What to know to save dough on car rental insurance


Five steps to proper protection

• Contact your insurance company and find out what is covered.

• Contact your credit card issuer(s) to learn what coverage is included with each card.

• Check car rental agency websites for optional insurance package pricing.

• Use your credit card with the best coverage to pay for the rental.

• Inspect the vehicle for damage before you pull off the lot. Make sure the rental representative notes any flaws before you leave.

Special to The Miami Herald

For vacationers renting a car, it’s that deer-in-the-headlights moment. You stroll up to the rental desk and as you complete the paperwork, the agent asks, “Do you want our insurance?” Trust me, this is not the time to ask, “Do I need it?”

Car rental insurance is at best, confusing and, at worst, a waste of your money. Are you covered by personal car insurance? How about a credit card? And if you’re covered, what are you covered for? Here are some tips for navigating the fine print.


Most car rental agencies offer at least two basic products — loss damage waiver and liability. Loss damage waiver protects the renter from all financial responsibilities for theft, vandalism, loss or damage to the car. Fees are based on the cost of the car and range from $9 to $36 a day.

Supplemental Liability Insurance protects you from lawsuits by victims of accidents. If you hit a car and someone is injured, a liability policy kicks in and deals with the claimants on your behalf. Supplemental Liability is a flat fee and ranges from $9 to $13 a day, depending on the car rental agency.

You also may be offered additional insurance options. For instance, Hertz sells personal accident insurance and personal effects coverage. That’s a death benefit for the driver and passengers and also covers limited reimbursement for loss of personal property during rental.

Then there’s the infamous “loss of use.” If a vehicle is damaged while you are renting it, you are on the hook. Basically the agency dings you for every day the car is out of service while it is being repaired, in addition to repair costs.


This may not be the advice you want to hear, but the only way to make an informed decision about car rental insurance is to have the facts before you leave home. That means a few phone calls.

If you have auto insurance, call your agent. It’s likely your personal insurance covers you when you get behind the wheel of a rental car. But policies differ as to the amount of coverage, your deductible and other details, says Michal Brower, State Farm Insurance’s Florida spokesman. “Most auto policies cover rentals with the same type and amount of coverage on your personal vehicle,” she says.

Have your agent explain your policy carefully and in detail. Some policies are considered null and void if you violate the rental agreement — have an unauthorized driver or park the car in a bad part of town.

Even if your insurance pays for actual repairs, few policies cover loss of use and/or “administrative fees,” which rental agencies arbitrarily apply when for processing paperwork or handling other tasks after an accident.

“In most cases you don’t need liability coverage, because personal auto insurance covers you,” explains Henry Godwin, executive vice president at MDW Insurance Group in Coral Gables. Also review your homeowners insurance. It may include some coverage, such as liability or property theft.


Once you have drilled down to the basics of your personal insurance, you need to contact your credit card issuer (you’ll find the customer service number on the back of the card). Visa, MasterCard, American Express and Discover all offer some car rental insurance, but it varies not just from brand to brand but card to card, says Beverly Harzog, an independent credit card expert.

American Express will not cover a car rental of more than 30 days. Visa is usually 15 days. Depending on the card, MasterCard ranges from 15 to 31 days. Some credit cards don’t provide international coverage. For example, Visa excludes Ireland, Israel and Jamaica.

Almost without exception, a credit card provides “secondary” coverage. If you get into an accident or something happens to the rental car, your credit card issuer is going to insist you first run any claims through your personal insurance. Only then will it kick in and pick up the “extras.”

Harzog is a fan of American Express’ Premium Car Rental Protection. It’s available with most AmEx cards. For an additional $24.95 (that’s per rental) you get up to $100,000 of primary coverage for damage or theft of car, up to $100,000 of accidental death or dismemberment coverage and up to $15,000 for excess medical expenses. Your car rental period is extended to 42 days.

The biggest selling point? “Coverage is primary,” says Harzog. “That means if anything happens to your rental car, you don’t have to file a claim with your personal insurance company, pay any deductible or risk having your premiums increase.”

No matter which credit card you have, one thing is paramount. You must use that card when renting to activate the coverage. And, points out Harzog, if you buy the rental insurance, that negates your credit card coverage. So no double dipping.


Back at the car rental counter, that agent is still asking if you want to buy insurance. And the answer is ... probably not.

Brower says the only time to buy at the rental agency is if your policy doesn’t cover rentals, has a high deductible or does not include collision coverage or sufficient comprehensive coverage (which helps pay for loss or damage to a vehicle not caused by a collision, but vandalism, theft, hail or similar).

“Even if you don’t own a car and therefore don’t carry auto insurance, take your time at the rental counter,” advises Brower. “Consider the packages being offered. You may not need the most expensive plan.”

Bottom line: Weigh the pros and cons. Should you rent a car and get into an accident or the car is stolen, the rental agency considers it your fault. If something happens and you opted out of rental insurance, it may reflect on your personal insurance record. And there may be the hassle factor of dealing with paperwork or your credit card company.

But never feel pressured to buy rental car insurance. “It’s optional,” emphasizes Paula Rivera, a spokeswoman for Hertz. “You are not obligated to take any car rental optional package. And no agent should tell you otherwise.”

Have a solid understanding of what you have and you’re on solid ground.

Laura Daily is a consumer travel strategist and executive editor at

Read more Travel stories from the Miami Herald

Miami Herald

Join the

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Marketplace

Today's Circulars

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category