Another Westlands Water District issue washes up at Court of Federal Claims


McClatchy Newspapers

Far from California’s San Joaquin Valley, an irrigation drainage problem that once turned deadly continues to confront a crucial but little-known federal court.

Though the U.S. Court of Federal Claims recently dismissed a $1 billion claim brought by the Westlands Water District, the nation’s largest, individual Westlands farmers are proceeding with a separate lawsuit filed in the same court. The legal arguments are different, but the stakes seem equally high.

“This is a constitutional claim, on behalf of individual farmers who are hurting,” Gus B. Bauman, an attorney involved in the case, said Wednesday. “The bottom line is, there has been a war going on in California . . . and the people who are getting hurt are the farmers who relied on government promises.”

Bauman is one of the attorneys for Mendota, Calif.-area farmer Michael Etchegoinberry and three other others who are challenging the government. The farmers hope that in time a judge certifies their case as a class action, which would crank up the pressure.

The farmers argue that the federal Interior Department’s failure to build a promised drainage system effectively rendered their privately owned land useless. They contend that this amounts to a taking, for which the federal government must pay.

The previously unreported lawsuit by the farmers as well as Westlands’ separate legal action, dismissed last week, center on the federal government’s failure to provide a drainage system for the valley’s west side. As a result, used and salty irrigation water accumulates and threatens valuable cropland.

Federal officials once directed the drainage to the Kesterson National Wildlife Refuge in western Merced County. Because the planned drain was never completed the additional 107 miles to the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, the toxic buildup at Kesterson Reservoir poisoned wildlife. At least 1,000 migrating waterfowl died from 1983 to 1985 through exposure to the selenium-tainted Kesterson water, federal officials later estimated.

Farmers, too, have suffered from the lack of irrigation drainage to accompany the delivery of irrigation water provided at subsidized prices. High water tables cause problems, ranging from stunted crops to decreased yields and sterile land.

“The farmers are saying, ‘Enough is enough. Our lands are falling apart. We are substantially being killed here,’ ” Bauman said.

Justice Department attorneys respond that Etchegoinberry and other Westlands farmers filed their lawsuit too late, since they should have known long ago about the drainage problems.

“Since closure of the Kesterson Reservoir in June 1986, no drainage service has been provided by the United States to any landowner in the Westlands Water District,” Justice Department attorney E. Barrett Atwood wrote in a brief. “From that point forward, there can be little doubt that landowners in Westlands knew that damage was occurring, and could continue to occur to their farmlands because they continued to irrigate but did not have drainage.”

Multiple lawsuits going back many years so far have failed to provide a permanent drainage solution for farmers in the 600,000-acre Westlands Water District. The latest lawsuits filed at the court of claims represent a relatively new front in the long-running fight.

Westlands sued last year under the theory that the federal government had breached a contractual obligation to provide drainage service. But in a ruling Jan. 15, Judge Emily C. Hewitt concluded that Westlands “failed to show that drainage service was a bargained-for benefit of any of these contracts” and dismissed the suit.

Though the water district isn’t party to the Etchegoinberry lawsuit, it helps the funding of it through a special fee assessed on farmers whose land has suffered from the lack of drainage.

The next anticipated turning point in the Etchegoinberry case will be a judge’s ruling on the Justice Department’s request to dismiss it.

Email:; Twitter: @MichaelDoyle10

Read more Politics Wires stories from the Miami Herald

FILE - This May, 15, 2014 file photo shows the entrance of the Corcoran Gallery of Art in Washington. A leading Washington philanthropist is presenting an alternate plan to save one of the nation’s oldest museums in court hearings this week over whether to break up the trust from 1869 that established the Corcoran Gallery of Art and later its college.

    Philanthropist calls for saving Corcoran in court

    Wayne Reynolds, a leading Washington philanthropist, laid out an alternative plan in court hearings this week to save one of the nation's oldest museums and its college as a judge considers whether to break up the nearly 150-year-old Corcoran Gallery of Art.

Lois Lerner emails obtained from the House Ways and Means Committee are displayed in Washington, Wednesday, July 30, 2014.  A former IRS official at the heart of the agency's tea party controversial called Republicans "crazies" and more in newly released emails. Lois Lerner used to head the IRS division that handles applications for tax-exempt status. In a series of emails with a colleague in November 2012, Lerner made two disparaging remarks about members of the GOP, including one remark that was profane. Republican Rep. Dave Camp, who chairs the House Ways and Means Committee, released the emails Wednesday as part of his committee's investigation. Camp says the emails show Lerner's disgust with conservatives.

    GOP: Lerner emails show bias against conservatives

    Congressional investigators say this is why they want all of Lois Lerner's emails.

FILE - In this Jan. 8, 2004, file photo, then-Secretary of State Colin Powell speaks at a news conference in Washington at the State Department. A document circulating among White House staff says a Senate report on the CIA's interrogation and detention practices after the 9/11 attacks concludes that the agency initially kept Powell and some U.S. ambassadors in the dark about harsh techniques and secret prisons.

    State Dept: 'No American is proud' of CIA tactics

    The State Department has endorsed the broad conclusions of a harshly critical Senate report on the CIA's interrogation and detention practices after the 9/11 attacks, a report that accuses the agency of brutally treating terror suspects and misleading Congress, according to a White House document.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category