Miami-Dade

Miami-Dade Courts

Lawyer’s Facebook photo causes mistrial in Miami-Dade murder case

 

A Hialeah man’s lawyer posted a Facebook photo of the defendant’s leopard-print underwear causing the judge to declare a mistrial.

dovalle@MiamiHerald.com

A Miami-Dade judge declared a mistrial in a murder case Wednesday after a defense lawyer posted a photo of her client’s leopard-print underwear on Facebook.

The defendant: Fermin Recalde, accused of stabbing his girlfriend to death in Hialeah in 2010.

Recalde’s family brought him a bag of fresh clothes to wear during trial. When Miami-Dade corrections officers lifted up the pieces for a routine inspection, Recalde’s public defender Anya Cintron Stern snapped a photo of Recalde’s briefs with her cellphone, witnesses said.

While on a break, the 31-year-old lawyer posted the photo on her personal Facebook page with a caption suggesting the client’s family believed the underwear was “proper attire for trial.”

Although her Facebook page is private and can only be viewed by her friends, somebody who saw the posting notified Miami-Dade Judge Leon Firtel, who declared a mistrial.

And Cintron Stern was immediately fired, according to Miami-Dade Public Defender Carlos Martinez, whose office represents clients who cannot afford a private attorney.

Clients are entitled to lawyers’ loyalty and respect, Martinez said.

“When a lawyer broadcasts disparaging and humiliating words and pictures, it undermines the basic client relationship and it gives the appearance that he is not receiving a fair trial.”

Also of concern to her superiors: an earlier post on her Facebook that appeared to call into question the client’s innocence.

Cintron Stern, a lawyer since 2008, could not be reached for comment.

The decision for a mistrial came after Recalde had sought, unsuccessfully, several times to fire his lawyers.

“In light of what took place in court, where the defendant was present and requested once again that his attorney be replaced, and considering the totality of the circumstances, the court granted that motion and also granted a motion for mistrial,” according to court spokeswoman Eunice Sigler.

This isn’t the first time the rapid rise of social media has vexed the criminal justice system – though problems at trial usually surface with jurors.

Judges across the country now routinely warn jurors about using the Internet, Facebook and Twitter during trials.

In April, the Miami-Dade Public Defender’s Office sought to overturn an armed robbery conviction after the jury foreman, Miami filmmaker Billy Corben, tweeted about his jury experience, although nothing directly about the case.

A judge declined to toss the conviction.

In 201l, the Arkansas Supreme Court threw out a man’s murder conviction and death sentence in 2011 after one juror repeatedly tweeted during the trial.

In September 2010, an appeals court threw out a manslaughter conviction of a Palm Beach County man after a juror used an iPhone to look up the definition of “prudent.”

In 2006, defense lawyers in an aggravated assault case against a pro football player sought to have a judge boot a prosecutor after he posted on his MySpace.com page links to news stories about the case. The defense claimed the prosecutor was trying to further his side gig as a South Beach DJ. He voluntarily stepped off the case.

Cintron Stern exhibited “shockingly poor judgment,” said Tamara Rice Lave, a University of Miami law professor who specializes in criminal procedure.

In today’s digital age, attorneys must recognize that their social media posts, even if meant to be private, can be damaging to their career, she said.

“But once it’s documented, everything is different. Once you’re a lawyer, your integrity and reputation are everything.”

As for Recalde, he is accused of fatally stabbing his ex-girlfriend, Dora Rial, during a jealous outburst. Rial, who worked at a Hialeah Hair Cuttery, had filed for an injunction for protection against an unemployed Recalde.

Rial’s teenage daughter was home when her mother was killed. The girl, now 16, testified Tuesday and now must testify again at a future trial.

Recalde, facing life in prison, was represented by Brian Kirlew and Cintron Stern, both assistant public defenders.

A new trial date, with a new lawyer, has yet to be set.

Read more Miami-Dade stories from the Miami Herald

  • Columnist

    Church baseball league’s longtime leader retires

    Seventeen years ago, Bob Haworth, a member of Grace Lutheran Church in Miami Springs, organized a coed softball league. And for all of those years, Haworth has served as the commissioner. Comes this summer, the good commissioner will move to Winter Haven, where his wife Diane, has started a new career.

  • In my opinion

    Daniel Shoer Roth: Hialeah ‘boletera’ a political scapegoat in ballot scandal

    Since the eruption of the electoral fraud volcano last summer, Hialeah ballot broker Deisy Pentón de Cabrera has been depicted by the authorities and the media as Snow White’s Queen Grimhilde transformed into a witch. Her basket hides not only a poisoned apple, but a complete harvest that, with the scandal’s shooting lava, has become rotten applesauce.

  •  

This 1972 Miami Herald photo shows Mike Burke, founder of Windjammer Barefoot Cruises.

    DEATHS

    Capt. Mike Burke, Windjammer founder, dies at 89

    Capt. Michael Burke sailed through life with his unending spirit and romantic outlook, touching the lives of many with his cruise empire, Windjammer Barefoot Cruises.

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Videos

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category