third consecutive NBA championship.

Miami Heat guard Dwyane Wade, left, and center Chris Bosh watch from the bench during the second half of an NBA basketball game against the Philadelphia 76ers, Wednesday, April 16, 2014 in Miami. The 76ers defeated the Heat 100-87.


    Greg Cote: Dynasty or dismantling for the Miami Heat?

    A Heat playoff run is the annual gift we slowly unwrap together, our two-month emotional thrill ride ever since LeBron James grandly announced he was “taking my talents to South Beach” that summer night in 2010. Well, buckle up again, South Florida. Prepare for exhilarating highs and work-productivity lows. Prepare for late nights walking drained from the downtown bayside arena. Prepare for hearts to soar or plunge on whether a basketball swishes through a nylon net or bonks off a painted rim.

Charlotte Bobcats' Al Jefferson, left, drives past Miami Heat's Shane Battier, right, to dunk during the first half of an NBA basketball game in Charlotte, N.C., Saturday, Jan. 18, 2014.

    In My Opinion

    Miami Heat sweep would challenge rosy outlook by Bobcats’ Al Jefferson

    I think that Charlotte Bobcats center Al Jefferson, not a star in the NBA but a good player, must lead the league in seeing the bright side, in trying to find the best in a bad situation. This talent figures to come in particularly handy in the next week-plus as his hopeless underdogs try to avert being swept in four games by the two-time, defending-champion Heat.

Get your Miami Heat Fan Gear!

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category