Florida

Higher premiums for customers, lavish spending for Citizens executives

 

Citizens Property Insurance executives spent lavishly on themselves even as they pleaded poverty and raised rates by unprecedented amounts to its 1.4 million customers, a Herald/Time investigation has found.

More information

A MONTH’S ITINERARY

Sharon Binnun, chief financial officer of state-run Citizens Property

Insurance, has spent at least $35,000 on travel this year including

$14,266 in April:

April 1-4 — In London to meet with reinsurance companies.

Bill: $3,634

Includes two nights at the Dukes hotel, a $235 dinner for three and

$502 for an airport car service.

April 10 — In New York to meet with potential investors.

Bill: $514

One night at the Ritz-Carlton Battery Park.

April 12 — In Switzerland and London to meet with investors.

Bill: At least $540

Includes $236 for the six-hour “day use’’ of a room at the Storchen,

Zurich’s No. 1 rated hotel, and $304 for the Grange City Hotel in

London.

April 13 — Flies to Bermuda to meet with investors.

Bill: $6,066

Airfare for the entire trip, from Tallahassee to New York, Zurich,

London and Bermuda.

April 13-15 — Three days in Bermuda.

Bill: $2,230

Includes a $559-a-night room at the Fairmont Hamilton Princess with

“gold’’ upgrade for breakfast, Internet and use of the office center.

April 24-26 — In Tampa for a Citizens board meeting.

Bill: $895

Airfare from Tallahassee.

April 29 — Buys a plane ticket for upcoming JP Morgan conference in Miami.

Bill: $387


Herald/Times Staff Writers

$633 “Gold’’ room

In its examination of Citizens’ travel costs, the Herald/Times reviewed expense records for the seven highest-paid current and past executives authorized to carry credit cards. The top spender: Binnun, Citizens’ chief financial officer.

From January 2011 to June, Binnun spent at least $70,000, while traveling. She checked into expensive hotels, including three in Manhattan this year — the New York Palace, Ritz-Carlton and Trump Soho — that cost, respectively, $549 a night, $539 a night and $356 a night.

In April, Binnun flew to Bermuda to meet with potential investors for Citizens bonds, which the company issues to lessen its risks. At the Fairmont Hamilton Princess, she upgraded her $459-a-night deluxe room by another $100 to “gold” status, bringing the cost, with taxes, to $633 per night.

The upgrade included Internet service, use of the office center and breakfast, though Binnun billed Citizens for several other meals.

Binnun arrived in Bermuda on a Friday and stayed in the waterfront room all weekend even though the only business duties on her official itinerary came on Monday. After a 9:30 a.m. meeting and lunch, she left Bermuda with a $2,031 bill for the hotel alone. Although Citizens’ travel policy recommends written approval for all weekend travel expenses, Binnun did not seek permission for a weekend stay.

The trip — Binnun’s second to Bermuda in as many months — was part of an international swing in which she traveled to New York, Zurich and to London, twice, to meet with reinsurance companies.

The total cost for the trips, including two nights at London’s elegant Dukes Hotel: More than $10,000.

Ashburn, the Citizens spokeswoman, said Citizens tries to get the best rates on hotels convenient to where executives need to be. But, she said, accommodations can be tough to find in certain places, including Bermuda in the spring when U.S. insurance executives converge on the island to buy reinsurance for the upcoming storm season.

Binnun, whose annual salary is $224,000, had no apologies for her travel costs.

“The value of these trips, I think, speak for themselves,” she said. “You saw the agendas… It wasn’t playtime on those trips, certainly.”

Seeing the state

Even when they were in Florida, Binnun and other Citizens executives ran up hefty travel bills.

That’s partly because the company’s operations are spread among three cities — Jacksonville, Tampa and Tallahassee, where Citizens has its corporate headquarters.

Citizens officials say multiple offices make sense because they have policyholders all over Florida. Moreover, if a Citizens office in one city was knocked out by a hurricane, work could shift to another location.

But in normal times, the far-flung operations mean executives spend much of their time on the road. In their final two years at Citizens, Wallace, the former president, and Paul Palumbo, the former chief underwriter, spent a total of nearly $70,000, mostly for in-state travel.

Almost half of Palumbo’s expenses were for shuttling between his Tallahassee office and Jacksonville.

Wallace, based in Jacksonville, made frequent trips in the other direction, driving his company-issued Acura to meet with staff in Tallahassee.

Susan Taylor Martin can be contacted at susan@tampabay.com. Jeff Harrington can be contacted at jharrington@tampbay.com. Toluse Olorunnipa can be contacted at tolorunnipa@MiamiHerald.com

Read more Florida stories from the Miami Herald

Miami Herald

Join the
Discussion

The Miami Herald is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

The Miami Herald uses Facebook's commenting system. You need to log in with a Facebook account in order to comment. If you have questions about commenting with your Facebook account, click here.

Have a news tip? You can send it anonymously. Click here to send us your tip - or - consider joining the Public Insight Network and become a source for The Miami Herald and el Nuevo Herald.

Hide Comments

This affects comments on all stories.

Cancel OK

  • Videos

  • Quick Job Search

Enter Keyword(s) Enter City Select a State Select a Category