In My Opinion

Greg Cote: Alabama coach Nick Saban is the man we love to hate, but it is time to move on


Alabama and Notre Dame arrived for one of the biggest games in South Florida ever, and the man we love to hate, Nick Saban, is right in the center of it all.

What they are saying

South Floridians who are part of the Public Insight Network, an online community of people who have agreed to share their insights with The Miami Herald, give their opinion on Alabama coach Nick Saban, who is most remembered for leaving the Miami Dolphins in a cloud of controversy:

John Widdowson: He’s a coward. A little weasel. A failure as a pro coach … he couldn’t push the players around as he does in college.

Art Pinto: I knew he was lying the minute the rumors arose [about him leaving the Dolphins for Alabama]. He should be ashamed of being such a two-face liar.

Richard Penders: I felt that I had been lied to many times over!

Matt Cohen: He’s a chump. Outright lied to everyone.

Terence Reisman: [Saban should] Apologize formally in the press prior to Jan. 7 [about lying].

Tony Meinero: I think a lot of fans still haven’t gotten over that [Saban leaving]. It’s a betrayal.

More information

Coming up

Who: Alabama vs. Notre Dame

What: BCS National Championship

When: Monday, 8:30 p.m. (ESPN)

Where: Sun Life Stadium

Nick Saban and his Alabama football team arrived in Miami on Wednesday to play Notre Dame in one of the most anticipated championship games ever in South Florida.

For Dolphin fans, Saban’s return to the scene of his overblown crime is as good an occasion as any to take a fresh look at the man we love to loathe, the man at the center of this much-anticipated title fight.

Water cannons shot arcs of spray over the Delta team planes as they landed. Dolfans, if in charge of the arrival, might have ordered the cannons aimed squarely at a deplaning Saban.

Well, South Florida, it is time to finally bury Nick Satan.

I mean that with benevolence, not malevolence.

It is time we moved past the past, beyond all of his old deceit and our stubborn animus. Past all of the stuff that makes so many of us look at Saban — even now, years later — and still want to conjure feelings so close to hatred and apply that devil’s nickname that fits so neatly.

I say it is time to forgive Saban his clumsy departure from the Dolphins.

Do more than forgive. Appreciate what he has accomplished, what he has become, since he moved on and we felt jilted.

I am being serious with all this, by the way, in case your incredulity gives you doubts.

Two points:

First, Saban, around this time of year as 2006 swung into 2007, made a career decision that was justifiable at the time even though we were too enraged with betrayal to see it.

And that same decision, in hindsight, looks smart bordering on brilliant. Genius.

To say it worked out for him ranks in the understatement category with saying Mark Zuckerberg made a buck or two off Facebook. Saban is favored to win his second consecutive national title and third in four years for Alabama.

A statue of him already has risen in Tuscaloosa, where he is the diminutive coach grown to Brobdingnagian stature.

Second, the way he left Miami wasn’t all that heinous to begin with, come to think of it, and his recent remorse over any hurt feelings seemed pretty genuine.

On Dec. 21, 2006, Saban was finishing up his second season with the Dolphins when Alabama fired Mike Shula and rumors immediately leeched onto Saban. After several days of insistent pestering from the media, Saban at last said, infamously:

“I guess I have to say it. I’m not going to be the Alabama coach.”

Thirteen days later, he was introduced as the Alabama coach.

He was not the first man in major sports to bend or manipulate the truth, to lie outright, to dramatically change his mind or to do some combination of all those things.

I have covered sports, and coaches since newspapers were dropped on lawns by pterodactyls, and I can testify very few coaches will hesitate to look you in the eye and say whatever suits their best interests.

Saban has since said he said what he said simply to shut up the media and erase the distraction from his team’s mind at the time. After the Dolphins season ended and Alabama contacted him, things changed. Things happen.

Besides, Wayne Huizenga, then the Dolphins owner, had hired Saban (from Louisiana State) with the understanding Saban would be free to leave at any time if he found he missed college coaching. To this day Huizenga and Saban maintain a great relationship, even as most Dolfans continue to rather obsessively vilify the man about whom Huizenga — ostensibly the man most betrayed — never felt an ounce of ill will.

Astonishingly, six years later Saban is still being asked about how he left the Dolphins and is still, in effect, asking forgiveness.

“The biggest [regret] was probably not handling the way I left very well. That’s always been a thing with me I’ve never ever really felt good about,” Saban admitted the other day, on 790 The Ticket.

“We all make mistakes. I don’t feel good about it, and I’ll probably never feel good about it.”

That was awfully touchy-feely for Saban, 61, whose public persona is that of a cold, unsmiling man along the taciturn lines of his mentor, Bill Belichick.

I suspect Nick, far from dumb, was being calculating, playing South Florida the way he plays recruits and their moms in living rooms — presenting himself at his best and most likable.

In any case, let’s call a moratorium on the mea culpas and move on. Saban shouldn’t have to continue to explain six years ago any more than we should keep picking at old scabs.

For the record, I think Saban would have been successful here and turned the Dolphins around had he stuck it out. He might still make a good NFL coach some day, if unrelenting rumors have any basis.

In any case it’s his career and life, not ours, and not even the most stubbornly bitter Dolfan could claim Saban’s decision hasn’t been justified.

A win Monday night making it three national championships in four years would give Saban’s Tide the first true dynasty in college football in the BCS era, since 1999, and maybe since Nebraska in the earlier ’90s. Notre Dame’s Frank Leahy in the 1940s was the previous coach to bunch three outright titles within four seasons. And Saban has done this coming out of the mighty Southeastern Conference, remember, the best and deepest league in the sport.

Another championship would be Saban’s fourth in 10 seasons (he won at LSU in 2003), and no coach in more than a half-century has done that, not even ’Bama’s legendary Bear Bryant. Saban will never be Bryant in Tuscaloosa, but he has earned his way into that good company now. Saban already is the only coach in The Associated Press poll era (since 1936) to win national championships at two different schools.

Saban does this with superior recruiting — so superior that eight of his underclassmen have left early for the NFL draft, all first-rounders, four of them top 10 picks, and yet his Tide keeps rolling, the cupboards always fully stocked.

Saban does this with attention to detail, too, and with a blinders-on focus to the task ahead.

He shows his team a video of Michael Jordan talking about making game-winning shots. From that, Saban extrapolates this point, as he said upon arrival Wednesday:

“The only [shot] that matters is the one he’s about to take,” Saban tells his players. “That’s the whole deal. Can you focus on that next shot?”

Saban is good enough that his protégés include current Florida State coach Jimbo Fisher and Florida’s Will Muschamp, both from his staff at LSU.

None less than the great Bobby Bowden calls Saban the coach “as good as anybody there’s ever been.”

Alabama raised Saban’s salary to $5.62 million before this season and extended his contract through 2020. At the announcement the coach said the extension “represents our commitment to the University of Alabama for the rest of our career.”

It is hard to envision he’d ever leave his Tuscaloosa kingdom for another college job, but the NFL rumors don’t quit. He was Cleveland Browns defensive coordinator under Belichick in 1991-94. The two years in Miami indicated an unfulfilled appetite for the pros, perhaps. Well, the Cleveland job just came open. Speculation, anyone?

“I don’t know where all this stuff comes from,” Saban said of the NFL talk. “It’s to the point now that anything you say about this, nobody believes.”

Plenty of Dolfans might snicker at that and say Saban’s past lies have invited that lack of belief in what he says.

Six years is a long time, though.

It is enough time for a coach to stand a few days from minting a dynasty, and putting himself on the path to being judged among the best ever in his sport.

It should also be enough time to move on, Miami — to step back from the petty hate and appreciate something pretty great.

Read more Sports stories from the Miami Herald

Defensive back Corn Elder looks on at University of Miami football practice, Thursday, August 21, 2014.

    UM football

    Miami Hurricanes enjoy surplus of talented cornerbacks

    UM defensive coordinator Mark D’Onofrio has an enviable problem: too many talented cornerbacks and not enough starting spots.

 <span class="cutline_leadin">Trust: </span>Florida State quarterback Jameis Winston, above, says that in his mind, it’s as if his offensive line has five, not four, starters returning, referring to Austin Barron’s experience.


    Austin Barron brings veteran experience to Seminoles’ returning O-line starters

    A few months ago, during Florida State's spring camp, a reporter asked quarterback Jameis Winston just how good it felt to have four starters returning on the offensive line.

Phillies fans show their desire to have Pete Rose inducted into the Baseball Hall of Fame Sunday, July 30, 1995, before the start of the Hall of Fame Inductions in Cooperstown, N.Y.

    In My Opinion

    Greg Cote: It’s time to welcome Pete Rose back to baseball

    Twenty-five years ago this week, Pete Rose was banished for life from baseball, and thus from the red carpet ride he would have taken into the Hall of Fame in Cooperstown, N.Y. Sympathy hasn’t often come his way since, partly because Rose can come off as irascible, unlikable, his own worst enemy — but mostly because he agreed to his ban, with a swipe of a pen trading immortality for indelible notoriety.

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category