Other Views

SCIENCES VS HUMANITIES

STEM promotes science instruction at the expense of humanities

 
 

MARTINEZ
MARTINEZ

culturaltranslations@yahoo.com

We need more engineers and scientists. That has become the mantra of promoters of STEM (science, technology, engineering, and mathematics) in education. There is nothing wrong with such a rallying cry, except that investment in STEM education usually comes at the expense of HAS (humanities, arts, and social sciences).

There is no arguing that inadequate science and mathematics education threatens the economic competitiveness of the United States.

It is no less true, however, that the neglect and systematic defunding of education in fields such as history, sociology and art history can have even more damaging repercussions. Damages include the creation of an uninformed citizenry and a concomitant erosion of democracy, and of a workforce unable to understand, communicate, and collaborate with people of different cultures in an increasingly diverse America and globalized world.

This, too, threatens America’s economic competitiveness.

The investment in science and technology, the desire for higher mathematical proficiency among school children, and implementation of programs to increase the number of graduating engineers are important goals but they are not a panacea.

Botanists and geneticists have succeeded at developing pest-resistant, high-yielding food crops but they have not been able to eradicate famine — world hunger is actually on the rise.

The so-called defense industry has created futuristic weaponry that can virtually guarantee victory in the battlefields, but its scientists cannot guarantee the preservation of peace once the smoke and stench of war have dissipated.

And likewise, modern medicine and biotechnology have prolonged people’s lives but cannot assure that those who live longer lead fuller and spiritually richer lives.

No! Scientists and their formulas and machines cannot solve the world’s problems!

We also need the knowledge of social and political scientists to help us figure out how to distribute those high-yielding crops in war-torn Africa.

We need the wisdom of historians to win the peace after winning the war or to prevent wars altogether.

And we need poets, painters, musicians, ballet dancers and clergy to nurture the spirit of those who now lead longer and healthier lives.

STEM without flowers is just a bare stem.

Indeed, we need more humanists and social scientists as canaries in the mines, to warn us about looming dangers of an increasingly technocratic, market-driven and authoritarian system.

And we may soon need them to play the role that a few thousand Irish monks played during the Middle Ages, helping to preserve the knowledge and artistic sensitivities of classical Greece and Rome in the face of barbarism.

The systematic neglect of HAS is far more complex than a simple transfer of education funds during tough economic times from those fields to STEM.

It is partially the result of the growing dominance of corporations which, on the one hand, demand highly-trained scientists, managers and technicians, and on the other, benefit from the existence of a vast pool of workers and consumers educated only to the point of basic functionality. Trends in our education system respond to such corporate demands.

Public school education, particularly in poor districts, has suffered from marginalization of the social sciences and the elimination of arts programs.

In many states, Florida among them, governments are neglecting, if not willingly dismantling, humanities and social science programs while expanding STEM fields.

Public schools in affluent districts, exclusive private schools and elite private colleges, while not immune to the increasing dominance of STEM, have successfully preserved holistic curricula with adequate support for the arts, humanities and social sciences.

These disparities between public and private institutions point to a dreadful scenario. One in which those who can afford it will enjoy the luxury of a well-rounded quality education, while those who cannot, will be limited to increasingly narrow vocational and technical opportunities.

Luis Martínez-Fernández is a history professor at the University of Central Florida and trustee of the College Board.

Read more Other Views stories from the Miami Herald

  •  

300 dpi Michael Rice illustration of U.S. Capitol building floating off the so=called fiscal cliff under a compromise parachute. Minneapolis Star-Tribune 2012<p>

krtnational national; krt; krtopinion opinion op-ed; mctillustration illustration; 11000000; 11010000; 11013001; krtdemocrats democrats democrat; krtgovernment government; krtpolitics politics; krtrepublicans republicans republican gop; krtuspolitics; movement; national budget; party; POL; public finances public finance; tax; krtsequestration fiscal cliff sequestration; donkey; elephant; hatchet ax; rice; 2012; krt2012; congress; parachute

    IN MY OPINION

    Glenn Garvin: Congress plots exit from Obamacare coverage

    Congress is not as stupid as you think.

  •  

300 dpi Reuben Munoz illustration of gridlocked freeway; can be used with stories about closure of California's 405 Freeway, also known as the San Diego Freeway. Los Angeles Times/MCT 2011<p>

04000000; 10000000; FIN; krtbusiness business; krtfeatures features; krtlifestyle lifestyle; krtnational national; krtnews; leisure; LIF; krt; 04015003; AUT; krtnamer north america; krttransportation transportation; krtusbusiness; road; u.s. us united states; 10007000; 10007001; commuting commuter commute; FEA; krttravel travel; LEI; traffic; USA; california calif. ca; krtcalifornia; 405; carmageddon; closed; closure; freeway; interstate; locator; los angeles; map; santa monica; repair; san diego; sepulveda pass; weekend; krt mct; 2011; krt2011; mctillustration, munoz; la contributed

    MDX

    MDX tolls keep rising: Let your voice be heard

    As the mayor of Cutler Bay I have had to field many questions from my constituents about the Miami Dade Expressway Authority (MDX). I have to explain to my citizens that this board is appointed by politicians but the members are not elected, and they have full control over five Miami-Dade County roads (State Roads 112,836, 874, 978, and 924).

  •  

Carvalho

    SCHOOL GRADES

    Florida’s grading formula a threat to accountability system

    Miami-Dade County Public Schools’ (M-DCPS) students outperformed the state in cumulative growth in reading and mathematics across all grades tested, according to recently released Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test (FCAT) results. In spite of improved performance, educators across Florida are bracing for lower school grades as the result of numerous accountability changes imposed by Florida over the last two years.

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Videos

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category