Miami-Dade

MURDER CASES

Use of controversial ‘brain-mapping’ technology stymied in Florida courts

 

‘QEEG’ technology, which can highlight brain damage, helped spare one Dade killer from the death penalty, but 3 other judges have since rejected its use.

dovalle@MiamiHerald.com

Two years ago, a controversial “brain-mapping” technology — allowed into evidence by one Miami-Dade judge — helped spare convicted Kendall murderer Grady Nelson from the death penalty.

But the prospect of widespread use of the technology in criminal court has dimmed as, one by one, Florida judges have refused to allow use of the “QEEG,” which some defense lawyers say explains a propensity for violence by illustrating brain trauma.

The latest South Florida case: a judge declined to allow defense lawyers to present the technology to jurors in a possible death penalty hearing for Dennis Escobar, accused of murdering a Miami cop in 1988.

Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Leon Firtel last month said the way defense experts interpret the brain-mapping technology was “not accepted” by the scientific community.

The decision — along with a similar ruling by another Miami-Dade judge, and one in Charlotte County on Jan. 2 — has vindicated prosecutors who have long maintained that the QEEG, or Quantitative Electroencephalogram, is unreliable.

“I’m hopeful that we can close the door on this chapter of junk science,” Miami-Dade State Katherine Fernández Rundle said. “It’s unnecessary spending of precious dollars needed elsewhere in the courts system.”

Terry Lenamon, who represents the accused Charlotte County killer, says he still believes the QEEG has a future in Florida criminal courts.

“We are at a time that science is moving forward in a way that is inconsistent with old, traditional methods,” said Lenamon, who also represented Grady in 2010.

“The death penalty is final. Keeping relevant information such as the QEEG from jurors will be problematic and costly. If the Florida Supreme Court decides that these judges are mistaken about the use of the QEEG, it will be yet another impediment to the justice system.”

Electroencephalogram tests, known as EEGs, record electrical energy in the brain through sensors attached to the head. The results are displayed as squiggly lines on paper, and the tests have been in use for decades.

In recent years, computers have been used to create the “Quantitative EEG,” known as QEEG, which translates the results into a digital image of a patient’s brain to help analyze brain-wave frequencies. The technology is often used to detect brain damage in stroke and epilepsy patients.

The use of the QEEG has been debated for years within the medical and neurological science communities.

No state criminal court had allowed jurors to consider the QEEG until the case of Grady Nelson, who was convicted of first-degree murder in July 2010. Nelson stabbed his wife 61 times, then raped and stabbed her 11-year-old mentally disabled daughter.

His defense lawyers said the QEEG showed Nelson’s brain damage and explained why he had a propensity for violence and acting impulsively.

After Nelson’s conviction, Judge Jacqueline Hogan Scola ruled that the QEEG’s “methodologies are sound, the techniques are sound, the science is sound.”

“I feel comfortable that the average juror can figure out what they believe and disbelieve, just like any other battle of the experts,” Scola said.

During the penalty phase, a defense doctor presented jurors with a computer slide show replete with colorful graphics of the brain, and explanations of the effects of damage to the frontal lobe. Two months later, jurors split, 6-6, on whether Nelson should be executed — which, by law, meant an automatic life sentence.

Read more Miami-Dade stories from the Miami Herald

  • Friends and Neighbors

    Charity pays for glasses for underprivileged kids

    The Heiken Children’s Vision Program provides free comprehensive eye examination and glasses when prescribed to low-income school children who fail their vision screening and have no insurance or other resources for eye care. The program was started in 1992, and since then, 75,000 children have received exams with 83 percent needing and receiving free eyeglasses.

  •  

High school senior, Nicole Muxo, received a surprise when Miami Heat guard Dwyane Wade arrived at her prom on Friday, May 17.

    A PROM NIGHT TO REMEMBER

    Dwyane Wade surprises Miami teen at prom

    Persistence paid off for an Archbishop Coleman Carroll senior. She asked (and asked) and ultimately received Dwyane Wade as her prom date.

  •  

Det. Eutimio Cepero stands before cameraman from A&E's popular "The First 48" show.

    REALITY TV

    Miami police parts ways with popular “First 48” cable show

    The popular television show has helped solve Miami homicides, but critics say the cameras can be a distraction to investigators and the show seems to focus more on African-American communities.

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Videos

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category